A Commonwealth Court ruling that denied a request by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette for an injunction to stop state agencies from deleting emails after five days appears to be accurately based on current state law, open government advocates say.

But, those advocates contend, the state Legislature should change the law so that emails are kept longer, ensuring that important state records are not destroyed.

Judge Dan Pellegrini on Friday found that section 507 of the Right-to-Know law states that the law is not to supersede, modify or rescind any record retention policy. That means state agencies can continue to follow retention policies that allow employees to delete emails from their accounts daily and the system to delete them permanently within five days.

“Based on what Judge Pellegrini ruled, it’s based on the law. Now it’s time for the Legislature to make a decision,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania News Media Association.

Advertise with us

“What’s happening at the state level with regard to emails is inconsistent across the board and can create significant problems for accessing government records and holding government officials accountable,” Ms. Melewsky said.

Barry Kaufmann, executive director of Common Cause Pennsylvania, agreed.

“That may well be a correct decision from a judicial standpoint if the laws are juxtaposing one another. But then it requires a legislative fix. It is in the public interest to maintain a complete a record as possible of the operations of government.”

Erik Arneson, a spokesman for state Sen. Dominic Pileggi, R-Delaware, author of the state’s Right-to =Know law, said in August that “an effective retention law” was important to ensure the public has access to government records and that the senator’s staff would be reviewing the current statute “to see what changes needed to be made.”

On Friday, Mr. Arneson said the review is continuing.

Advertise with us

In its suit filed last month, the Post-Gazette argued that the state should be retaining deleted employee emails longer than five days and not doing so was threatening public access to government records. Post-Gazette attorney Frederick N. Frank asked that all emails be preserved for at least two years on an archive server.

“We are disappointed that the court did not recognize the overarching intent of the Right-to-Know law of access and did not consider that in construing the two statutes together,” Mr. Frank said. “We are reviewing our appeal options.”

The Post-Gazette was joined in the suit by The Patriot News of Harrisburg; the York Daily Record/​Sunday News; the Chambersburg Public Opinion; The (Hanover) Evening Sun; the Lebanon Daily News; and LNP Media Group, parent company of The Intelligencer Journal and Lancaster New Era.