HARRISBURG — A Senate committee starkly divided along party lines voted Wednesday to subpoena Gov. Josh Shapiro’s revenue secretary, Pat Browne, for tax records of a special development district in Allentown, Lehigh County, created when Mr. Browne represented the city as a state lawmaker.

The subpoena was served later on Wednesday, according to Senate Secretary Michael Gerdes. A spokesman for Mr. Shapiro, Manuel Bonder, said, “The administration is reviewing the subpoena as we evaluate any next steps.”

The action is rare but not unprecedented. Four years ago, a Republican-led Senate committee voted to issue subpoenas to the administration of Gov. Tom Wolf related to a controversial business waiver process during the COVID-19 pandemic.

On Wednesday, all Intergovernmental Operations Committee Republicans, including Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward of Westmoreland County, voted for a subpoena. All Democrats voted against it, including Jay Costa of Allegheny County, the Senate minority leader.

Advertise with us

A separate committee in December was directed by the Legislature to audit the Allentown Neighborhood Improvement Zone. Republicans believe revenue figures for more than 20 different types of taxes are needed to do it.

On Wednesday, they said repeated written requests for the information to Mr. Browne and the department had been declined.

Republican Sen. Cris Dush of Jefferson County said that if the records are not produced, he will draft legislation to eliminate the so-called NIZ, which has generated hundreds of millions of dollars of development since Mr. Browne wrote the law that created it. The records, he said, are necessary to evaluate how it is performing.

“The constitution prohibits us from making special language for a specific group of people,” Mr. Dush said after the vote. “The Legislature found a way around that when they created the NIZ in the first place.”

Mr. Costa said the motion for a subpoena — made by committee Chairman Sen. Jarrett Coleman, a Republican who defeated Mr. Browne in his 2022 bid for re-election to the Senate — called for what would be an illegal vote. Mr. Costa’s attempt to have the motion tabled was defeated.

Advertise with us

Both Mr. Costa and Sen. Christine Tartaglione, D-Philadelphia, reiterated the Department of Revenue’s position that the information was confidential. They said that compelling Mr. Browne and the department to release it was the equivalent of directing them to break the law.

“The department would be committing a misdemeanor by complying with this request,” Ms. Tartaglione said.

Both said the matter should be before the Finance Committee, not Intergovernmental Operations. Mr. Costa called the quest for the information a “fishing expedition.”

The Wednesday action followed a failed attempt by Republicans on the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee — the entity directed to audit the NIZ — to generate a subpoena. In late June, a vote by that committee on a motion to issue a subpoena ended at 6-6, with all Democrats opposed and all Republicans in favor.

Mr. Coleman subsequently said Mr. Shapiro should direct Mr. Browne to release the information.

Advertise with us

Following that statement, the governor’s office said the Department of Revenue had made clear that state law protects taxpayer information and forbids the disclosure of the information sought by the committee. While there are exceptions, the office said, the budget and finance committee request did not meet any of them.

“As a result, the Department of Revenue must continue to follow the law and has respectfully declined to provide this confidential information,” the office said.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com