WASHINGTON — The latest indictment of former President Donald Trump is also the latest reminder of how much Pennsylvania was at the center of his efforts to overturn his loss in the 2020 election.
The four-count, 45-page indictment announced Tuesday by special counsel Jack Smith included a familiar host of Mr. Trump’s lies about and attacks on the election in the Keystone State — but this time in court papers accusing him of federal crimes. Among other now well-documented instances, the indictment highlighted Mr. Trump’s false claim that there were “205,000 more votes than voters” in Pennsylvania, and efforts to form a fake slate of electors.
"The attack on our nation's Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, was an unprecedented assault on the seat of American democracy," Mr. Smith said Tuesday in brief remarks after the indictment was unsealed. "As described in the indictment, it was fueled by lies. Lies by the defendant targeted at obstructing a bedrock function of the U.S. government: the nation's process of collecting, counting and certifying the results of the presidential election."
This was the third criminal indictment of the former president, who is nevertheless leading by huge margins in polls for the Republican nomination to reclaim the White House — and locked in a dead heat in a potential 2024 rematch against President Joe Biden. Polls and interviews with Pennsylvania Republican voters and party leaders have indicated Mr. Trump’s legal troubles are only strengthening his grip on the GOP.
And it might not be the last indictment: A state-level investigation in Georgia into Mr. Trump’s attempts to overturn the election there continues, with a decision on charges expected soon
The new federal indictment alleges that Mr. Trump knew his claims of a stolen election were false, but that he “repeated and widely disseminated them anyway — to make his knowingly false claims appear legitimate, create an intense national atmosphere of mistrust and anger, and erode public faith in the administration of the election.”
Read More
“Despite having lost,” the indictment said, “the defendant was determined to remain in power.”
Mr. Trump, who has long denied any wrongdoing in the post-election period and continues to insist the election was stolen from him, is expected to make an initial court appearance in the case on Thursday in Washington.
“Why did they wait two and a half years to bring these fake charges, right in the middle of President Trump’s winning campaign for 2024?” said Tuesday on his website Truth Social. “The answer is, election interference! The lawlessness of these persecutions of President Trump and his supporters is reminiscent of Nazi Germany in the 1930s, the former Soviet Union and other authoritarian, dictatorial regimes. President Trump has always followed the law and the Constitution, with advice from many highly accomplished attorneys.”
As he tried to cling to power, Mr. Trump zeroed in on seven states, including Pennsylvania, where the indictmensays he and unnamed co-conspirators set up fraudulent slates of electors to “mimic the procedures” of the legitimate ones who formally elected Joe Biden. This alleged scheme included meeting on the day required under federal law, voting for Mr. Trump despite his loss in the state, and signing “certificates falsely representing that they were legitimate electors.”
The fake Pennsylvania electors joined a conference call with three unnamed co-conspirators, who urged them to sign the certificates, the indictment said. Several refused to do so, and others wouldn’t sign without assurances that the documents would be used only if Mr. Trump won the ultimately futile court fights his campaign was waging.
As Pennsylvania’s legitimate electors certified Mr. Biden’s 80,555-vote victory on Dec. 14, the fake electors convened to cast their votes for Mr. Trump. Those certifications were mailed to the president of the U.S. Senate, the archivist of the U.S. and others and, the indictment said, were used “to deceitfully target the government function, and did so contrary to how fraudulent electors were told they would be used.”
The goal, according to the indictment, was to “create a fake controversy at the certification proceeding” and enable Vice President Mike Pence, who presided over the certification, to use the pro-Trump fake electors instead of the real pro-Biden ones. Mr. Pence said he didn’t have the power to reject the state-certified electors. (Unlike fake electors who were indicted in Michigan, the ones in Pennsylvania are likely to avoid prosecution because of a legal caveat they included in their certifications.)
At least one of the six unnamed co-conspirators, none of whom have been formally accused of any wrongdoing, has ties to Pennsylvania. And the indictment suggests the alleged fake electors scheme was orchestrated with help from state Sen. Doug Mastriano and U.S. Rep. Scott Perry. Both are staunch Trump allies and leading figures in the state’s election denial movement.
Mr. Perry, R-York, reportedly introduced Philadelphia native Jeffrey Clark, a former acting assistant attorney general, to Mr. Trump. While prosecutors didn’t name Mr. Clark in the indictment, he appears to be one of the unnamed co-conspirators. Prosecutors alleged that a former Justice Department official worked with the former president “to open sham election crime investigations and influence state legislatures with knowingly false claims of election fraud.”
After top Justice officials continued to tell Mr. Trump there was no widespread election fraud, he sought to replace the acting attorney general at the time, Jeffrey Rosen, with Mr. Clark. The president only relented when he was told “it would result in mass resignations” at Justice and the White House, prosecutors said.
“The Department of Justice is running cover for the corrupt activities of regime allies, criminalizing the political activities of regime rivals, and attempting to entrap innocent Americans in criminal schemes,” Russ Vought, former White House budget director under Mr. Trump and now president of the Center for Renewing America, where Mr. Clark is a senior fellow, said in a statement. “We are fighting with Jeff Clark and all Americans who have been taunted, abused, searched, arrested, and locked up by our federal government.”
