Diane McNeill knows the red and blue American history textbooks sitting under her students’ desks are inadequate. The white glossy pages, the edges covered in pencil marks, were published in 1997. In the back, a list of U.S. presidents ends with Bill Clinton.
The book is a bulky reminder of the disadvantages East Allegheny School District students face as the underfunded district struggles to afford the kind of modern technology and curriculum readily available in wealthier districts.
At East Allegheny, teachers and administrators often fill in the gaps; Ms. McNeill uses outside resources such as History Channel videos while posters hanging on her classroom walls extend lessons past the Clinton administration. And her days are often filled with sending kids to the school’s “free store” for clothing or to the nurse for supplies they don’t have at home.
“Every day is a marathon because it’s so much more than just teaching the kids at this point,” Ms. McNeill said while sitting in her classroom one afternoon this school year. “When the kids come in, they need so much from us and I’m usually getting pulled in so many different directions. … But we don’t have all of the resources that unfortunately we should.”

East Allegheny — a small Mon Valley district of almost 1,400 students — is contending with a lack of resources, deteriorating school buildings and a $5 million budget deficit. It neighbors Westmoreland County schools such as Norwin and Penn-Trafford, both of which collect millions of dollars more in real estate taxes each year than the Allegheny County district.
And East Allegheny students struggle. Scores on standardized tests are low — with 36% passing the most recent English language Pennsylvania System of School Assessment, 18% in math and 48% in science — while special education needs are high. Some students also have mental health needs as they grapple with difficult home lives, often leading to rough mornings, raucous bus rides and instances of acting out.
Read More
But change could be coming to struggling districts across Pennsylvania. A judge last year declared Pennsylvania’s education funding system, which relies on property taxes, unconstitutional because districts with high property values can raise ample tax dollars to bolster budgets, something those in low-wealth neighborhoods are not able to do. That leads to, the judge said, students in lower-income districts having fewer resources than their wealthy neighbors.
It’s now up to the state to figure out a way to fairly fund schools, a process that could take years.
At East Allegheny — where administrators and teachers agreed to extensive interviews with the Post-Gazette this school year — officials are now fighting for equal opportunities for their students.
“It’s not so much a dollar amount,” Superintendent Joe DiLucente said. “It’s to bridge that gap and ensure that if kids go to East Allegheny, they have access to [Advanced Placement] courses. If kids go to East Allegheny, they have access to electives that are of interest.”

Funding
East Allegheny — which serves East McKeesport, North Versailles, Wall and Wilmerding — has a low tax base. The highest median household income between the communities is almost $61,000 in East McKeesport, census data shows. The lowest is $36,100 in Wilmerding. That’s compared to North Huntingdon, part of Norwin, where the median income is $91,000. And Pine, part of the Pine-Richland School District, has an average income close to $172,000, census data show.

East Allegheny sits in the Mon Valley, a swath of communities south of Pittsburgh heavily affected in the decades since many steel mills left the region. Since then, little industry has moved in. Online retailer Amazon did open at the former Eastland Mall space, located within the school district, in September but the Seattle-based company only pays about $34,350 annually in property taxes.
And while East Allegheny has not had to cut programs or raise taxes because of those disparities, officials are “left to make very difficult decisions” with the current funding structure, Mr. DiLucente said.
Teachers make up for a limited number of security guards — some wealthier districts in the region such as Bethel Park and North Allegheny fund their own police departments — by conducting bag searches each morning. And the administration is small — positions over the years have not been restaffed following retirements — meaning those in top spots take on multiple crucial positions.
The district has also sold two school buildings — Westinghouse Elementary in 2008 and Green Valley Primary School in 2015 — to cut back on growing maintenance costs as the buildings aged.
Today East Allegheny operates two schools. Logan Elementary, which opened in 2008 for fifth through eighth graders, now houses kindergarteners through sixth graders — meaning the Jacks Run Road school is “bursting at the seams,” Mr. DiLucente said. Rooms intended for clerical work were converted into offices. Classroom space is often shared between multiple teachers.
The junior senior high school, housing seventh through 12th graders, is in need of repair. The auditorium’s mezzanine can’t be used for safety reasons while the swimming pool sits empty because of high maintenance costs. And temperatures in the unairconditioned building at times creep to upwards of 90 degrees, an ongoing equity issue some Pennsylvania districts grapple with.
“I’ll do all of the diligence, the hard work, of combing through the budget, with looking at per pupil costs and being fiscally responsible,” Mr. DiLucente said. “But that has to be overlaid with funding that takes into account that our schools and our tax bases in the Mon Valley are never going to produce what those same elements are producing for our county friends.”

