HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania Supreme Court orders unsealed Tuesday undermine Attorney General Kathleen Kane’s claim — made as she publicly defended herself against criminal charges — that a judge’s order prevents her from disclosing pornographic emails shared through government email accounts.
Ms. Kane told reporters in a 15-minute speech last week that the charges filed against her earlier this month had been engineered by people trying to cover up an exchange of sexually explicit messages at the attorney general’s office before she took office. She said Judge William Carpenter, who oversaw the grand jury that investigated her, was preventing the emails from being made public.
But in orders on Dec. 19, sealed until Tuesday, the Supreme Court quoted Judge Carpenter saying he did not intend to restrict the release of such emails.
“As explained by Judge Carpenter, the protective order ‘is not intended to restrict or impact ‘appropriate public [disclosure]’ of information connected with the possession and/or distribution of possibly pornographic images by members of the [Office of Attorney General],’ ” the orders state.
Ms. Kane was charged this month with perjury, obstruction of justice, official oppression and other offenses. County prosecutors said she orchestrated the disclosure of confidential information in an effort to retaliate against former state prosecutors she believed had embarrassed her in a newspaper story.
In her speech last week, Ms. Kane said the charges against her stemmed from people involved in a chain of pornographic emails who were trying to ensure the messages would not be made public.
Read More
“At each step on this trail of concealment, they have been assisted — wittingly or unwittingly — by judges and prosecutors and, in particular, one Judge William Carpenter, who to this day prevents the complete public dissemination of these emails under a tortured interpretation of our state’s grand jury secrecy laws,” she said at the time.
A press release Tuesday from the state courts said the Supreme Court orders were unsealed “in light of public statements made last week by Attorney General Kane.” The release said the courts were reviewing whether additional documents can be unsealed.
A spokesman for the attorney general’s office said the office continues to believe that disclosing the messages referred to by Ms. Kane could violate the judge’s order.
“Those orders don’t fundamentally change our position in that the protective order issued by Judge Carpenter was broadly written, and release of the emails may have violated other strictures within the protective order,” said spokesman Chuck Ardo. “We are still hopeful that the judge will vacate his order and allow us to release all the material in question.”
But Ms. Kane’s defense attorney said later that the emails can now be released.
“We expect that appropriate public disclosure will occur in connection with the vigorous defense of the criminal charges that have been laid against her,” attorney Gerald Shargel said in a statement. “These images and the emails to which they are attached are essential to demonstrating Attorney General Kane’s innocence and the abject flaws” in the case.
In September 2014, the attorney general’s office revealed that the agency email accounts of several former employees contained images ranging from photographs of nude women to videos of sexual acts. Aides to Ms. Kane said a review of the agency’s handling of the investigation of child sexual abuse by former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky turned up the explicit images.
The aides named eight former employees, some of whom held prominent positions in the administration of Gov. Tom Corbett. After the disclosure, Christopher Abruzzo resigned from his post as secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection, and Glenn Parno resigned as deputy chief counsel of the agency.
Weeks later, the attorney general’s office said that 61 current workers were subject to discipline for having such materials in their emails. The office said during that time human resource policies and union agreements prevented it from identifying current employees found to be involved.
In her remarks last week, Ms. Kane inferred that others yet to be identified were involved, and Mr. Ardo said afterward that “absolutely” that was the case.
“It certainly has the potential to be embarrassing to some well-known and high-profile people,” he said.
Earlier Tuesday, a longtime filer of ethics complaints against public officials requested an investigation of Ms. Kane. Good-government activist Gene Stilp claimed the attorney general had improperly used her office’s personnel and resources for her own criminal defense.
Mr. Stilp took issue with Ms. Kane’s use of the Capitol Media Center for her speech to reporters last week, the presence of her security detail at her arraignment earlier this month and the fact that her official spokesman, Mr. Ardo, has addressed the charges against her.
“The criminal matter may be private, but she remains the attorney general and is entitled to the use of the media center because she holds that elective office,” Mr. Ardo said.
He said her position similarly should allow her to use the security detail, and that she reimbursed the state $325 for using satellite time in the media center.
Mr. Ardo said the emails are a subject within the authority of the attorney general’s office.
Last week, Mr. Stilp sought to have Ms. Kane’s law license revoked through a complaint with the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.
Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com, 1-717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley. Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com, 1-717-787-4254 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.