The indictment notes that Mr. Mastriano, R-Franklin, presided over an event at a Gettysburg hotel on Nov. 25, 2020, where another co-conspirator — who appears to be former Trump attorney and New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani — falsely claimed Pennsylvania had issued 1.8 million absentee ballots but received 2.5 million back. Prosecutors said a Trump campaign staffer later wrote that “there’s no way to defend” Mr. Giuliani’s claim, prompting the deputy campaign manager to say “it’s very frustrating.”
Mr. Mastriano later rented buses for Trump supporters heading to Washington on Jan. 6, where he joined them in marching toward the Capitol. Mr. Mastriano, who ran for governor last year and lost to Democrat Josh Shapiro, has said he didn’t cross police lines, though videos have showed him closer to the Capitol than he has said he was.
Mr. Perry has previously criticized indictments against Mr. Trump as an abuse of government power, and Mr. Mastriano on Tuesday shared social media posts that blasted the new indictment as “malicious” and “bogus.”
This latest indictment also cited Mr. Trump’s attacks on Al Schmidt, a Republican former Philadelphia elections official who is now Pennsylvania's elections chief. Mr. Trump’s criticism of Mr. Schmidt for saying there was no evidence of widespread fraud led to death threats against him and his family. Mr. Schmidt, a Pittsburgh native who Mr. Shapiro chose as his secretary of state earlier this year, became a prominent face of the resistance to Mr. Trump’s election denial movement among Republican officials.
Mr. Trump later retweeted a post attacking Pennsylvania state lawmakers unwilling to overturn the election as cowards. And he was told more than once by his own Justice Department that his allegation that there were more votes than voters was false, the indictment said.
That didn’t stop Mr. Trump from repeating that lie in his Jan. 6, 2021, speech outside the White House, in which he urged his supporters to march to the Capitol and “fight like hell.” In fact, he told the crowd there that the Pennsylvania legislature wanted to take a new look at election results it had certified earlier.
“They want to re-certify,” Mr. Trump said. “But the only way that can happen is if Mike Pence agrees to send it back.”
The crowd responded by chanting, “Send it back.”
That afternoon, supporters of Mr. Trump broke into the Capitol, pummeled Capitol Police officers, ransacked offices and threatened the lives of Mr. Pence and members of Congress.
When the building was cleared hours later, a majority of House Republicans — including Western Pennsylvania’s three House GOP members, Mike Kelly of Butler, Guy Reschenthaler of Peters, and Glenn Thompson of Centre County — still voted to reject Pennsylvania’s certified electoral votes.
But as Mr. Trump mounts an unprecedented comeback campaign for the White House amid mounting criminal charges, his legal travails so far have only strengthened his standing with Republican voters. And there is no evidence the latest indictment will change that dynamic.
Mr. Kelly quickly issued a statement Tuesday accusing Mr. Biden’s Justice Department of “targeting” the former president.
“Make no mistake — the two-tiered Biden justice system has been weaponized against Donald Trump,” Mr. Kelly said. “If it wasn’t for a double standard, there would be no standard at all. If this can happen to a former president, this can happen to anyone. Where is the outrage?”
And in recent interviews before the latest indictment, several of the state’s county GOP leaders shrugged off the fact that their party’s presidential frontrunner is now a criminal defendant. Many who remain undecided on the 2024 primary still included Mr. Trump among their top preferred candidates. And some party leaders said the former president’s legal troubles could make him a more sympathetic figure and help broaden his base.
Sean Logue, the Washington County Republican chair, said the ongoing investigations only have strengthened his loyalty to Mr. Trump.
“They've shown that the Democratic Party and their allies in the deep state are so fearful of the MAGA revolution,” he said, “that they will weaponize the Department of Justice to go after the only president, or the only person I see, as being totally independent of their system.”
Tom Eddy, the GOP chair in Erie County, called the indictments “a scheme by Biden and the attorney general.”
"I don't see anybody beating Trump out for the primary election in 2024,” he said.
And in Venango County, Republican chair Keith A. Klingler said Mr. Trump’s legal troubles will have a minimal impact on who he supports in the election, describing the ongoing cases as “politically motivated, not legally motivated.”
“Democrats have done much worse and nothing has happened to them,” he said.
In a New York Times/Siena College national poll released Monday, 54% of likely Republican primary voters said they would back Mr. Trump, with 17% backing Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. No other Republican had more than 3%.
And in a Monmouth University survey released last Tuesday, Mr. Trump led Mr. DeSantis among Republicans, 54% to 22%, with no one else pulling more than 5%. In addition, 47% said they were not concerned about the criminal charges hurting Mr. Trump, and only 11% said they would make him a weaker candidate next fall.
“Trump has successfully pushed a politics of grievance where the system is out to get you,” said Patrick Murray, the Monmouth pollster. “In that light, the criminal charges seem to make him an even stronger advocate in the eyes of many Republicans.”
Allie Miller and Kristen Axtman contributed to this article.
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant; Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.