Monica Ruiz still remembers frantic calls during the first Trump administration from women whose husbands never made it home — pulled over by federal agents for supposed traffic violations and detained, their abandoned work vans cluttering Pittsburgh’s streets.
“They don’t know if he’s dead and kids are crying not knowing when they’re going to see their dad again,” Ms. Ruiz, who serves immigrant families as executive director of the Beechview-based immigrant advocacy group Casa San Jose, recalled. “It’s really heartbreaking.”
With just a few weeks before President-elect Donald Trump returns to the White House, Ms. Ruiz and other advocates, lawyers and lawmakers are bracing for hardline immigration policies and tactics to resume.
Trump and Tom Homan, the incoming “border czar” and Trump’s previous chief of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, say their first aim is to deport migrants with criminal records. Advocates and Democratic leaders are increasingly concerned about the incoming administration’s vows to send packing the 11 million undocumented immigrants across the U.S. — more than 150,000 of them in Pennsylvania.
Advocates warn of families being ripped apart, militarized roundups, an increase in costly detention centers and temporary camps, the potential for dramatic economic losses of workers in key industries and local, state and federal coffers drying up by tens of billions of dollars.
Trump — who claims immigrants “cost us a fortune,” take Americans’ jobs and spike crime rates despite data suggesting otherwise — recently doubled down on his commitment to unprecedented mass deportation. Vice President-elect JD Vance suggests the process should begin with 1 million people annually.
It's impractical to talk about deporting 11 million people,” U.S. Rep. Jamie Raskin, D-Md., told the Post-Gazette. “You would have to channel all of the resources of the government to that purpose and it would cause an economic calamity. But I would expect they have scaled back their ambitions now and are talking about deporting criminal aliens, which of course they have every right to do. Criminal aliens are deportable.”
Mr. Raskin, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee in the next Congress, said Americans have an interest in seeing that the Constitution “is observed and due process is observed and the values of the country remain strong.”
“[Thomas] Paine called America an asylum to humanity, not an insane asylum,” he added. “I hope we will remain an asylum to humanity and not become an insane asylum.”
While fears of deportation and family separation in the immigrant community are rampant, and the still vivid uncertainty of 2016 looms, local groups say they feel more prepared this time.
The Jewish Family and Community Services is already seeing a growing need for legal support, community education and case management as families are “rushing” to get answers, according to COO Dana Gold. The organization settled more than 300 people last year from all over the world, from Afghanistan to Colombia to Ukraine.
“We’re getting concerns about, ‘Is my status OK?’” she said. “‘What can I do? Am I going to get deported?’”
Over the past six weeks, JFCS has convened nearly 20 immigrant-focused organizations confronting similar challenges across Allegheny County to start conversations about a path forward.
The groups aim to create a larger strategic plan and to craft a mass letter on the priorities to county and city leadership. Ms. Gold said this kind of proactive, collaborative effort among agencies is rare, but it felt necessary.
“Whatever changes are coming, we know there are changes coming, and they will be impacting the people we serve,” she said. “We, as a community, need to be prepared and not just wait and see.”
Casa San Jose has already ramped up its “Know Your Rights” sessions and legal screenings for families, many of whom are creating their own contingency plans to prepare for the changes to come.
“Just because an ICE officer approaches you on the street, we say you don’t have to talk to them,” Ms. Ruiz said. “When they come to your house, unless they have a valid warrant, you don’t have to open the door.”
Legal challenges against Trump’s efforts to end long-standing protections for immigrants are expected to intensify as well.
Trump in his first term attempted to end Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, which protects some undocumented people who arrived in the U.S. as children. But the Supreme Court blocked his efforts.
He also has eyed rollbacks or an end to the Temporary Protected Status program that shields more than 800,000 foreign-born individuals whose safety would be in jeopardy in their home countries.
Ms. Ruiz expects more lengthy court battles that will leave families in limbo over their future in the U.S. And an increasing number of families won’t apply for government programs they’re eligible for, like food assistance or medical insurance, out of concerns it could lead to deportation, Ms. Ruiz added.
That climate of fear affects daily life, as families may face increasing violence or harassment, said Sloane Davidson, who founded her Pittsburgh-based nonprofit, Hello Neighbor, in the wake of the last Trump presidency. Since 2017, the organization has served 3,500 refugees and immigrants from more than 59 countries.
“People will stop going out in public,” she said. “They would rather stay home than the fear of the unknown, of being targeted on the bus, walking down the street. We don’t want kids to miss school, parents to miss work, because they’re scared.”
During Trump’s last presidency, it became more difficult for foreign-born workers to enter the U.S. on visas or as refugees. Visa denials and extensions increased, while refugee admissions diminished.
There were also sweeping policies targeting specific groups, like Trump’s executive order that effectively halted arrivals from Muslim-majority countries. People who have already completed rigorous vetting processes fear they won’t ultimately be allowed to enter the U.S. if such polices return, Ms. Davidson said.
“They’re really nervous that they won’t be able to come anymore, even if those people are at the very front of the line, the proverbial line,” she said. “All of the checks and balances have happened, but if they’re not approved to travel, they can’t get here.”
How many DACA and TPS recipients are in Pennsylvania?
Along with the economy, border policy and crime were key issues of concern among voters in Pennsylvania who sent Trump back to the White House.
Crime and census data between 2017 and 2022 showed “no statistically significant correlation between the immigrant share of the population and the total crime rate in any state,” according to the American Immigration Council.
