When rescue workers arrived at the site of a Sept. 12, 2008, crash of a passenger rail train in Chatsworth, Calif., they encountered a scene of devastation and despair.
The train, operated by a texting engineer, had run a red light on its route north of downtown Los Angeles and collided with a Union Pacific freight train twice its size, killing 25 and injuring more than 100 passengers.
Bodies and limbs were strewn around the crash site.
It was one of the worst rail disasters in U.S. history, but, like victims of the deadly May 12 Amtrak derailment in Philadelphia, the injured passengers soon learned Congress would limit total damages to $200 million.
That wasn't enough to pay the personal-injury claims in California. And litigation experts expect it won't be enough to satisfy anticipated claims from the Amtrak wreck here, in which eight passengers were killed and 200 injured.
After the California crash, family members and survivors sought to pressure Congress to lift the $200 million liability cap per rail accident but ran into a stone wall. Now, in reaction to the Philadelphia derailment, lawmakers are mounting an effort to raise the cap imposed in 1997 to $500 million.
Read More
In 2011, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Peter D. Lichtman, whose task was to sort through the claims of injured passengers and surviving family members, wrote in court papers the compensation that could be paid under the congressional cap was little more than half what was needed.
He likened the process of deciding who would get how much to the film Sophie's Choice, in which an Auschwitz prisoner is forced by a sadistic camp guard to choose which of her two children should be sent to the gas chamber.
"They never got a fair share," Barbara Kloster, whose son was severely injured in the train crash seven years ago, said in an interview. "Some of them could never go to work again, some lost their lives. It does make you mad. And I stayed mad."
In his written opinion parceling out the damages, Lichtman described a scene of horror.
"Severed limbs were strewn all about and blood was pooled everywhere," he wrote. "The first car had flipped on its side and fire started to erupt."
The National Transportation Safety Board concluded engineer Robert Sanchez, who was killed in the California crash, had been texting while operating the train and failed to notice a stop signal. Sanchez had been warned about cellphone use on the job, and on earlier trips, he had invited several teenage rail buffs to ride with him as he operated the train, according to the NTSB.
Like the May 12 Amtrak derailment, there seemed to be little doubt about the liability of the California rail line. Metrolink, a Los Angeles-area passenger line that operated the train, said within days of the 2008 crash that Sanchez had disregarded a stoplight.
But the federal cap on damages proved to be far more problematic.
Judge Lichtman found during hearings that the $200 million cap on payouts in rail accidents wouldn't come close to compensating families of those who died while providing for full payouts to everyone else.
As a consequence, he said he was forced to engage in "triage," parceling out money to victims most in need.
"This court was forced to do precisely what first responders did on the day of the accident," Lichtman wrote. "It had to categorize the injuries and victims . . . and make awards on the basis of what the future would hold for many of the families and victims."
In some instances, medical bills for severely injured passengers immediately after theCaliforniacrash exceeded $1 million, and, typically, injured passengers were required to reimburse their health insurers or health-care providers out of any damage settlements they received. Many required lifetime medical treatment.
Others, like passenger Jim Paulson, were forced to retire after the crash and had to cope with a drastic decline in income. Paulson, who was 58 at the time of the crash, had worked as a freight train conductor with the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad. He suffered a head injury when he was thrown violently against a bulkhead, and suffered from depression, for which he took medication, and an inability to concentrate, which ended his railroad career.
Paulson told The Inquirer he received $240,000 after attorneys fees and payments to his medical insurer for the cost of his treatment.
"It was absolutely not enough," Paulson said of the total award, adding that he felt bad for the victims of the Philadelphia crash knowing payments to them would be subject to a cap as well and likely would fall short.
"I think about this every day," he said of the California crash. "You get some depression and you take some medication for that and that helps, but your life changes. Something like this, you are a survivor and you start evaluating why are you alive and why were those people killed?"
After that crash, Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D., Calif.) and former House member Elton Gallegly, a Republican, pushed Congress to increase the amount that could be paid to rail accident victims. But opposition proved too great a hurdle then, and the effort never got any traction.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.