Just hours into a new legislative session, state legislators are moving a bill that could give them renewed authority to decide when organizations, including hospitals and other large employers, receive tax exemptions. Officials outside Harrisburg already sound unhappy.
“I think the public will be supportive of this,” said state Sen. John Eichelberger, R-Blair, of Senate Bill 4, which was introduced and referred to the Senate Finance Committee on Tuesday.
The legislature “should not preclude our ability to get larger nonprofits to help pay for local services,” countered Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald.
SB 4 would let voters decide — perhaps as early as spring — whether to amend the constitution to give legislators power to define the criteria for “institutions of purely public charity,” nonprofits entitled to tax exemptions.
The last time the legislature did so was Act 55 of 1997. Critics said the criteria set back then made it nearly impossible to seek revenue from even well-heeled nonprofits.
Those skeptics got a reprieve in 2012, when the state Supreme Court set aside Act 55 in favor of an earlier test, under which exemptions were easier to challenge. The legislature’s proposed amendment, however, would take the matter out of the judiciary’s hands.
Several Finance Committee members are cosponsors of SB 4, and Mr. Eichelberger, who chairs the committee, predicted “a pretty strong vote” in favor of the bill on Thursday.
If the full House and Senate pass the bill by mid-February, the referendum could appear on the May primary ballot. Though such a schedule would be aggressive, “I think it’s possible,” Mr. Eichelberger said.
The amendment process doesn’t require a governor’s signature, but the proposed amendment must pass two legislative sessions before voters can weigh in. The 2013-14 session’s version passed in less than five months, largely with Republican support. “It’s already been debated,” said state Sen. Ryan Aument. R-Lancaster. “And the voters will have the opportunity to weigh in.”
Foes of the bill, including local officials and government workers, are planning a news conference today at the Capitol Rotunda. The bill’s timing is already being cited as a concern.
If the referendum is in May, Mr. Fitzgerald said, “My sense is you would have one side that would have a whole lot of money to run a campaign. One that might not be in communities’ best interest.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.