Yet from the day he announced his first presidential campaign in 2015, to the day before Election Day last month in a Pittsburgh speech, Trump has consistently linked migrants with criminality — a message that his critics say demonizes millions of people.
“We’re an occupied country,” Trump told the Steel City crowd, suggesting Nov. 5, 2024 would be “Liberation Day” in the U.S. “On day one I will launch the largest deportation program of criminals in the history of our country.”
On the “Meet the Press” television show last weekend, Trump argued the country had “no choice” but to crackdown on all undocumented immigrants over the next four years — even people who are otherwise following the law or are among the 4 million people in families with mixed legal status.
“It’s a very tough thing to do,” Trump said. “But you have to have … rules, regulations, laws. They came in illegally.”
Pressed by NBC’s Kristen Welker on the cost (likely hundreds of billions of dollars) and logistics of deporting even just 1 million immigrants annually, including more detention centers, more agents and more transportation, Trump said: “Number one, we’re doing criminals and we’re going to do them really rapidly. … And then we’re starting with others, and we’re going to see how it goes.”
Working with the Democrats
Trump said he’d work with Democrats on a plan regarding so-called “Dreamers,” children who were brought to the country illegally by their parents, many of whom are no longer younger people.
But Democratic lawmakers aren’t holding their breath.
This past week, Sens. Catherine Cortez Masto, D-Nev., Ben Ray Luján, D-N.M., and Alex Padilla, D-Calif., urged President Joe Biden to act now to help protect hundreds of thousands participating in DACA along with those granted Temporary Protected Status. They also urged for expanding the program to people from Ecuador, Nicaragua and El Salvador.
Ms. Cortez Masto told reporters at a press conference at the Capitol that she’s willing to work with Trump on strengthening the border while also addressing a broken immigration system, arguing they are “not mutually exclusive.” She credited Trump for using the Deferred Enforced Departure program to protect Venezuelan exiles on his last day in office in 2021, and for telling “Meet the Press” that he hoped he could “do something for Dreamers.”
“I’m always ready to work with them,” she said of the incoming administration. “But you’ve got to keep in mind — and this is why we need our employers … the faith-based community … everybody to come out and make a push — the last time he said that, and we brought him a bipartisan bill to do something to protect our Dreamers, he killed it.”
More than 500,000 in the U.S. participate in DACA, according to the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
The American Immigration Council said Pennsylvania had almost 4,000 active DACA recipients in 2022, though more than 13,000 Keystone State residents were eligible. Almost 99% of the state’s DACA-eligible residents are employed, and in 2022 they collectively paid $60 million in state taxes and $70 million in federal taxes.
Pennsylvania’s more than 150,000 undocumented immigrants accounted for almost 2% of the state’s workforce in 2022. These immigrants paid $386 million in state and local taxes that year, according to the American Immigration Council.
“By taking work authorization for hundreds of thousands of workers away, we’re gutting our own workforce,” Mr. Padilla said, warning voters who told pollsters that the economy drove their choices at the ballot they’ll face higher prices for food, housing and energy if mass deportation is executed.
As of March, there were more than 860,000 Temporary Protected Status recipients from 16 countries, USCIS said. Likely more than 3,000 recipients are in Pennsylvania; data from 2018 showed at least 1,000 from both Haiti and El Salvador.
Critics say the temporary program fosters illegal immigration. Trump, who pushed for rollbacks in countries like Haiti, has threatened TPS during his campaign.
Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation blueprint for the next conservative administration, calls for repealing Temporary Protected Status altogether. Trump sought to distance himself from Project 2025 this year, but many of his current and former team members helped author it, including Mr. Homan.
The White House and Trump’s transition team did not immediately respond to a request for comment, nor did the offices of Sens. Bob Casey and John Fetterman.
A message left with Gov. Josh Shapiro’s office asking if the state was following the incoming administration’s proposals and taking any action was not immediately returned.
Manuel Bonder, a spokesman for Mr. Shapiro, recently told Newsweek that the administration “is preparing for all scenarios and taking steps to safeguard our commonwealth from potential federal actions that could be harmful to Pennsylvania families and communities.”
Ending birthright citizenship? Or just talking about it?
Trump also says he “absolutely” plans to end birthright citizenship, claiming the U.S. is the “only country that has it.” In fact, more than 30 countries — including most of the Western Hemisphere — have unrestricted birthright citizenship, while another 30-plus countries include restrictions such as requiring at least one parent to be a citizen, according to the Library of Congress.
Trump said he could try to take executive action to work around the 14th Amendment’s birthright clause, or “get it changed” by going “back to the people.”
Eladio Bobadilla, assistant professor of history at the University of Pittsburgh, said “fear-mongering” rhetoric can be an effective political tool itself, despite what the actual policy shifts will look like.
“Historically, that has often been the most powerful weapon,” he said.
Even sweeping policies like mass deportation can prioritize political optics over effectiveness, Mr. Bobadilla said.
During the racially-driven Operation Wetback in 1954, the government said it deported about 1 million people — cramming many into into boats, buses and planes in poor conditions — but in some ways it amounted to a “publicity campaign,” as many were brought right back as guest workers, he said.
“Because Americans really like cheap labor and we actually do like the effects of immigration,” Mr. Bobadilla said. “It was just a way for the government to tell the American people the immigration problem is solved. But, of course, migration didn’t stop. It has never stopped.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.