UPMC’s name is bound to come up in any debate about taxing nonprofits. But at a public hearing Thursday, the hospital giant’s top lawyer said that even if tax laws were altered, UPMC would be among those with the least to lose.

“If the standards [for tax exemption] were to change tomorrow, we’d adapt,” UPMC’s executive vice president, W. Thomas McGough, said during the hearing, which was convened by state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale. After all, he argued, UPMC provides hundreds of millions of dollars in charitable care every year — enough to satisfy anyone’s standard. And it employs 39 legal and tax experts to count every cent.

By contrast, he said, “a lot of the small nonprofits don’t have the resources to do that.”

How many such nonprofits would need to do so was just one question during the afternoon forum, held in the Allegheny County Courthouse’s Gold Room to discuss state Senate Bill 4.

Advertise with us

The bill proposes amending the state Constitution to give state legislators sole authority to “establish uniform standards [for defining] institutions of purely public charity” that receive tax-exempt status. If passed by the Legislature and approved by voters, the amendment could reverse a state Supreme Court ruling which, in 2012, undermined the Legislature’s previous attempt to define those standards: Act 55 of 1997.

Act 55 was popular with nonprofits, but municipal officials complained that it precluded challenging the tax-exempt status of behemoths such as UPMC, the region’s largest employer. The Supreme Court’s ruling, however, made such challenges seem more feasible: Following that decision, former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl filed a lawsuit challenging UPMC’s own exemptions. The suit later was dropped by Mayor Bill Peduto.

“There is a big difference between the community food bank … and the corporate land bank that continues to take properties off our tax rolls,” argued city Controller Michael Lamb at the hearing. The ability to challenge large institutions in court, he said, gave municipalities such as Pittsburgh leverage in seeking aid from them. By passing the amendment, “You’re taking that away from us.”

Mr. McGough disagreed. Although UPMC and other large nonprofits are negotiating ways to help the city, he said, that “did not happen until after Mayor Ravenstahl’s lawsuit was dismissed.”

A representative for smaller hospitals, meanwhile, said they could use help themselves.

Advertise with us

Patricia Raffaele, a vice president with the Hospital Council of Western Pennsylvania, said that more than one-third of the council’s member hospitals lose money on operations, and costly court fights over tax exemptions would worsen the financial bleeding. “Patients, especially the most vulnerable, may not be able to get access to the care they need,” she said.

“There are things the General Assembly could do right now to remedy the problems you frequently hear about,” countered law professor Nicholas Cafardi of Duquesne University. Legislators don’t need a constitutional amendment to prevent frivolous tax challenges, he argued. They could simply pass a law requiring municipalities to pay a nonprofit’s legal bills if a challenge fails, he said..

Thursday’s hearing was the first of four Mr. DePasquale will hold statewide this month. He plans to issue a report on the amendment’s potential impact and on how state law could be improved even without it.

Such questions need a thorough airing, he said. “The biggest thing is letting the public know this debate is happening.”