WASHINGTON -- A plan to help the victims of the Amtrak train derailment in Philadelphia will be stuck in limbo for weeks -- maybe months -- as Congress heads to its summer break, leaving open the question of how much money could be available for those who suffered devastating injuries and the families of passengers who were killed.
At issue is a 1997 law that caps the liability in rail accidents at $200 million, an amount that experts say likely will not be enough to cover the damages for the eight people killed and more than 200 injured in the Philadelphia accident.
The Senate moved to address the concern last week, voting to raise the limit to $295 million and making the change retroactive to the May crash. But the House had left for the summer, and the Senate will begin its recess this week, leaving the plan's fate to be decided in the fall, when it is expected to become part of high-stakes negotiations over a sweeping transportation plan.
The proposal comes as dozens of lawsuits detail the pain caused by the wreck.
Bob Hewett was left with fractures to more than 20 ribs, his hip, and his spine, and a collapsed lung. Leonard Knobbs had a fractured back and knee, broken ribs, and bruised lungs.
Eli Kulp was paralyzed below his chest. Robert Gildersleeve was killed, leaving behind his wife and two teenage children.
All have sued Amtrak or plan to sue, and the rail agency has conceded its liability.
But the victims and their lawyers worry that the $200 million ceiling could limit the compensation they receive as they face years of medical care, rehabilitation, lost income, and emotional pain.
Without an increase, there could be agonizing decisions ahead over how much each family gets from a limited pot.
"It is heart-wrenching," said Kenneth Feinberg, the lawyer who has overseen compensation funds for victims and families after 9/11, the Boston Marathon bombing, BP's Deepwater Horizon oil spill, and other incidents.
In Boston, Mr. Feinberg used a tiered system to parcel out $61 million. People who suffered double amputations and families of the four killed got $2.25 million each; those hospitalized for more than 30 days got $950,000; and so on, down to $8,000 for anyone who received emergency outpatient treatment.
But in that case, he was distributing money that had been donated. He said it is rare to have federal caps on the kind of lawsuits stemming from the Amtrak crash.
The liability limit was put in place to shield struggling rail lines from massive claims. Railroads are opposing the plan from Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., and Bill Nelson, D-Fla., to increase the cap.
"These are public agencies. They're operating under limited operating budgets," said Brian Tynan, the top lobbyist for the American Public Transportation Association, which represents passenger railroads.
Rail accidents that cause enough damage to approach the cap are rare, he said. Only one -- the 2008 Chatsworth crash in Southern California -- has exceeded the limit.
The rail group helped fight off efforts to increase the liability ceiling after that incident killed 24 and injured more than 100.
A California state judge found that victims were entitled to $264 million, but he had to cut back the compensation to $200 million.
"What was given to one victim had to be taken from another," the judge, Peter Litchman, wrote in a 2011 ruling.
It's not clear if the Amtrak accident will result in as much owed to victims. More people were hurt in Philadelphia, but more were killed in California.
Thomas Kline, a Philadelphia lawyer who has sued on behalf of several Amtrak Train 188 passengers or their families, called it "manifestly unfair" to "discriminate" against victims hurt in rail crashes, who face limits others do not.
Mr. Hewett, 57, a regional security manager for BASF, called the cap "offensive."
That night, he was texting his wife, Judy, as he rode home from meetings in Washington. They were considering their next vacation: Aruba? The Bahamas?
Suddenly the phone flew from his hands and he was thrown through the car, then out of it, he said.
Mr. Hewett spent the next seven weeks at Hahnemann University Hospital, about five of them in a medically induced coma, according to Judy.
He now has little use of his arms, and eats and drinks through a tube into his stomach, he said, speaking by telephone from a rehabilitation center near his North Jersey home. He only recently began walking "a little," and said he will see a doctor for the rest of his life for a kidney lacerated by his shattered ribs.
Worker compensation has helped, but with a year of physical therapy expected, he worries about paying for college for his 17- and 14-year-old children. And he doesn't know when he'll be capable of taking another family vacation.
"The government is handing out billions of dollars left and right," he said. "They can't do right by the people that rely on Amtrak?"
His lawyer, Robert Mongeluzzi of Philadelphia, plans to file suit this week.
Amtrak has agreed to pay for the initial hospitalizations and 30 days of rehab for people hurt in the crash. But lawyers for the victims say their clients have to worry about long roads ahead.
The proposed liability limit of $295 million reflects inflation since the 1997 law was put in place, according to Senate aides. They said Amtrak has insurance to cover the amount.
The proposal would also set up increases tied to inflation every five years.
Amtrak is "confident" Congress will "carefully consider all the issues in arriving at a result that fairly balances all interests involved," a spokesman wrote in an e-mail.
The plan faces a long slog to becoming law.
It is part of a more than 1,000-page, six-year transportation plan, loaded with enough spending and policy provisions to anger both the right and left -- including Pennsylvania and New Jersey lawmakers who opposed the bill because they said it would weaken a critical rail-safety requirement.
In the House, leaders on key committees were mum last week when asked whether they would increase the liability limit.
The House and Senate are expected to begin talks on a comprehensive transportation plan after their August break. But that measure could itself become entangled in a bigger debate over critical budget deadlines set to hit late this year.
If the limit is not raised, there are several ways the $200 million could be divided. A judge could oversee the process or could appoint a special master such as Mr. Feinberg. A set percentage could be cut from every victim's damages, said Mr. Kline.
Mr. Feinberg predicted that Amtrak would create a tiered system like the one he used in Boston.
When there is a limited amount to give out, he said, "this is what we must do, and it is not just. It is not fair. It is mercy."
It quickly distributes money to people who need it without protracted legal fights, he said. Some will say it's not enough, and some will say others got too much, he acknowledged.
"It is rough justice," Mr. Feinberg said, "but how do you talk about justice when people have been killed or maimed?"




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.