HARRISBURG — The House Health Committee has approved legislation that would require many day cares to have carbon monoxide monitors, as well as a bill that would bar medical students from doing intrusive medical exams on unconscious patients without their consent.

House Bill 494 covers child care facilities which are heated by a fossil-fuel burning heater or have a fireplace or an attached garage.

The legislation, sponsored by Rep. Jeanne McNeill, D-Lehigh, comes just months after an incident in Allentown in which more than two dozen people — most of them children — were sickened by carbon monoxide.

Emergency responders went to the Happy Smiles Learning Center on reports of an unconscious child and evacuated the building after a firefighter's CO monitor was triggered.

Advertise with us

The leak was caused by a malfunctioning heating unit and a blocked venting system, investigators said. They noted the building did not have carbon monoxide detectors, according to The Associated Press.

The vote comes almost three weeks after the Department of Human Services announced that it will provide two carbon monoxide detectors to every day care operator in the state.

“Because carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless gas, without detectors it is not possible to detect a leak before people start to feel sick,” DHS Acting Secretary Val Arkoosh said in a statement March 9. “As the state works to update regulations to require this important safety mechanism be in place at our child care centers, this opportunity will help providers increase protections at their facility right away. I urge all providers to take advantage of this opportunity to get new carbon monoxide detectors to safeguard their staff and children in care.”

HB 494 was amended by the committee to require that the state notify all day care operators about the new law, if it becomes law, at least six months before it goes into effect.

“It is alarming that there are no statewide carbon monoxide alarm requirements in place for the facilities that care for children,” Ms. McNeill said in a statement after the vote. “Given the invisible signs of carbon monoxide — headaches, dizziness and nausea — many people experience it without being aware that they are suffering from a leak. This can cause permanent health effects and even death for young kids who may not be able to explain or even understand the source of their discomfort. This is a sensible safety precaution that needs to be implemented.”

Advertise with us

Rep. Paul Schemel, R-Franklin, was one of four lawmakers who voted against the measure.

Mr. Schemel said that one case doesn’t seem to justify adding a new regulation for every other day care operator to follow. He said that day care operators already complain about their struggles making ends meet while trying to keep day care bills low for parents and that adding regulations only adds another burden for them.

Rep. Arvind Venkat, D-McCandless, a physician, said that while he understands the concerns about adding regulations, the nature of carbon monoxide poisoning and the fact that the “neurological effects can be devastating” justifies the requirement.

Unwanted intrusive exams

The Health Committee also approved legislation that would bar medical students from conducting intrusive medical exams on unconscious patients without first gaining explicit consent from the patient.

Advertise with us

Rep. Elizabeth Fiedler, D-Philadelphia, said House Bill 507 was inspired by a complaint from a constituent who reported that she’d been subjected to a pelvic exam while unconscious as part of the training of a medical student.

“Making sure we have highly trained medical professionals is incredibly important, but at the same time, patients should be asked for their consent ahead of time,” Ms. Fiedler said. “We’ve taken great care to ensure that this legislation doesn’t limit how doctors treat patients’ medical concerns; it simply requires explicit consent where medical students are performing intrusive examinations for training purposes.”

Lawmakers on the committee who are also health care professionals lauded the legislation and said that while the practices the bill targets are uncommon, they should be completely banned.

Rep. Tarik Khan, D-Philadelphia, a nurse practitioner, said that having medical students conduct intrusive exams on unconscious patients without their consent “is horrifying.”

Under HB 507, hospitals or medical schools that allow medical students to conduct exams on unconscious patients without obtaining consent would be required to pay the patients $500 for the first offense and $1,000 for the second offense.