To some, it's an unsettling sight -- drivers for the financially struggling Port Authority letting riders board or alight without paying their fares.
"With an authority strapped for cash, how can a large amount of riders get free rides on a daily basis?" asked Matt Ruffalo, a Light Rail Transit rider.
The phenomenon stems from the same staffing problems that caused weekend service outages on the T this month. A shortage of off-board fare collectors has left some station fare booths unstaffed. On crowded trips, drivers are faced with a choice -- wait while dozens of riders line up at the farebox on the train, or throw open all of the doors and let people enter or escape without paying. Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said operators have the discretion to let people board or exit without paying, to avoid long delays.
"Generally, we err on the side of keeping people moving," he said. "There's a loss involved, and it's not that we don't care about it. You're not talking about very much money. It's not the kind of loss people are imagining."
For riders who have monthly and weekly passes, there is no lost revenue, he noted.
The transit agency is addressing the problem as part of a plan to call back about 50 rail and bus operators who were laid off in 2011, he said. In addition, two fare collectors will be called back. Rail operators are used as backups when fare collectors are off, so the callbacks should ease staffing issues for rail trips and fare collection.
Four recalled rail operators began service this week.
When operators of crowded trains insist on collecting fares, people complain about delays. And those complaints outnumber the ones coming from those upset about people not paying, Mr. Ritchie said.
"We hear it both ways," he said.
Riders have reported empty fare collection booths at Potomac, Dormont, Mt. Lebanon and Washington Junction over the past two weeks.
The staffing shortage is a side effect of the financial problems that have the authority planning a record-breaking 35 percent service reduction effective Sept. 2. With the agency seeking concessions in contract talks with its largest union, and the likelihood of hundreds of layoffs when service is cut, many employees are choosing to retire.
The authority is expecting the number of retirements this year to reach 131 by July 1. There were 61 for all of last year and 10 the year before. One rail operator said chronic staffing shortages have caused some to work 15- and 16-hour days.
"They're burned out. They're worn out," said Paul Rumbaugh, who is leaving after 24 years because of the uncertainty facing the transit agency.
He said when he has a crowded train with no off-board collectors, he'll open all the doors and make an announcement asking cash customers to come forward and pay at the farebox, but few do.
"People just bolt. They just go," he said.
Unstaffed fare booths can cause other problems during rush hours, when two-car trains operate. If the driver requires boarding passengers to enter the first car to pay their fares, it can become overcrowded while the rear car remains virtually empty. On outbound trips, riders in the rear car may be trapped on board if the driver opens only the door by the farebox on the front car.
Crowding on buses also costs the agency some fares.
Some riders on the P1 East Busway-All Stops route get free trips when the extra-long articulated buses get overcrowded. Drivers at outbound stops open all three doors rather than have riders in the back squeeze their way forward to the farebox, Mr. Ritchie said.
The staffing problems come at a time of rising ridership. The authority saw a 10 percent increase in riders last month, compared with April 2011 (the month after a 15 percent service reduction). On the T, ridership was up 30 percent, boosted by the debut of the North Shore Connector.
The connector is attracting about 6,000 riders per weekday. "That's a very strong start for the connector," Mr. Ritchie said.
Ridership for the fiscal year, which began in July, is up 2.2 percent, an indication the agency has recovered the lost business that followed the March 2011 service cut.
"I'm sure that gas prices play a role in that," Mr. Ritchie said.
The authority provided 54.4 million rides over the 10-month span.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.