In January 1986, newly elected Philadelphia District Attorney Ronald Castille signed off on a request by the head of his homicide unit to pursue the death penalty against an 18-year-old accused of beating a man to death and setting him on fire.

Twenty-six years later, then-Pennsylvania Supreme Court Chief Justice Castille refused to recuse himself from hearing an appeal of the same case alleging prosecutorial misconduct. Instead, Justice Castille remained on the panel that ultimately overturned a lower court finding that granted Terrance Williams a new sentencing hearing. The court found the Philadelphia DA’s office had withheld exculpatory, mitigating evidence from the trial, including that Williams had been sexually abused by his victim, who had a history of sexual offenses.

On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument on the case, and its decision could have a lasting impact on how disqualification of judges is handled, given the current patchwork of rules in place across the country.

In 1986, the prosecutor trying Williams sought permission from her supervisors to seek the death penalty, including in a written memorandum of support that Williams and his co-defendant abducted the victim, forced him into a cemetery, tied him with his clothes, beat him to death with a tire iron and socket wrench and then poured gasoline on the body and set it on fire.

Advertise with us

Then-DA Castille, who had only been in office a couple weeks, placed a handwritten note at the end that read, “Approved to proceed on the death penalty. Ronald J. Castille.”

Williams was found guilty of first-degree murder and robbery and sentenced to death.

He filed a series of unsuccessful appeals, but in March 2012, Williams’ attorneys got new information from his original co-defendant, Marc Draper, including that the DA’s office had written a letter to the state parole board on Draper’s behalf and that prior to trial he had been threatened with the possibility of the death penalty in a separate, unsolved homicide if he did not cooperate.

On Sept. 28, 2012, the Philadelphia Common Pleas Court issued a stay of execution and vacated Williams’ sentence, finding prosecutorial misconduct. The district attorney’s office appealed to the state Supreme Court, and three days later, the defense asked Justice Castille to recuse himself because of his previous involvement. On that same day, Justice Castille denied the request, as well as another for the rest of the court to consider the issue.

Two years later, on Dec. 15, 2014, the state Supreme Court issued a unanimous, 6-0 opinion reversing the common pleas court and reinstating Williams’ death sentence. Justice Castille issued a concurring opinion.

Advertise with us

Williams asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear his case, arguing that his due process rights were violated when Justice Castille refused to step down.

Among the evidence cited linking Justice Castille to the case, the defense noted that when he ran for state Supreme Court in 1993, he touted his 45 death-penalty convictions. Williams was the first one.

On Monday, the justices peppered Williams’ attorney, Stuart B. Lev, with questions about the extent of Castille’s involvement in the underlying decision in 1986 to pursue the death penalty and whether it was enough to require recusal.

“When the issue goes directly towards the conduct of the prosecutions in his office, it implicates the integrity of the office and the reputation of the leadership,” he answered.

But Justice Samuel Alito said, “The problem that is presented by this case … is where this constitutional line is going to be drawn. You want us to … get pretty deeply into the issue of a constitutional recusal policy for judges. So it’s really not enough to just say what happened here was bad.”

Advertise with us

Recusal is necessary, Mr. Lev said, when a “prosecutor has direct personal involvement in a substantial decision in the case, and the issue before the court reflects upon that decision.”

The simple act of a top prosecutor signing off on one of thousands of indictments, he said, would not be enough to warrant recusal, but having “direct personal involvement” is.

Instead of just eliminating Justice Castille’s vote — which could have left the panel at 5-0 — Williams’ attorney wants to have the entire case heard again.

“What do you do with the fact that Chief Justice Castille was not solely responsible for the decision in this case?” asked Justice Alito. “This was a decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.”

Chief Justice John Roberts, too, said that is an important question for him — whether Justice Castille had a dominant role in the panel’s discussion.

Advertise with us

“The problem is we don’t know what happened within the decision-making structure, and we can’t know what happened with the decision-making structure,” Mr. Lev said. “And that’s why the rules should be that — that a defendant should be entitled, anyone should be entitled to a panel of appellate judges where there are no judges with bias.”

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, in questioning the commonwealth’s attorney, said that by most ethical codes, Justice Castille had an obligation to step down.

“Your honor, I think that’s exactly the point, that it’s the ethical codes or statutes that really control for this sort of situation, and that as a constitutional question, this is not the ideal case at all,” answered Ronald Eisenberg, Philadelphia County deputy district attorney.

Instead, as the U.S. Supreme Court previously found, it is the totality of the circumstances that must be reviewed, he said.

“Do you think that the public would find it unusual that someone who makes a decision as to whether to seek the death penalty or not, that the public wouldn’t perceive that as a great probability of actual bias?” Justice Sotomayor asked.

Advertise with us

“I think that this court’s law generally recognizes that judges are human beings, they have prior lives, and that we don’t want to have a situation where the only people who can become judges and sit on cases are people with no prior experiences,” he answered.

Williams’ case — and the death warrant signed by former Gov. Tom Corbett just before he left office — led to Gov. Tom Wolf in February 2015 issuing a temporary reprieve for Williams and a moratorium on the death penalty in Pennsylvania pending the outcome of a report from a bipartisan commission investigating capital punishment.