As the Civil War entered its final months, some of the boys employed at Lawrenceville’s Allegheny Arsenal found themselves at the center of a theft scandal.
Three adults were arrested and charged with buying stolen lead, often in the form of bullet-shaped rifle balls pilfered by boys employed at the arsenal. The metal balls were packed with powder in a paper cartridge.
“The crime of receiving stolen goods is in itself bad enough,” The Daily Pittsburgh Gazette said on Dec. 9, 1864. “But encouraging children to steal, as these parties have been doing, is a most heinous offense and should be severely punished.”
The alleged misdeeds described in the newspaper may have reminded some readers of “David Copperfield,” the famous novel by Charles Dickens. In that book, published in 1850, young Copperfield is instructed by the villainous Fagin on how to pick pockets.
At a Dec. 8 hearing before Pittsburgh Mayor James Lowry Jr., several boys admitted what they had done. Thomas Hughes, 13, and Michael Borden, 14, told the mayor that on several occasions, each filled his pocket with lead and walked out of the arsenal. They then found buyers who asked few or no questions about where the material came from.
When one customer asked about the source of the metal, young William Donaldson “replied that they had been found at the [Allegheny] river.” Teamsters John Link and George Heninger offered some corroborating evidence. Dirt and cinders hauled from the arsenal to the riverbank often contained discarded bullets, they said.
Suggesting that there was little honor among thieves, Isaac Wood, “aged about seven years,” testified that he had taken “nine bullets from the Arsenal once, but a boy named O’Connell took them from him.”
Lead has a relatively low melting point — about 620 degrees. As a result, sometimes the boys would melt down the balls into bars or cakes, using a cast-iron skillet over a wood fire, before offering the metal for sale.
Margaret O’Connell, a widow who lived in Lawrenceville, was one of the adults charged in the case. The newspaper story doesn’t indicate whether she was the mother of the O’Connell boy who took metal away from Isaac Wood.
When police searched Mrs. O’Connell’s house, they found a kettle filled with bullets and about 100 pounds of lead that had been melted into 30-pound cakes.
“The price paid by Mrs. O’Connell to the boys for balls was usually about 6 cents, so she could make a handsome profit,” the newspaper said. The market price for lead was 15 to 16 cents a pound, according to that day’s paper.
Testimony about pay at the arsenal — boys might earn as little as 30 cents a day — helped to explain their motivation. Mrs. O’Connell had paid Michael Borden 56 cents for seven pounds of lead, or about 8 cents a pound.
Mayor Lowry ruled that two of the buyers, Mrs. O’Connell and Michael Maloney, would face trial on a charge of receiving stolen goods. A third person, Albert Rusk, would face another hearing. The boys were freed with an agreement that they would return and testify.
Len Barcousky: lbarcousky@post-gazette.com or 724-772-0184. See more stories in this series by searching “Barcousky” and “Eyewitness” at post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.