Local restaurants and bars seem to be generally on board with a pending change to allow longer happy hours in Pennsylvania, but there are a few words of caution.

House Bill 829, which was introduced last year in conjunction with the Pennsylvania Licensed Beverage and Tavern Association, offers several amendments to the Pennsylvania Liquor Code, including the chance for bar and restaurant owners to extend their happy hours from 14 hours a week to 24, offer discounts on up to two food and alcoholic drink combination specials and to include the cost of up to two drinks in the cost of self-sponsored events.

The bill, which was passed by the State Senate in a 47-3 vote last week and is expected to be signed by Gov. Josh Shapiro, also has a provision allowing for the temporary extension of a liquor license to outdoor dining areas within 1,000 feet of a licensed building. This was first permitted during the COVID-19 pandemic and was set to expire at the end of this year.

“I honestly hadn’t heard about [the bill],” said 21-year-old Addison Diehl, a server at Revel in Market Square and one of a quick sample of workers interviewed after the vote. “But that’s really cool. Happy hour is one of our busiest times during the week — we’ve been very slow otherwise — but if we extend happy hours, we’re definitely bringing in a lot more money, a lot more tips, a lot more happy customers.

Advertise with us

“Having [those] extended hours and extended options for food and drinks would definitely make us get a lot more business, and a lot more reputable for our happy hour,” Ms. Diehl said. “[Pennsylvania] has always had the weirdest, most strict alcohol laws, so I think loosening up our liquor laws, or just changing them a little, is definitely a step in the right direction, because we’re behind a lot of other states.”

Adam Cordova, a 38-year-old bartender and server, has been a bartender and server at City Works in Market Square for a year but has worked in the industry in the area for about seven years.

“I think it’s definitely going to generate more business and bring more people out to the restaurant,” Mr. Cordova said. “I also feel like the [current] happy hours are really short anyway. Because everyone gets off work at 4, and it’s only from 4 to 6:30, so not really a lot of time to settle down and enjoy it. So yeah, I think it would be great if they extended the hours.”

Mr. Cordova said he thinks the bill would affect business at City Works in a positive way.

“Business has been steady, it’s kind of dropped down a bit,” he said. “But I feel like if [the bill passed], it would actually help the restaurants a lot, especially at night. That’s another thing too, is drawing people to come out at night. It’s tough enough to make people come out to a restaurant, but if you give them another little incentive, that also helps.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think [the bill] is going to affect anybody in a negative way,” Mr. Cordova said. “If anything, it’s going to affect everybody in a positive way. It’ll even help smaller businesses and other places that are struggling to keep afloat. The more people you can draw by giving them cheaper drinks for a little bit longer, then why not?”

Matt Lopez, 29, a server at Bar Louie on the North Shore, had similar thoughts.

“Restaurants always want people to come in, and if there’s a special to get people in to have fun and enjoy it and tip their servers and everything, I feel like that would just stimulate the restaurant industry,” Mr. Lopez said.

Bar Louie has a “pretty extensive” happy hour menu already, he said, which increases foot traffic.

“I feel like extending that will extend the invites for more people to come and hang out,” he said.

Advertise with us

City Works server Misael Siegert, 27, said he thinks the bill is “a great idea,” pointing out that Pennsylvania is “extremely strict” compared to other states when it comes to liquor laws.

But not everyone thinks the bill will be particularly impactful or beneficial.

“What I’ve noticed is with happy hour, when people sit at tables, they tend to stay for a very, very, very long time, and that can affect a server’s income,” said Spencer Melda, a 23-year-old server who also is at City Works. “Because if a table stays for three hours, that’s like three tables, and they’re going to just tip you for one table.”

“I don’t have a negative or positive view toward it,” said City Works managing partner Ismael Garcia, 44. “I don’t think it’s going to drastically change the way we do our business.”

Mr. Garcia said that he doesn’t think the bill will have much effect on the amount of business that City Works and other establishments in Market Square get.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think it’s going to bring more people out,” he said. “Sometimes happy hours devalue our brand because you’re offering constant discounts. Not everyone makes a lot of money off of happy hour, it’s just getting more people interested in the concept and things like that. For us, being that we are a very popular restaurant, people are going to be at [Market Square] no matter what, so I don’t think it’s going to positively or negatively impact us.”

For restaurants outside of Market Square, Mr. Garcia said he thinks the bill may or may not have an effect on business.

“We live in a very small-profit-margin-world, so when you’re adding more discounts to an industry that already has high, increasing prices of everything, it can be difficult,” he said. “I think it should be viewed from a marketing standpoint; you’re just trying to get people to learn a little bit more about you. It all depends on how each restaurant is marketing themselves. It can help some other people, but it also can hurt some other people if they’re not keeping up with discounting their brand.”

Mr. Garcia is not in support, however, of the bill’s provision allowing for temporary extension of liquor licenses to outdoor dining areas.

“I don’t like it,” he said. “For us here in Market Square, not at all. I am all about safety and security of this restaurant, not only for our patrons but also for our staff.”

Advertise with us

As crowds celebrated the Fourth of July in the square, he said, “a bunch of kids shot fireworks into the crowd, and everyone had to disperse. That’s two years in a row now. So for me, people can’t even enjoy big gatherings in the Square, and then to add alcohol to that mix, I just don’t find it to be beneficial. I don’t promote walking around, drinking out in the open, especially when we’re trying to make it a more family-friendly space. I think the alcohol should stay in here, in a safe environment, [where we] can keep an eye on everybody.”