Insisting it’s his duty to protect the privacy rights of Pennsylvanians, state Attorney General Josh Shapiro said his office is suing top Senate Republicans in an effort to stop them from subpoenaing the personal information of several million voters.
Mr. Shapiro, in a call with the press on Thursday, said Pennsylvanians have a constitutional right to keep their personal information private, something that’s been upheld by the state Supreme Court.
Using the Senate Intergovernmental Operations Committee, Republicans had voted to subpoena a number of records from the Pennsylvania Department of State as part of an effort to investigate the 2020 presidential election, including the driver’s license and the last four digits of Social Security numbers of nine million registered voters.
“We plan to argue in court that these subpoenas violate those rights without any justifiable legislative purpose,” Mr. Shapiro said.
Republican leaders say the subpoenas are necessary to complete their investigation, which they insist will determine if there were any errors in the electoral system they can correct with legislation.
Mr. Shapiro’s office, on behalf of the commonwealth, its department of state and Acting Secretary Veronica Degraffenreid, is suing the committee, its chairman Cris Dush, R-Jefferson County, and Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman, R-Centre.
Read More
The attorney general, a Democrat, said the GOP’s subpoenas would turn over sensitive data to some “mystery third party company,” while party leaders provide no information on how they’ll keep the data secure.
“All of these actions raise significant privacy risks and we believe clearly violate the law,” Mr. Shapiro said. “What makes our litigation unique is my office has the standing to sue on behalf of Pennsylvanians to protect their privacy rights.”
Republicans haven’t been able to provide much information about who would have access to the subpoenaed information, nor have they selected a third-party vendor to do the investigation. Facing questions from Democrats about why they’d have to verify the identity of voters, Mr. Dush had said it’s “because there have been questions regarding the validity of people who have voted and whether or not they exist.” It’s an investigation, he added — not a response to proven allegations.
Mr. Shapiro, asking the Commonwealth Court to put a stop to the subpoenas and declare them unlawful, directly criticizes the motives of the GOP in his office’s lawsuit, making the case that the Republican leaders haven’t yet provided a “reasonable justification” for the information they’re requesting. The suit says the committee’s concerns about the 2020 general and 2021 primary elections are “based on false, partisan narratives that have been repeatedly disproven.”
Senate Republicans are subpoenaing the information from the Department of State “not to conduct a good-faith investigation or to further secure Pennsylvania’s elections but instead to pursue a disproven narrative designed to undermine faith in the results of Pennsylvania’s 2020 presidential election,” the suit continues.
GOP leaders have countered that their phone lines have been flooded by Pennsylvania residents who are concerned about the integrity of elections, and that it’s their job to look into allegations and restore faith in the system.
Mr. Corman, defending the subpoenas, asked committee members why anyone would be afraid of doing a fact-seeking investigation and said it would accomplish one of two things: either reveal problems that can be addressed by legislation or debunk concerns about the last election.
Praising the election workers for how they ran the two contests, the attorney general’s suit criticizes former President Donald Trump for refusing to accept the outcome of the election, saying that claims of widespread fraud in Pennsylvania and elsewhere are lies that continue to be perpetuated by Republicans.
Mr. Shapiro is taking issue with where the subpoenaed information will go, and wrote in the suit that the defendants conceded it’s possible the vendor will have connections to the “perpetrators of some of the most vicious lies about the 2020 election.” Mr. Dush, the chairman of the committee, had said it would be difficult to ensure that no vendor has a relationship to a candidate, but that the vetting will be based on qualifications and that he won’t “hire political activists to be investigators.”
“Anything is possible, but it’s not where I’m going with this,” Mr. Dush had added.
Mr. Shapiro’s suit marks the second time the GOP has been sued since its decision to subpoena the information last week. Senate Democrats have sued the Republican caucus, arguing that the chamber is not the place to conduct an election contest or to “undertake an audit that will force election officials to violate federal law and invade the privacy of each and every Pennsylvania voter,” according to a release.
On Thursday, top Democrats joined their ideological counterparts from Arizona — where GOP leaders have undertaken a similar investigation into the 2020 election — to denounce the subpoenas. Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, honed in on how little is known about the third-party vendor.
“We simply know nothing about what they're going to do nor do they; they haven't chosen folks,” Mr. Costa said of Republicans, “and they're in the process of vetting, is what we're told. It remains to be seen how that all plays out, so we're going to continue to fight our Republican colleagues on this.”
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @julianrouth





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.