Told by gun reform activists that gun safety can be a winning issue for Democrats in November, the three leading contenders in Pennsylvania’s closely watched U.S. Senate primary — fielding questions in a forum hosted by Gabby Giffords’ organization on Monday — said they would draw on their personal experiences to prioritize fighting gun violence if they’re elected.
Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, the front-runner in recent polling, reaffirmed his support of getting rid of the filibuster to pass such measures as a ban on assault rifle ownership, called the National Rifle Association a “lunatic fringe of gun ownership” and said Democrats are not here to take your deer-hunting rifles but to pass commonsense reforms.
Mr. Fetterman also faced questions about a 2013 incident in Braddock that has re-emerged as an issue in this campaign, saying that a commitment to public safety — not racial profiling — was the reason he pursued and pulled a shotgun on a man as mayor of Braddock. Mr. Fetterman believed the man may have been involved in a shooting; the man turned out to be an unarmed Black jogger who had not been involved in a shooting.
U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, a Marine veteran and former assistant U.S. attorney, insisted that he can uniquely speak — as a trained member of the military — to rural Pennsylvanians skeptical of the Democratic Party’s views on guns. He said the federal government needs to put more resources into prosecuting and preventing gun violence.
State Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta said everyone in the race is for reducing violence but that only he goes home to a block where there may be another shooting. He noted that more than 100 people have been murdered in Philadelphia already this year and said that for him, it “hits differently.” The problem isn’t in developing ideas, he said, but in getting the political numbers to pass them.
Held at a time when gun violence is rising across the state, the forum was hosted by Ms. Giffords’ Courage to Fight Gun Violence, a group co-founded by the former congresswoman. Ms. Giffords was shot in the head in 2011 at a constituent event by a gunman who killed six and injured 12 others. Monday’s forum was conducted live from Philadelphia’s National Constitution Center and livestreamed on the web.
Read More
Peter Ambler, executive director and co-founder of the organization, said all three candidates are motivated to do the right things on gun safety, and encouraged them to see the value in running on the issue as a top priority. He cited recent polling among general election voters in Pennsylvania that found more than half said the U.S. needs stronger gun laws, while fewer than half know that background checks aren’t required on all gun sales.
“I know that this November, millions of Pennsylvanians are going to go to the polls and vote for the candidate who’s going to keep their kids and keep their communities safe from gun violence,” Mr. Ambler said.
Mr. Fetterman, who said the issue of gun safety singlehandedly drew him to public service in one of Pennsylvania’s most economically challenged communities, said the overwhelming majority of gun owners support basic reforms, but the Senate’s rules make it unlikely. It’ll take abolishing the filibuster to make progress, he said.
Noting that the state has a long history of hunting, Mr. Fetterman said gun ownership is compatible with commonsense gun reform legislation.
“We should not have weapons of war in the hands of civilians,” Mr. Fetterman said. “I have seen with my own eyes — in the scenes in my community — what a military-grade round does to the human body.”
Asked about the incident in 2013 when he was mayor of Braddock, Mr. Fetterman said he was out with his 4-year-old on a January afternoon when he heard a burst of gunfire. He got his son to safety, called 911 and saw an individual in a ski mask, he said, running from where he thought he heard gunshots toward an elementary school.
Mr. Fetterman insisted that he didn’t know the race of the individual, and that when he came in contact with him, he never pointed his weapon at him. He framed it as a “split-second decision” to intercept the person and protect the community — part of his commitment to eliminating gun violence as a whole, he said.
“My proudest accomplishment as mayor was that we went 5½ years without loss of life with gun violence. We lost nobody,” Mr. Fetterman said, showing the tattoos on his arm of the dates of homicides in his community.
The man who he chased down, Christopher Miyares, said Mr. Fetterman aimed the shotgun at his chest.
Mr. Fetterman’s opponents, at times deeming his behavior wrong and dangerous, have warned that Democrats would be in danger of losing the seat in November if Republicans used the news report from the incident.
Mr. Fetterman said the details have been misrepresented by his opponents and added that he was re-elected numerous times after the incident by a majority-Black community that understood it had nothing to do with profiling or race but was instead about public safety.
Mr. Lamb, who didn’t raise the issue in the forum on Monday, used part of his time on stage to talk about his training as a Marine, and said he can bridge the divide by returning the culture of firearm ownership to being “about heritage, tradition, carefulness and respect.”
The congressman said he’s not a politician who comes “with an agenda to come and take [your] firearms away, but someone who is trying to promote obeying the law and being responsible.”
Mr. Lamb said at the very least, the Senate needs to follow the House’s footsteps and pass laws requiring a background check on all gun sales, closing the Charleston Loophole and allowing family members and law enforcement to obtain protection orders to temporarily take firearms away from those who are deemed a danger to themselves or others. The Charleston Loophole is the gap in federal gun regulations that allows gun dealers to complete sales if a background check is not completed by the FBI within three days.
Those are “low-hanging fruit” in a way, Mr. Lamb said, and Congress must go further. He said he would draw on his experience in the U.S. Attorney’s office, where he spent half his time working on gun crimes and half working on drug crimes, to call for more resources to combat firearms offenses. He said the Drug Enforcement Administration gets about $4 in funding for every dollar the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives gets.
“I would love to be someone who is addressing the budgetary issues behind that,” Mr. Lamb said, calling for more resources to be shipped into gun violence prosecution and prevention.
Mr. Lamb said the biggest misconception about gun violence is that it is a simple issue, when in reality, it’s a complex problem that could warrant an “entire world” of things the government should be investing in. He cited a program in the early 2000s in Philadelphia where community leaders, pastors and elected officials identified at-risk youth and intervened directly — not to funnel them into the criminal justice system, but to help them.
Mr. Kenyatta said Democrats need an advantage in the political math — the numbers game in Washington — to usher in a new political opening. Echoing the main theme of his campaign, he said it’ll take leaders who know the problem firsthand.
“For me, this is not just something to talk about,” Mr. Kenyatta said. “It’s something that when this campaign is over, when this auditorium is empty, myself and my family and the people in my community — we’re still going to be thinking about this, working on this and committing to ending this crisis, because I do think we have it within our capacity to end this crisis.”
To change the Senate, change the senators, Mr. Kenyatta said, insisting that he won’t be a “wallflower” on the issue if elected. He also called for an end to the filibuster.
Asked what he’d do to address police violence, Mr. Kenyatta called the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act “serious and thoughtful legislation” that includes components that are widely supported by the American people. It doesn’t get done in Washington because of the political math, he restated.
That legislation would end certain police techniques like chokeholds, ban no-knock warrants in federal drug cases, end “qualified immunity” protecting officers from most civil lawsuits and invest in community programs, among other things. It hasn’t received a vote in the Senate.
“The issue is, we don’t have nearly enough people in Washington who know what I know about being stopped for no reason simply because of what I look like,” Mr. Kenyatta said.
The primary is May 17.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.