HARRISBURG - Three political challengers who “primaried” incumbent state lawmakers on Tuesday pulled off the rare feat of getting more votes than the incumbent by the end of Election Day, but only one – Scott Barger – has relatively clear sailing to a new job in Harrisburg.
Mr. Barger, a 50-year-old Blair County resident who runs a real estate business, beat incumbent Rep. Jim Gregory in the Republican primary in House District 117 and faces no Democratic opposition in November in the heavily Republican district.
Hence, he is very likely to have the job in January.
“I am a Christian person,” said Mr. Barger, who previously was a pastor for 15 years. “I want to have principle but still work with people who disagree with me.”
Challenger Sean Dougherty beat incumbent Rep. Kevin Boyle in the Democratic primary in a Philadelphia district. But Mr. Dougherty faces a Republican opponent in November.
And challenger Jamie Walsh finished Tuesday ahead of state Rep. Mike Cabell by only eight votes in the Republican primary in a Luzerne County district. But some absentee and other ballots have yet to be counted, and Mr. Cabell has not conceded.
Read More
Only 20 incumbent House members who were listed on the ballot Tuesday had challengers in the primary. Seventeen won those contests, for an 85% winning percentage.
That, said Jim Lee, president and CEO of Susquehanna Polling and Research, is pretty typical. The only time a lot of incumbents lost primaries was after the infamous 2005 scenario in which lawmakers voted in the middle of the night to give themselves a big pay increase.
In the Senate, where half of the 50 seats are up for election this year, no incumbent who sought re-election had a primary challenger. Mr. Lee said that indicates a lot of potential challengers “are afraid to run because of the money disadvantage” and also, perhaps, that the electorate is not dissatisfied with their state senators.
Mr. Barger knew there was dissatisfaction in Blair County early last year when he made his first bid for elective office by running for county commissioner. In an interview Thursday, he recalled how during his campaign for that seat, many voters said they did not like the fact that Mr. Gregory had voted in favor of making Rep. Mark Rozzi, a Democrat, speaker of the House.
Mr. Barger said voters also connected that vote by Mr. Gregory with the Legislature’s failure to pass a bill on voter ID, which many district residents favor.
Ultimately, Mr. Barger lost the county commissioner race by 101 votes. But he decided to challenge Mr. Gregory, and he said he and his wife probably knocked on 2,000 doors during the course of the campaign. Unofficial results show that he defeated Mr. Gregory 5,917 to 5,012.
On Tuesday, he said the outcome was still sinking in.
“For six or seven months, your life is consumed by this campaign,” he said. “And then it is done.”
In Philadelphia, Mr. Dougherty beat Mr. Boyle in the Democratic primary for the House seat held by Mr. Boyle since 2011 by a count of 3,601 to 1,331. Top state Democrats backed Mr. Dougherty financially, and for about a week before the election, stories about an open arrest warrant for Mr. Boyle were featured prominently in the media.
The day before the election, Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner announced that the arrest warrant had been withdrawn because new information had come to light: that the protection from abuse order Mr. Boyle was alleged to have violated was not in fact active.
Mr. Dougherty will face Republican Aizaz Gill in the November election.
In Luzerne County, Mr. Walsh, a 49-year-old small business owner and first-time office seeker, had 4,723 votes to Mr. Cabell’s 4,715 in unofficial posted results for the Republican primary in House District 117.
Mr. Walsh said the swell of support for his challenge to first-term incumbent Cabell grew out of dissatisfaction with Mr. Cabell’s voting record and Mr. Cabell’s support for the use in schools of Kooth, a digital mental health platform that includes gender identity information.
“I feel like my supporters were more engaged to get me elected than his,” Mr. Walsh said.
Mr. Walsh said there were still a small number of non-traditional votes to be counted, but, “I am 100 percent confident I am going to win.”
Mr. Cabell said uncounted votes included some mail ballots with problems, military and overseas absentee ballots, and provisional ballots.
“There are certainly more than eight of those, all combined,” Mr. Cabell said. “There is no doubt about that.”
An adjudication on certain mail ballots is scheduled to begin Friday morning in the Luzerne County courthouse, Mr. Cabell said.
“We need to go through the entire process,” he said. He added that he would endorse the result after “every vote is counted” and it is clear the process was fair.
Unofficial results in a special election held Tuesday to fill a vacant seat in yet another House district – this one representing parts of Wayne and Pike counties – gave the victory to Republican Jeff Olsommer. After he is sworn in, the balance of power in the House will be 102 Democrats and 101 Republicans.
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.