WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. — The parents of a special needs student who was strapped to a backboard in a Williamsport Area High School class have rebutted the claim of the teacher that it was a training exercise.
Page Carol and Nathaniel Woods Jr., in an amended complaint they were permitted to file last week in U.S. Middle District Court, cite this from the state Health Department’s emergency medical services basic life protocols 2023.
“There is no evidence for the ‘standing backboard’ technique of strapping an ambulatory patient to a backboard while standing.
“Ambulatory patients should be eased to a seated position on the stretcher mattress without backboard, then laid back gently while restricting excessive spinal motion.”
Those protocols undermine the contention that it was a training exercise and that if the same series of actions were done in the real world, it would be malpractice, the amended complaint claims.
The teacher, Richard A. Caschera III, in response to the Woods’ suit, claimed he was conducting a training exercise in his May 28 homeland security class when he had their son, identified as N.W., strapped to a backboard just below his neck and then turned it vertically.
The Woods claim their son’s toes were touching the floor, and he had to feign a cough to be released.
They contend that Mr. Caschera strapped N.W. to the backboard as punishment because he perceived he was sleeping in class during a test.
They claim their son, who has significant allergies, put his head on his desk after multiple requests to use the bathroom were denied.
The school district, associate principal Alicia Differ, head principal Justin Ross, and Matthew Fisher, the director of the career and technical education program and Mr. Caschera’s direct supervisor, remain the defendants.
They contend they are entitled to immunity and the suit should be dismissed.
It was nothing more than a live classroom “scenario” conducted in a homeland security class, and no law or constitutional rights were violated, was the defense response to the allegations.
They claim the Woods failed to sufficiently show that Mr. Caschera engaged in outrageous conduct, that N.W. suffered any physical harm, or that he was detained.
The amended complaint removes an assault count and a request for declaratory judgment that N.W.’s constitutional rights were violated.
The backboard incident occurred three weeks after Mr. Caschera was hired as a full-time homeland security and protective services teacher. He held a temporary substitute teaching certificate. The school board accepted his resignation on Aug. 12.
The Woods are seeking unspecified compensatory and punitive damages.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.