A New York State woman challenging her drunk-driving conviction after being stopped at a Robinson DUI checkpoint in 2013 lost her appeal Tuesday when Pennsylvania’s Superior Court upheld the trial court’s decision.
The opinion could have ramifications for how police departments operate across municipal lines, according to Michael Steven Sherman, the Pittsburgh lawyer who handled Molly Hlubin’s case. He said the court’s ruling effectively takes power out of the hands of elected officials when it comes to policing.
“I believe the decision eliminates the elected officials from the policing process as well as the decision on how to allocate police resources, personnel issues, expenditures regarding the police, liability issues,” Mr. Sherman said Tuesday, just after reviewing the 18-page opinion.
“Unless it’s reversed by the [state] Supreme Court, it is the law of the land.”
Ms. Hlubin, 32, of Buffalo, NY, was stopped Sept. 29, 2013 during a DUI checkpoint on Steubenville Pike in Robinson, which police identified as a problem area following concerts at KeyBank Pavilion (the former Star Lake Amphitheater in Burgettstown).
A task force made up of officers from 15 different jurisdictions operated the checkpoint where Ms. Hlubin was stopped. She told an officer that she had a shot and a beer, according to the opinion. Ms. Hlubin failed elements of three different sobriety field tests, the court said. Police said they smelled alcohol in her vehicle and that her speech was slurred.
A blood test showed that Ms. Hlubin’s blood alcohol content was 0.152, nearly twice the legal limit for driving in Pennsylvania. She was charged with two counts of DUI.
Ms. Hlubin filed a suppression motion, arguing that the checkpoint was unconstitutional, “and that everything that flowed from the illegal stop should be suppressed,” the opinion said.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Flaherty denied the motion and convicted Ms. Hlubin in a May 21, 2015 non-jury trial. She was sentenced to 30 days in jail, probation and fines
Ms. Hlubin appealed, and her punishment was stayed. Her attorney, Mr. Sherman, asked the court to review three issues: whether the police had probable cause to arrest Ms. Hlubin; whether the checkpoint officers were complying with the Municipal Police Jurisdiction Act, which allows police to operate outside of their jurisdictions for certain reasons; and whether the checkpoint was legal in the first place.
The appellate court found that police were fine on the first two issues.
As for the third, Mr. Sherman argued — and the prosecution agreed -—that the DUI checkpoint that caught his client did not comply with something called the Intergovernmental Cooperation Act. That allows local governments to work together after their governing bodies pass ordinances. In this case, the 15 jurisdictions that handled the checkpoint had no formal working agreement approved by their elected officials.
“The Commonwealth wants to take the power away from the governing authorities and give it to the police when it’s convenient,” Mr. Sherman wrote in his brief. “That is the antithesis of how our local government works.”
The court, however, disagreed that the lack of compliance was a fatal flaw.
As a result, Mr. Sherman said, police departments now have license to work together on activities such as DUI checkpoints and multi-jurisdictional drug task forces without formal agreements among their elected officials.
“The effect of the court’s decision is to essentially eliminate municipal boundaries with regard to municipal policing. I fully expect a decision to be used by police to broaden their authority in other areas,” Mr. Sherman said.
Mr. Sherman said he will discuss the opinion with his client before deciding whether to appeal to the state Supreme Court.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg..






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.