At 12:53 a.m. March 24, 2014, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane’s top aide sent her an email with a stern warning: Divulging information about a secret criminal investigation could break the law.
Ms. Kane did it anyway, a grand jury found.
And when she was later questioned under oath, Ms. Kane gave a false account — saying the very same aide had endorsed the leak, the panel found.
According to several sources familiar with the grand jury’s work, those findings are at the heart of its call for criminal charges against Ms. Kane.
That late-night email warning is among a range of previously undisclosed information that underpins the grand jury’s decision to recommend the arrest of the state’s highest law enforcement official.
The panel contends that Ms. Kane unlawfully released confidential information to the Philadelphia Daily News in a bid to punish a rival prosecutor. For doing so — and subsequently denying it — the panel recommended that Ms. Kane be charged with perjury, official oppression, obstruction and other crimes.
Read More
Ms. Kane has said she did nothing wrong, and her lawyers say she will not resign if charged.
Lanny Davis, a lawyer and spokesman for Ms. Kane, issued a statement late Thursday denouncing “anonymous sources” and “cowardly leakers” who he said had lied about Ms. Kane to The Inquirer.
“They are attempting to try and convict Kathleen Kane in the media by whispering into a reporter’s ear in the darkness of anonymity and non-accountability,” Mr. Davis said.
Ms. Kane’s lawyers argued before the state Supreme Court on Wednesday that the special prosecutor who led the grand jury had no legal authority to do so and that the case against her should be thrown out.
Her lawyers also have pointed out that Ms. Kane, a suspect in a leak inquiry, has been the target of repeated leaks herself.
The state grand jury, based in Norristown, sent its recommendation of criminal charges against Ms. Kane to Montgomery County District Attorney Risa Vetri Ferman. Unless the high court rules otherwise, Ms. Ferman must decide whether to bring a criminal case.
The grand jury presentment has not been made public.
Some of what the panel found was disclosed in legal documents filed before Wednesday's arguments. Sources familiar with the evidence presented to the grand jury filled in further details.
This story is based on interviews, the recent legal filings, and other official documents.
There is no doubt that the grand jury concluded that Ms. Kane, 48, the first woman and Democrat elected attorney general, was squarely behind the release to the newspaper of confidential documents from a 2009 investigation handled by her Republican predecessors.
The grand jury found that she did so to embarrass Frank Fina, a former top prosecutor in the attorney general's office with whom she had been warring. The panel called her protestations to the contrary false testimony.
The grand jury also concluded that Ms. Kane falsely testified that her top deputy at the time, Adrian R. King Jr., had endorsed sharing the investigative material with the newspaper and had knowingly helped deliver the leaked documents.
Mr. King told jurors that was not true — and his denial was corroborated by the March 24, 2014, email he sent to Ms. Kane before the newspaper story was published.
“I fail to see how we can legally give ... access to any OAG [Office of Attorney General] criminal division file materials," Mr. King wrote.
The email was prompted by Ms. Kane’s request to share grand jury material with a prominent Philadelphia law firm that she had consulted. But the advice from her deputy was unequivocal: investigative material developed by a state grand jury could not be provided to anyone outside the attorney general’s office.
In a public pleading last month, Special Prosecutor Thomas E. Carluccio said Ms. Kane stood alone in her wrongdoing.
To challenge Ms. Kane, the grand jury cited testimony from a wide range of her former or current aides — not only Mr. King but also her first assistant, Bruce Beemer; David Peifer, a top commander of the office's agents; and her grand-juries expert and appeals chief, James Barker.
In his legal brief, Mr. Carluccio wrote, “Kathleen Kane is the only employee of the OAG who was found to have allegedly committed perjury before the grand jury and leaked grand jury information.”
Mr. Carluccio declined to be interviewed, as did Mr. King.
The case that threatens Ms. Kane’s career involves her decision last year to reveal information about a long-dormant investigation of Philadelphia civil rights leader J. Whyatt Mondesire.
The material appeared in a Daily News article published in June of last year. Mr. Mondesire was not charged with a crime and has denied any wrongdoing.
The grand jury found that Ms. Kane, in releasing details of the closed case, was heedless of the possible damage to Mr. Mondesire’s reputation.
The information given to the Daily News included a transcript of a 2014 interview with an agent, Michael Miletto, who had worked on the case five years earlier.
The agent contended that Mr. Fina ignored leads suggesting that Mr. Mondesire was diverting government grants for his personal use. This criticism made its way into the story.
Mr. Fina is a former top state corruption prosecutor who now works for the Philadelphia District Attorney’s office. He has rejected any suggestion that he did not properly pursue leads in the Mondesire case.
Ms. Kane leaked that information, the grand jury found, to retaliate against Mr. Fina. She blamed him for the barrage of criticism she received after The Philadelpia Inquirer revealed last spring that she had declined to prosecute Democratic officials from Philadelphia who were caught on tape accepting cash or jewelry during an undercover sting operation.
The sting was overseen by Mr. Fina, who left the attorney general’s office shortly after Ms. Kane took office in 2013.
The Inquirer broke the news of Ms. Kane’s decision, which had been kept secret under court seal, in an article published March 16, 2014.
In the week after the Inquirer story appeared, the grand jury found, Ms. Kane focused intensely on how Mr. Fina had handled the Mondesire case.
It was during this week that Mr. Peifer, who is in charge of special investigations in the attorney general’s office, was dispatched to interview Mr. Miletto.
Mr. Peifer taped his March 21, 2014, interview as Mr. Miletto said Mr. Fina had not vigorously pursued the Mondesire case, which had grown out of a secret grand jury probe into a former employee of Mr. Mondesire's.
In defending herself in the leak case, Ms. Kane has said that she discussed the Mondesire investigation during a meeting in late March with several of her top staffers, including Mr. King, and that they concluded it was in the public’s best interest to get information out about what had happened.
The grand jury found otherwise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.