As spots in affordable housing units and shelters remain few and far between, two Pittsburgh council members want to do something different.

Council members Anthony Coghill and Deb Gross are proposing the city build temporary facilities, particularly tiny homes, that could shelter people for about four years at a time, and come with in-house social services. The planning commission and city council agreed to hold off on a vote to move the zoning ordinance forward to address some of the ordinance’s language and compliance with federal and state law, including the Fair Housing Act. A working group of city leaders and experts will help guide the process.

On the table is Bill 2197, which would amend the city’s zoning code to allow the development of temporarily managed communities in the Golden Triangle, Riverfront and North Shore. The fate of the proposal is in the hands of the nine-member Pittsburgh Planning Commission, which held a Tuesday hearing to get public input.

The proposal was met with a mixed response. Some community members shared their optimism for the proposal as a faster, feasible solution compared to building up apartments or other permanent housing, and it offers more options for people who may not feel safe in a shelter setting or can’t get into one. Others shared concerns about these communities’ proximity to local businesses and residential areas, and questioned their sustainability over time.

Advertise with us

“We’ll keep going until something sticks to help the people get off the streets and provide a better way of life for everybody,” Mr. Coghill said.

During Tuesday’s meeting, Mr. Coghill and Ms. Gross argued that people who are in safe, clean housing get back on their feet sooner, and it’s a vetted strategy. These temporary managed communities exist in 24 states and 80 cities, according to their presentation.

Mr. Coghill described other housing concepts that could be made possible through the zoning ordinance, ones that could take upwards of $20 to $24 million to create, including building another facility similar to Second Avenue Commons shelter.

The idea he and Ms. Gross find most promising is creating mini neighborhoods with tiny homes, which would be equipped with hygiene facilities, food, garbage pick up and other services. If using vacant lots, he estimated one temporary managed community would cost much less.

“You could have 10 places, two people per residence there,” he said. “So, you’re housing 20 people with $4 million dollars.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Coghill said the tiny homes would create a safer environment compared to encampments, including for providers who wouldn’t have to cross highways and go under bridges to reach those in need. The temporary managed communities would come with 24-hour wraparound services, overseen by licensed providers. Social workers trained in emergency response will be available around the clock.

The sites would also be required to provide food, hygiene facilities, garbage pickup, along with mental health and addiction services.

But given that some of these communities could push into local neighborhoods, he knows pushback is inevitable.

“It is very challenging … red flags go up when you say, ‘Oh I want to build a place for the unhoused in the community,’” Mr. Cohgill said.

Only meant to be a bridge between shelter and permanent housing, Mr. Coghill and Ms. Gross’ ordinance would only permit them for four years, without renewal.

Advertise with us

Ms. Gross said these tiny homes can fill a necessary gap between housing and shelter. And costs are at top of mind, with construction for apartments doubling within 10 years – from $250,00 to $500,000, she said. She estimated that the city had spent $200 million in taxpayer funds on affordable housing already.

“We are going to be helping people get their lives back,” she said. “If we can do it sooner and cheaper, then we have to do it. In these communities, people can have that kind of mutual respect, mutual support. They can live with the dignity and autonomy that each of us expect.”

At least a dozen people, from advocates to residents, shared their hopes and concerns for the proposal.

William Goodridge, an attorney who lives in Brighton, called the efforts “commendable,” but he doesn’t agree that they should be located close to Downtown and North Shore, where they could interfere with business and recreational activities.

Tyler Andrews, who lives on the North Side, worries about long term stability, and whether this project could sway focus and “necessary funding” from permanent housing solutions.

Advertise with us

Some leadership of local councils also spoke on behalf of their neighborhood in opposition. Timothy Zinn, president of the Allegheny West Civic Council, said proposed change will undo the millions of dollars of investment in the city's river fronts.

“We also find it curious that the targeted areas are limited to the central business district and the city's river fronts,” he said, speaking on behalf of the Allegheny West Civic Council. “We believe this disproportionately impacts those neighborhoods that are one of the river fronts and those that are adjacent to the currently proposed areas.”

But those who work directly with the unhoused, like Sam Schmidt, an outreach worker for the local nonprofit Food Not Bombs, think the proposal is “thoughtful,” and just one of many solutions that should be considered. She said it’s hard for people to imagine the severity in this situation when “you’ve never slept on a sidewalk.”

Rachel Nunes, executive director of the Thomas Merton Center, thinks the tiny house plans diversify the current shelter options that don’t serve everyone. She asked that the working group and other city leaders reach out to members of the community for input moving forward.

“I know that you'll likely hear nothing about urgency from community advocates such as myself, but this is the pace at which we must move on these things,” she said.

Advertise with us

Jonathan Nadle, who lives in Beechview, says this proposal doesn’t require Pittsburgh to completely reinvent the wheel. Instead, it’s doing something that many other cities have “successfully done” already. Shelters and emergency warming centers are important but are “insufficient themselves” in meeting the need, he said.

“The tiny homes are the quickest, most cost effective way to get the unhoused housed and to efficiently get them the services they need all in a few consolidated locations,” he said.

Following the public comment, some commission members expressed a desire for the proposal’s success.

Commission member Phillip Wu said he is optimistic about what work can be done in the coming weeks, as the city’s law and planning departments help amend the proposal.

“We're on the same page in terms of, you know, what the goals are,” he said. “it's really just a matter of figuring out how it works within the zoning ordinance that we have today. I think that's what we're going to be working on in the next eight weeks.”

Advertise with us

Commissioner Mel Ngami added the same sentiment, and that she doesn’t want to “sacrifice the good for the perfect.”

“I do want us to be super cautious about how we step forward with this, which is why I appreciate that we're doing an eight week extension,” she said. “Because a lot of times when we look at the boon at the end, we forget the holes in which people fall through.”