PHILADELPHIA — State Attorney General Kathleen Kane said she was “cautiously hopeful” following a hearing before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in which her attorneys claimed a special prosecutor had no authority to bring allegations of wrongdoing by her office before a grand jury.
Wednesday’s hearing was the embattled attorney general’s attempt to derail a case alleging she leaked secret material from a 2009 grand jury to the Philadelphia Daily News.
Ms. Kane did not speak during the hearing, but she told reporters afterward that she is grateful the court agreed to hear the case.
She is challenging Montgomery County Judge William Carpenter’s appointment last May of a special prosecutor to investigate the alleged leaks and the decision to bring the allegations before a grand jury, which later recommended criminal charges.
Ms. Kane’s attorney, Joseph Del Sole, argued that the special prosecutor was not properly appointed.
Thomas Carluccio acted without legal authority, so the grand jury’s presentment should be “null and void” and the evidence in it should be suppressed, Mr. Del Sole argued.
Read More
But Mr. Carluccio said Ms. Kane didn’t object to his appointment until the grand jury finished its work and recommended charges of perjury, false swearing, official oppression and obstruction of justice. Charges have not been filed pending the outcome of Wednesday’s arguments and a presentment detailing the basis for the recommendations has not been publicly released.
“The presentment comes out and when the attorney general doesn’t like the results she wants to quash it. I think there’s something wrong with the timing of that,” Mr. Carluccio told the Supreme Court.
Mr. Del Sole argued that only attorneys general and district attorneys can present evidence to grand juries, and that Judge Carpenter violated the constitutional principle of separation of powers when he appointed Mr. Carlucci. He said the judge had no authority to investigate the alleged leaks because they related to a disbanded grand jury that another judge supervised.
“There’s a fundamental difference between [this and] protecting the integrity of the grand jury he is supervising,” Mr. Del Sole argued.
He said it would have been proper for Judge Carpenter to refer the allegations to a district attorney instead.
Justice J. Michael Eakin scoffed.
“If I’m a small-town district attorney, do I want to investigate the attorney general?” he asked rhetorically.
Justice Max Baer, meanwhile, inquired about the limits of power of a grand jury supervisor and a special prosecutor, asking whether they could act “like dictators.”
Addressing Mr. Carluccio, he said, “You seem to be saying, ‘We can do anything we want to do. … Because there was a leak, our power to get to the bottom of it is unlimited.’ ”
Mr. Carluccio said he acted within the scope of the law.
Mr. Del Sole and Mr. Carluccio declined to comment as they exited the courtroom.
The court issued no immediate ruling. It is unclear when the court will rule.
Ms. Kane has said she did nothing illegal because the information she disclosed last year was not protected grand-jury material.
The information related to an investigation into whether former Philadelphia NAACP leader J. Whyatt Mondesire misappropriated grant money intended for a job-training program run by the nonprofit Creative Urban Education Systems. Mr. Mondesire was never charged.
Kane detractors suspected she leaked the information to embarrass political enemies, including Frank Fina, the former deputy attorney general who ran the Mondesire investigation.
Ms. Kane won her office in a 2012 landslide election that made her the first woman and first Democrat elected to the post. Since then, her office has been mired in controversies including a dispute over a corruption investigation involving state lawmakers from Philadelphia.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.