“Some may argue Scott was doomed the day he got on this earth.”
That’s what Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie told a courtroom on Thursday during a sentencing hearing for 22-year-old Shaun Scott, who was found guilty of third-degree murder for the 2022 shooting of 18-year-old Maleek Thomas.
Howsie described the Wilkinsburg native’s involvement in criminal activity from a young age. Revealed his mother was incarcerated. Called him the “poster child” for what happens when a child isn’t raised with structure.
Ultimately, though, there is “no excuse” for taking two lives, Howsie said.
Scott was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole for fatally shooting Thomas on June 24, 2022. He was also given three to seven years for a gun charge.
These are to be served consecutively to a sentence Scott is currently serving for first-degree murder in the March 2022 death of 15-year-old Dayvon Vickers, for which he was given 35 years to life in prison.
Read More
First-degree murder convictions in Pennsylvania carry a mandatory life sentence, but such sentences are unconstitutional for individuals who were juveniles at the time the crime was committed. Because Scott was 17 when he killed Dayvon, he was sentenced to 35 to life in that case. Scott was 18 by the time he killed Thomas in 2022.
Third-degree murder convictions for an adult in Pennsylvania usually carry a maximum sentence of up to 40 years in prison — unless the person has a prior conviction for murder or voluntary manslaughter, which in that case would mandate life imprisonment.
Scott’s lawyer, Frank C. Walker II, argued the mandatory life sentence should not be imposed because Thomas’ murder happened before Scott’s imprisonment.
Howsie rejected this argument, given the first conviction happened prior to Thursday’s sentencing.
Camille Baskins, Thomas’ mother, told reporters she was surprised by the outcome of the case.
“I was expecting 20 to 40 [years,]” she said. “He ain’t coming home and it makes me feel really good.”
‘There are no winners’
Howsie’s decision came just one day before what would’ve been Thomas’ 23rd birthday.
Prior to reaching it, the judge heard from Baskins, who described the last four years of sleepless nights, recurring nightmares and crippling anxiety and fear whenever she hears a gunshot.
“The day Maleek died, I died as well,” Baskins, 41, said.
Baskins arrived at the courtroom on Thursday wearing a T-shirt with pictures of her son’s face on it and “Nubbie” — her nickname for him — printed in large letters at the bottom.
She told reporters she wanted Scott to see her son’s face.
Thomas’ younger sister, aunts and high school friend also showed up to the hearing.
“I was 12 years old when my brother was murdered,” A’Lasia Aiken, now 17, wrote in a statement read to the court by Assistant District Attorney Matthew Rabinowitz.
“Every milestone I reach is a reminder he should be here too,” she said.
Scott was also given the opportunity to speak.
He described losing one of his best friends to gun violence prior to the 2022 incident involving Thomas.
“Whether or not they want to believe it, their son is not innocent,” he said standing before the judge.
When pressed repeatedly by Howsie on what that had to do with Thomas, Scott refused to provide a clear answer.
“I’m from the streets,” he said, seeming to insinuate that because his friend had been killed, shooting Maleek was justified. “Call it get back.”
Things then got heated when Baskins returned to the microphone to clarify she knew her son was “not perfect,” but that he graduated high school with honors and was on the right path.
As she spoke, Scott repeatedly made comments out of turn and even raised his voice at Baskins. When reprimanded by deputies, he told them to “shut up.”
Howsie gave him multiple warnings to stop speaking “disrespectfully” before he was eventually escorted out. He was not present to hear his sentence.
The judge said Scott’s behavior was “disappointing” and “made it abundantly clear that he has no remorse.” He also referred to the case as an example of kids getting into “senseless beef” where “there are no winners.”
“I think it’s sad our children are developing a mindset that everyone needs a gun,” Howsie said. “It breaks my heart. Children are dying too young. Parents are burying their children. Children are going to prison.”
“When does it end?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.