HARRISBURG — A House committee heard differing views Tuesday on legislation to impose housing restrictions to keep convicted sexually violent predators from living in proximity to children at schools and day cares.

The Judiciary Committee held a hearing on House Bill 77 to prohibit these offenders from residing within 2,500 feet of a public school, private school, parochial school, preschool and day care facility.

Under current state law, sex offenders convicted of a sexually violent offense must register with state police for life and provide verification of residence under Megan’s Law, but face no restrictions on where they reside.

The Pennsylvania State Police reported in 2021 there were nearly 2,500 violent sex offenders in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

"The issue of residential restrictions came to my attention from constituents when a sexually violent predator moved within 500 feet of an elementary school," said Rep. Arvind Venkat, D-McCandless, the bill sponsor.

"We need to find a way to balance the safety of the community, but rendering individuals homeless and not connected would also be dangerous to the community," said Mr. Venkat.

The question is whether HB77 is a prudent measure to reduce the risk of recidivism with sexually violent predators, said Mr. Venkat.

There should be a setback from sensitive areas such as elementary schools, said Rep. Robert Mercuri, R-Pine.

“I would encourage us to close that loophole,” he said.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association said HB77 is well-intentioned, but also expressed concern that if it becomes law it could drive sexually violent predators underground without a main residence and an incentive to keep their registration up to date.

“You might also consider trying to achieve the goals of this legislation through an enhanced process by the (state) Parole Board and/or county probation offices regarding GPS and electronic monitoring…,” wrote Association Executive Director Greg Rowe and Counsel Kelly Callihan.

Residence restrictions violate a host of protected rights under the Pennsylvania and United States Constitutions, including due process and ex post facto laws, said Veronica Miller, senior ACLU policy counsel.

“The potentially punitive effect of these laws is significant, especially considering that these are individuals who have been allowed to return to their community following a punishment — an implicit agreement that they are safe enough to be in the community…" wrote Ms. Miller. “To impose a restriction after the fact can have no other effect but to punish, especially since these restrictions apply for life.”

The proposed residence exclusion area in HB77 would be much larger than the existing 1,000-foot mandatory buffer around schools regarding drug trafficking, said Mark Bergstrom, executive director of the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing.

“Our concern about creating large exclusion zones, especially in urban settings, is an increase in the number of transient sexually violent predators,” said Mr. Bergstrom. “Jurisdictions that have enacted housing exclusion zones for sex offenders have experienced difficulties in supervising and enforcing conditions for those on probation or parole, and in managing the registration, community notification, and access to information about these individuals.”