HARRISBURG — The state should be retaining deleted employee emails on servers for longer than five days, and by not doing so, it is harming public access to government records under the Right to Know law, an attorney for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette argued Tuesday in Commonwealth Court.

The newspaper filed suit against the state last month, saying the state’s practice violates the due-process rights of the public seeking release of public records; the PG was joined by a number of other newspapers in its complaint.

“After five days, the discarded email is permanently deleted from the executive agency’s server and can never be recovered for purposes of responding to a Right-to-Know request, even if the employee improperly deleted an email that in fact was a public record,” the newspaper’s complaint says.

Joining the Post-Gazette in its lawsuit were The Patriot News of Harrisburg; the York Daily Record/​Sunday News; the Chambersburg Public Opinion; The (Hanover) Evening Sun; the Lebanon Daily News; and LNP Media Group, parent company of The Intelligencer Journal and Lancaster New Era.

Advertise with us

In court, the commonwealth argued the 2008 Right to Know law still gives the state the right to set its own records retention policies — in this case, allowing employees to delete emails after five days that they deem to be transitory, and not part of a public record that must be retained.

“The Post-Gazette wants the Right to Know law to be a record-retention practice. It’s not,” said Linda Barrett, senior deputy general counsel at the Office of General Counsel.

Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini asked Ms. Barrett if the state could decide to delete all emails after 30 days.

“Can you use your records retention policy to frustrate the Right to Know law? The purpose of the Right to Know law? Under your position, that’s OK?”

Ms. Barrett said the idea of the commonwealth deleting all emails after 30 days “defies credulity.”

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette, through its attorney Frederick N. Frank, is asking the court that emails be preserved for at least two years on an archived server.

The newspaper’s court action arose after Acting Education Secretary Carolyn Dumaresq’s suggestion that department employees “delete and cleanse” their emails nightly. Although the department subsequently sought to clarify her statement, the lawsuit said “there is clearly daily purging” by the department.

Ms. Dumaresq made her statement in trying to explain why the agency was able to produce only five emails over 12 months that had been sent by Ron Tomalis, then the governor’s special adviser on higher education. He announced his resignation from the $139,542-a-year job two weeks after a July 27 Post-Gazette story cited his minimal email activity, a largely empty work calendar and phone logs showing barely more than a call a day.

“We're following the [court] case closely,” said Erik Arneson, a spokesman for state Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, the author of the state’s Right to Know law. The senator is in the midst of a state email records retention policy review, brought about in part by the reports of Ms. Dumaresq’s remarks, Mr. Arneson said.

After arguments concluded Tuesday, President Judge Pellegrini did not indicate a timeline for his decision.