HARRISBURG -- In 2006, a nonprofit called Greene County Industrial Developments Inc. applied for a $500,000 state grant on behalf of a start-up Internet company in Pittsburgh.
State officials turned down the funding request because it did not follow grant guidelines.
But thanks to a secret contract with the nonprofit, weak grant oversight, and the efforts of state Rep. Bill DeWeese's office in Harrisburg, Gravity Web Media ultimately ended up with access to the money anyway -- despite never signing a deal with the state.
The state was none the wiser. But as a result, it is all the poorer.
By the time the state Department of Community and Economic Development learned last year about the deal between Gravity Web Media and the nonprofit, about $243,000 of the grant had been spent.
The state is not exactly sure what the money bought. But based on inquiries by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the DCED on Friday confirmed it has opened an internal investigation of the grant's documentation and usage that will use a "fine-toothed comb" approach, department spokesman Mark Shade said.
The state attorney general's office also is investigating Gravity Web Media, which is defunct and gone from its former offices in One Oxford Centre, Downtown.
"This is the subject of an ongoing case," Mr. DeWeese said in an e-mail response to questions about his ties to the company and its president, James H. Rossell III. Mr. DeWeese said he has been cooperating with the attorney general's office.
Kevin Harley, the attorney general's spokesman, declined comment.
It is unclear what the attorney general's office is investigating, but possibilities include the grant as well as payments Gravity Web Media received from the House Democratic caucus.
In his e-mail, Mr. DeWeese said Mr. Rossell knew his former chief of staff, Michael Manzo. Mr. DeWeese said he remembers meeting Mr. Rossell twice.
"He expressed a fervent desire to locate his business in Greene County," said Mr. DeWeese, whose district includes Greene County. "I could not pick him out of a five-man lineup."
Mr. DeWeese is facing charges in the public corruption trial investigation known as Bonusgate. Last month Mr. Manzo pleaded guilty to 10 counts in that case and is now a star witness for the prosecution.
Bonusgate defendants stand accused of illegally using public money for election purposes. Mr. Rossell's own testimony before a grand jury investigating Bonusgate raises questions about whether the same line was being skirted by the House Democratic caucus, which was headed by Mr. DeWeese -- then the Democratic leader.
Mr. Rossell testified that his company was hired by the caucus after giving "a presentation in which he promised he would take care of the campaign Web sites and blast e-mails [to prospective voters] in a timely and efficient manner," according to a grand jury presentment.
Mr. Manzo testified Friday in the Bonusgate trial that Gravity Web Media signed a contract with the caucus in September 2006 for $96,500.
Mr. Rossell could not be reached for comment, and none of his business associates or lawyers reached last week knew his whereabouts.
An integral player in the saga of the DCED grant money is Greene County Industrial Developments Inc., a nonprofit that runs the EverGreene Technology Park in Waynesburg.
Donald Chappel, the group's executive director, said he was introduced to Mr. Rossell through Pittsburgh lawyer Bruce F. Rudoy of Tucker Arensberg, and former Tucker Arensberg lobbyist Robert Vescio.
Mr. Rudoy represented Mr. Rossell and introduced him to Mr. Vescio.
"They asked me to meet with the guy because he potentially was looking for help at the state level, he was trying to grow his business," Mr. Vescio said.
Mr. Vescio said he introduced Mr. Rossell to Mr. Chappel and Mr. Manzo during a trip they made to Pittsburgh.
First application rejected
Greene County Industrial Developments' first grant application was rejected because it tried to tap funds designated for nonprofits on behalf of Gravity Web Media, a for-profit company. It did not apply for other state funds meant to aid for-profit businesses.
Undaunted, the Greene County group reapplied, but this time for $500,000 to fund its own operations. It never mentioned Gravity Web Media to the state in its application.
Two days after winning the grant in April 2007, though, Greene County Industrial Developments signed a memorandum of understanding known as a "pass-through contract" with Gravity Web Media to use the state funds "to assist GWM in its business activities" and to establish a location in the EverGreene Technology Park.
That information was not shared with the state, Mr. Shade said.
A lump-sum payment of $500,000 was sent to the development corporation on May 12, 2007. Greene County Industrial Developments was to take a $10,000 cut to administer the grant, but it is unclear if the fee was ever collected.
Mr. Chappel said the idea for the pass-through came from Mr. Manzo. He said he could not recall how Mr. Manzo got involved in that decision.
Mr. Manzo, who was on the witness stand this week in Bonusgate, had no comment.
DCED barred pass-through contracts in 2006 or 2007 as a way to improve accountability, according to Mark Shade, a spokesman for the agency.
Mr. Chappel said his group had also barred pass-through contracts since the experience with Gravity Web Media.
With pass-through contracts, Mr. Shade said, "in most cases we don't know exactly who the money's going to, where the money's going."
At the time of the Greene County grant, the contracts were allowed, but only with DCED being aware of and approving them. The ban on pass-through contracts, Mr. Shade said, was unrelated to the Gravity Web contract.
Now, Mr. Shade said, "We're looking at supporting documentation to see whether the payments to Gravity Web were proper under the contract."
In 2008, Mr. Chappel said it became clear to him that Gravity Web Media was no longer in business. Mr. Chappel consulted with the state development corporation's top lawyer upon realizing "the closeout would become an issue," according to the grant file.