Essential services
Riley Verner, the valedictorian of the nearly 100-person East Allegheny class of 2023, was confident her 4.0 GPA and transcripts reflecting AP and dual enrollment courses — classes that allow high schoolers to earn college credits — would give her an upper hand when applying to colleges.
But then rejections started coming in.
The now 19-year-old was waitlisted at the University of Pittsburgh’s main campus and at Case Western in Cleveland, Ohio. Ms. Verner believes she would have been more marketable had she been able to take more high school AP classes. East Allegheny currently offers five AP classes and five dual enrollment courses through Carlow University.
But College Transitions, a North Carolina-based college admissions consulting firm, found students need to take between eight and 12 AP classes to be competitive at highly selective colleges.

“I literally can still say to this day senior year was the most stressful time for me,” Ms. Verner, who attends High Point University in North Carolina, said. “And getting rejected from those colleges that I thought I’d be able to get into was just so disappointing.”
The district over the years has shifted its focus to core classes, temporarily nixing extras such as middle school art because “our curriculum’s being dictated by who retires,” Mark Draskovich, the seventh and eighth grade principal, said, noting the district cannot always afford to hire a new teacher to replace the one who left. And they are forced to rely on grants when bringing in things such as STEM — or science, technology, engineering and math — a course already offered at Norwin.
The district also has to prioritize funding for mental health services.
At East Allegheny, 67% of students are economically disadvantaged and 72% receive free and reduced lunches — the National Library of Medicine found that poverty in childhood can cause poor mental health through social stresses, stigma and trauma.

The district heavily relies on grant money, something that leaves gaps in East Allegheny’s mental health services. In the middle school, Mr. Draskovich, who is also the director of student services and safety director, said his most pressing need is for an emotional support classroom for students with behavioral or mental health needs. But right now, he said, kids in need are in regular classrooms, and are “just not getting the degree of support that I think they need.”
Grant money is currently being used to provide services such as counselors and programs aimed at helping children regulate emotions and “mindfully start days,” Mr. DiLucente said. “Certain school districts, this would never be a consideration. For us, it’s really important.”
But grant funding, which is also used for safety initiatives, is “kind of temporary,” Mr. Draskovich said during a risk assessment meeting in September, attended by the elementary counselor Lesley Hawkins. When the grants dry up, “so will some of the positions,” he said.
“That scares me,” Ms. Hawkins said.
Community input
Tracy Yusko, a fifth grade language arts teacher, president of the high school football boosters, and lifelong East Allegheny resident, knows her students are capable of doing what they need to do to be successful.
“It’s unfortunate that we don’t have the funding like other school districts have,” Ms. Yusko said in the fall while watching one of the last football games of the season.
That night, Stephen Shurgaq proudly watched as his grandson played in the football game on turf that is in need of replacement, something the district cannot afford. Surrounding districts, including Norwin, are considering stadium renovation projects. Around him, cheerleaders’ chants of “Let’s go Cats” filled the night air. Mr. Shurgaq, a 1974 East Allegheny graduate, has lived here his entire life, and spent 24 years coaching high school girl’s soccer.
“For years I always felt that the more affluent school districts and affluent communities got more money or the same amount of money as lower income communities,” Mr. Shurgaq, who was decked out in blue and yellow in support of the district, said. “It’s been hard for us to survive with that.”

State officials are now debating the best way to fund schools. Gov. Josh Shapiro in his most recent budget proposal recommended increasing basic education funding by $1.1 billion, a 14% bump from the current year that would bring the budget line to a total of $9 billion. He also called for an additional $50 million in special education funding. And this month the House Education Committee advanced the first bill since the 2023 ruling, endorsing a $1.07 billion increase in K-12 funding for the 2024-25 school year. It also increases money for underfunded districts.
“The nearly two million dollars we would receive if the Basic Education Funding Commission’s leveling recommendations were to pass would tremendously boost our efforts to support our students better,” Mr. DiLucente said. “We would ensure we had the educators and curriculum-based resources to enhance our offerings for all students. For now, we have to make tough calls with minimal discretionary funds.”

But discussions have already hit partisan roadblocks, and lawmakers are close to missing the June 30th deadline for passing the budget. Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill, a member of the state’s Basic Education Funding Commission, noted the “level of complexity” in changing the funding formula “essentially guarantees that there are no easy solutions when it comes to these problems.”
As East Allegheny waits for the state’s next steps, families remain the backbone of the district. Many volunteer their time to help run sporting events and other activities. Teachers and staff who have spent decades in the district are now cheerleaders for their students.
“Education is the great equalizer that should be the corrective measure to make sure that these kids do get a chance in life,” Mr. Draskovich said. “These kids need to have the fair funding. Every kid should have the equal opportunity to get the same education.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.