A spokesman for Attorney General Kathleen Kane said Thursday that her lawyers will file a court motion next week seeking permission to release pornographic and offensive emails that state officials and employees shared on their government computers.
Spokesman Chuck Ardo’s statement came after a Montgomery County judge said he would not act on Ms. Kane’s public appeal on Wednesday for permission to release the emails, which she said she believed are subject to grand jury secrecy laws.
Judge William R. Carpenter, who supervised the grand jury investigation that led to criminal charges against Ms. Kane last week, said in a statement that the attorney general “has not filed with me any petition, pleading, motion or other request for court action. Accordingly, I will take no official action at this time.”
Ms. Kane, who was charged with perjury, obstruction of justice, official oppression and other offenses, said she believes the case against her is rooted in a conspiracy to prevent the release of the emails. She did not identify any of the alleged conspirators but singled out the judge with this remark:
“At each step on this trail of concealment, they have been assisted — wittingly or unwittingly — by judges and prosecutors and in particular, one Judge William Carpenter, who to this day prevents the complete public dissemination of these emails under a tortured interpretation of our state’s grand jury secrecy laws.”
In his statement, Judge Carpenter said in his supervision of the grand jury, “I made no decision based upon politics, gender, anger, bias or prejudice.” He said the emails referenced by Ms. Kane were not part of the evidence in the investigation that led to the charges against her.
Read More
Speaking at a news conference in Harrisburg on Wednesday, Ms. Kane suggested that more people were involved in what some have called Porngate than the 35 officials and employees who have been fired, forced to resign or reprimanded since she disclosed the existence of the emails. She said they had devised a “grand plan” to keep the emails secret by forcing her from office.
Ms. Kane said it was “critical to my defense” that the full truth about the emails comes out, but did not explain how that was relevant to the charges against her.
Commenting on the judge’s refusal to act, Mr. Ardo said “it’s my understanding that the attorney general’s attorneys plan to file a motion seeking to vacate the court order governing these emails sometime next week.” Ms. Kane’s defense lawyer, Ross M. Kramer of New York City, could not be reached.
Ms. Kane revealed last year that her inquiries into former attorney general Tom Corbett’s investigation of child sexual abuse by Jerry Sandusky, a former Penn State University assistant football coach, had uncovered the explicit emails. The revelations led to the suspension and ultimately the resignation of state Supreme Court Justice Seamus McCaffery and the resignations of Chris Abruzzo, state secretary of environmental protection; Glenn Parno, a ranking DEP lawyer; and Randy Feathers, a member of the Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole.
Six employees of the attorney general’s office were fired, two resigned and 23 were reprimanded, Ms. Kane said.
In a speech Wednesday, Ms. Kane, who is accused of leaking secret grand jury information to a Philadelphia Daily News reporter to allegedly embarrass a former state prosecutor, and then lying about it under oath, said only “part of the story” had been told.
“It’s not a story about sting investigations, proposed personal vendettas or press leaks. It is a story that begins with pornography, racial insensitivity and religious bigotry. [It] begins and ends with the circulation of pornographic, racial and religiously offensive emails both within and outside of the Corbett attorney general’s office,” she said.
Mr. Corbett has not commented on the statements.
Ms. Kane, who has possession of the emails, said she feared additional charges if she released them without Judge Carpenter’s permission.
Jon Schmitz: jschmitz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1868. Madison Russ, an intern with the Pennsylvania Legislative Correspondents Association, contributed from Harrisburg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.