As hundreds of people cycle through Allegheny County’s shelter system each year, one portion of the population is turning to emergency beds the most.

Despite making up only 14% of the county’s population, Black men and women comprise the majority of people living in both adult-only and family shelters. The insights come from data released by the Allegheny County Department of Human Services, which examined trends in emergency shelter usage from April 2022 to March 2023.

About 70% of people using adult-only shelters were men, and over half of them were Black, the data showed. The disparities presented even more in family shelters — women make up 90% of heads of households, and an overwhelming 77% were Black.

Adult and family homelessness looks different, from income levels to past experience with publicly funded social services. But racial disparities persisted across both shelter systems, and advocates, including Carlos Carter, president and CEO of the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh, say it’s a poverty issue.

Advertise with us

CLICK TO ENLARGE

Confronting gaps in education access, employment rates, job prospects, wages and health outcomes, Black communities are more vulnerable across the board, he said.

“Black people are overrepresented in homelessness, but we're also overrepresented in poverty,” he said. “Those who are most in poverty are most fragile. It just impacts everything when you don't have the resources.”

Individuals in adult-only households make up about three-quarters of the county’s overall shelter users. Despite making up the bulk of this population, Black men in particular see less support across the shelter and housing systems, said Michael Moore, director of the Northside Common Ministries. The nonprofit’s Pleasant Valley emergency shelter accommodates 25 men.

“There are definitely not enough safety nets,” he said. “And definitely not enough programming. I think single men are probably last to be prioritized when it comes to housing subsidies. Sometimes, they can be on a list for five, six, seven years before their applications are even looked at.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Moore says it's becoming increasingly difficult to transition clients into stable housing. Among adults who used a shelter at any point in 2022, only about 10% subsequently enrolled in a county-funded supportive housing program, according to the report.

And the interventions designed to lift people out of shelters — supports like transitional and permanent supportive housing that come with case management — do not always assist Black residents in an equitable way.

Nicole Harrington, director of employment and housing services for the East End Cooperative Ministry, sees it when her Black clients apply for housing at the shelter. Landlords often rely on criminal records, credit scores and eviction records, which can disproportionately impact Black and Brown applicants. They’ve also tightened leasing criteria and require more money upfront, between the application fee, security deposit and other payments, she said.

“It used to be, you have to make two times the rent,” she said. “Now, some of the landlords are going to three times the rent. This is a big reason why some of them are not able to succeed or become self-sufficient. There's a lot of barriers.”

Transitioning to another place to live isn’t a simple solution, says Rochelle Jackson, founder of the Black Women’s Policy Center. One study by the U.S Department of Housing and Urban Development found people of color were shown fewer rental units and denied more leases compared to white people. White individuals were also more likely to be offered cheaper rents, and move-in costs, such as deposits, were quoted as “negotiable.”

Advertise with us

“It makes sense that they would be experiencing a crisis in housing when they aren't being paid equally,” she said. “Black women are more likely to work at minimum wage jobs.”

For residents of local adult-only shelters, just about one-third were employed in any given quarter from 2017 through 2022. While those in family shelters were more likely to have a source of income and had more access to rent assistance and other social programs, their financial resources were still constrained. The average income was between $923 and $1,243 a month, well below federal poverty lines of $1,526 per month for a family of 2 and $1,919 for a family of three. Black women tend to have higher labor force participation rates than other women, she said.

Ms. Jackson thought 2019 would bring a reckoning, when a study by University of Pittsburgh researchers found that Black individuals, particularly women, could find better prospects in health, employment, education and more in nearly any other comparable city in the United States.

The researchers also found that Pittsburgh’s Black women are twice as likely as Pittsburgh’s white women to live in poverty, and over one-third of Pittsburgh’s Black women live below the federal poverty line.

But, when the pandemic emerged a year after the report’s release and there was a change in mayoral administrations, operations of the gender equity commission fell to the wayside, even failing to maintain full-time members and hold regular meetings.

Advertise with us

“One of the things that we've been committed to is making sure that no one forgets that report,” Ms. Jackson said. “It is the state of Black Pittsburgh, Black women.”

“But there has not been a lot of movement or a lot of improvement in those in that data, in those statistics. In fact, in a lot of ways, it has gotten worse. Poverty is still a number one pressing issue for Black women, even for Black women who are working.”

Ms. Jackson is concerned about the prospects of unhoused Black children. At the time of entering a family shelter, 49% of children were found to be age 5 or younger, according to county data. That means many are experiencing the instability of homelessness at young ages, and the effects of the trauma reverberates through the whole family, she said.

Families tend to have less experience with the behavioral system compared to those living in adult-only shelters. The county’s data shows that the most common mental health diagnosis for heads of households was acute stress disorder, a short-term mental health condition that can occur within the first months after experiencing a traumatic event.

“Mothers don't experience poverty in a vacuum,” she said. “What they feel, what they go through, their children also feel. A child experiencing someone coming to their house, the sheriff or whoever it is putting them and their mother or their siblings out in the streets, or going into this strange shelter with people that they don't know and sleeping in this cold, sterile room — that's traumatic.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Jackson wants to see more conversation about racial inequities persisting in the shelter system, calling on providers and officials to develop a regional plan.

“We're facing a crisis — those numbers represent a crisis,” she said. “If we're not talking about who's really experiencing homelessness, then we don’t really address the issue. This is not just a city of Pittsburgh thing. The Greater Pittsburgh region is experiencing this crisis.”

Jordan Anderson: janderson@post-gazette.com