HARRISBURG — Gov. Josh Shapiro, opening a happy, budget-signing press conference Thursday night, revealed the secret sauce that produced the deal: “A willingness to have hard conversations, find compromise, and get stuff done.”
He spoke just before signing the main $47.6 billion spending bill that emerged from weeks of intense, secretive negotiations. While Mr. Shapiro and others praised agreed-upon investments made within the main bill and associated “code” bills, perhaps the most compelling evidence of compromise was what was left out.
There was no personal income tax reduction, even though Senate-controlling Republicans passed a bill for one. There was no Whole-Home Repairs Program, embraced for two years by Democrats and some Republicans. There was no voucher-style student scholarship program, a Republican favorite, and no $293 million public transit funding boost as Mr. Shapiro proposed and Democrats favored – it was only $80 million.
“Everybody has priorities and not everything makes the final cut,” Sen. Dan Laughlin, R-Erie, said of how compromise appeared to play out in the recent negotiations. “At the end of the day, we need to put politics aside and do the work the people actually hired us to do.”
He and Sen. Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton, have been prominent in condemning hyper-partisanship. Together, they introduced a bill last year to let people not affiliated with the two major parties vote in primaries, although the bill has languished in committee.
Both saw a good bit of compromise emerge from budget negotiations.
Read More
“There is not a single person who walked out of that room getting all they wanted,” Ms. Boscola said.
She gave significant credit to Mr. Shapiro’s involvement.

A former seven-year House member himself, Mr. Shapiro “does recognize the need to work both sides,” Ms. Boscola said. He learned from last year – when a disagreement with Senate Republicans blew up negotiations in early July – and conducts himself now as if her were “a very moderate lawmaker,” Ms. Boscola said.
Mr. Laughlin said he had little knowledge of exactly what happened during negotiations, but he has been told “Mr. Shapiro was more involved than he was the year before.”
Perceptions of a much-improved performance on the budget this year could add further luster to Mr. Shapiro’s already bright national image among Democrats.
Almost since he took office in January 2023, Capitol insiders have observed that his demeanor, track record and reach-across-the-aisle style seem to point toward national office. Recently, as media reports on President Joe Biden’s cognitive status have become widespread, mentions of Mr. Shapiro as a potential presidential candidate have become more frequent.
On the just-signed state budget, Mr. Laughlin got a personal taste of compromise from the budget deal.
He was one of the early Republican supporters of Whole-Home Repairs, a program that doles out grants of up to $50,000 for major home projects for income-qualified recipients. It was tremendously popular in Allegheny County. While Mr. Shapiro proposed to give it $50 million in funding this year, it received none.
“Do I wish it had gotten funded? I do. But at the end of the day, it got cut, and we can take another stab at it next year,” Mr. Laughlin said.
At the same time, the budget deal yielded Mr. Laughlin’s long-sought wish of having Erie designated for a City Revitalization and Improvement Zone, or CRIZ. It will change tax rules in a chunk of the city to spur development.
Ms. Boscola also experienced a mixed, win-loss feeling. Her longstanding push to fix the property tax system got no help in the budget, but she believed its economy-boosting pieces would pay off for her constituents over time.
Those included adoption of a “net-operating-loss carry forward” tax provision that should help business; a program to enhance and expedite the process of getting a permit in the state; and $500 million put into a Shapiro-desired PA SITES program that gets potential industrial sites ready for use.
For his part, Mr. Shapiro said soon after he signed the spending bill he would not discuss closed-door conversations about things that didn’t make the cut.
“Everybody had to compromise, and we didn’t always get what we wanted,” he said. “But we all are going to come back and continue to fight for the things we believe in.”
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.