Mr. Chappel terminated the grant and returned $264,000 to the state in leftover funds and interest. His group hired an outside auditor to review the grant. The development corporation was able to find about $159,000 in receipts for expenses the corporation deemed eligible under the grant, Mr. Chappel said in a memo to DCED. It could not be determined, however, whether another $84,000 spent was allowable under the terms of the grant.
The state rejected the audit for several reasons, including noncompliance with auditing standards and the development company's failure to return certain funds.
"We're looking within the $159,000 that was spent by Greene County [Industrial Developments], and if any of that went to Gravity Web that was not part of the contract we will demand that back," Mr. Shade said. "We want the [remaining $85,000] back, but we're also looking to see if any of that [$159,000] was spent contrary to what our agreement was."
The grant file contains invoices sent to Mr. Chappel from Gravity Web Media for salaries, benefits and a laser printer.
Mr. Chappel told the state that his group "is not fully equipped" to return the $85,000.
"It was not repaid and there was an affidavit that we accepted saying, 'OK, it's not going to be repaid,' and we closed the file," Mr. Shade said. "But in light of the new questions we are reopening the file."
Mr. DeWeese's office sponsored the grant application filed by Greene County Industrial Developments. It was so involved in helping revise the application for the Community Revitalization Program grant that state economic development employees referred to it as "the DeWeese CRP," according to an e-mail message between DCED employees.
According to one memo in the grant file, one former DeWeese staffer "did the leg work on getting grant approval," while another was copied on several e-mail messages regarding the grant. At least two others were involved in discussions regarding the application.
Applications in the Community Redevelopment Program are typically signed off on by lawmakers and prioritized by caucus leaders, who forward them to DCED. Those that meet grant criteria receive grant awards, Mr. Shade said.
Mr. Rossell's background
Although Gravity Web Media's Web site is no longer available, an archived version of the site includes Mr. Rossell's biography. In it, he is listed as holding a bachelors degree and an M.B.A. from the University of Pittsburgh. The school has no record of granting degrees to anyone by his name, spokesman John Fedele said.
In a filing with the DCED, Gravity Web Media lists a six-member advisory panel. Four of the members who could be reached confirmed they knew Mr. Rossell -- one said he had met him a single time years ago -- but were not on any such panel. One person's identity could not be verified, and the final person could not be reached for comment.
One of the people listed as a panel member was Mr. Rudoy, the lawyer. "I represented that company at one point, but it's been a long time," Mr. Rudoy said, adding that he was not on a panel. "It was never offered to me. I never accepted it."
Mr. Chappel said he did not know of questions about the degrees or advisory panel when he was trying to help Gravity Web Media win its grant. And, he said, he did not know about it in March 2007 when his group reapplied to the state.
Mr. Chappel said his mistake was not finding out more about Gravity Web Media before signing the pass-through contract.
"I was lax on it," he said.
Mr. Rossell's name came up during opening arguments last week in the Bonusgate trial.
"Rossell never did any work for the Democratic caucus. Rossell never did any work for the Democratic campaign committee. He never relocated his offices from Pittsburgh to EverGreene Technology Park, and he never fully accounted for the grant money," said William Fetterhoff, lawyer for Bonusgate defendant Stephen Keefer.
Grant documents on file with the state show that Gravity Web Media formed in 2005 and generated about $400,000 in its first year of operation.
Of that, $82,550 came from the House Democratic caucus in three payments sent in the fall, just as Mr. DeWeese and others in his caucus were fighting for their political lives in one of the most contentious election cycles in state history.
Quality of work questioned
Three current and former House Democratic employees who worked on political campaigns confirm Mr. Rossell also had agreed to work on campaign Web sites. In the end, though, he did little more than create a mediocre template for a Web site that was never used, according to two highly placed sources on the House Democrats' re-election team.
"What do you guys want to do with Gravity? The samples that he sent the other day, in my opinion, were crap," wrote Mr. Keefer, then the director of information technologies, in an e-mail message to four other staffers in February 2007.
"I'm not a Web designer and could have done a better job," he wrote in another message.
Kevin Sidella, a campaign operative on Mr. DeWeese's staff, responded that Mr. Rossell is "all talk, in my opinion. He has produced nothing of substance."
Said one former staffer in an interview last week: "He had a lot of ideas, but after a time, our people said he's not producing anything, and had this grant to move to Greene County but he wasn't moving a body or a box. We were done dealing with him."
He and two others who dealt with Mr. Rossell said Gravity Web Media did no legislative work to earn its pay from the Democratic caucus in 2006.
The three asked not to be identified. One is a current staffer who did not want to face repercussions at work, and the others had been instructed by lawyers not to speak with reporters.
Their statements however, are backed up by grand jury testimony in the Bonusgate case.
Dan Reese, the House Democrats' programming web supervisor, told a grand jury "that Gravity Web Media never performed any work on the caucus's legislative Web site," according to a 2008 grand jury presentment.
"He further testified that he was unaware of any legitimate work ever performed by Gravity Web Media for the caucus."
Mr. Reese told the grand jury that he had tried to contact Mr. Rossell eight or nine times regarding the legislative Web site, but each time Mr. Rossell was unavailable or could not speak to him about the Web site.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.