The head of the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board on Friday sent Gov. Tom Wolf a letter warning that a controversial bill passed by Pennsylvania’s Legislature to block public officials from immediately releasing the names of officers involved in shootings would engender “public skepticism and suspicion of government institutions.”
“As a professional in civilian oversight of law enforcement I am deeply concerned about the ramifications of [the bill] and urge you to weigh the impact of this bill on the public perception of special treatment extended to police officers and the bill’s influence on related public policies,” Elizabeth Pittinger, the board’s executive director, wrote in a two-page letter.
The board is a city-funded, independent watchdog that investigates citizen complaints about improper police conduct.
Jeffrey Sheridan, Mr. Wolf’s spokesman, confirmed that the letter had been received.
“The governor has not made a decision at this time,” Mr. Sheridan said. “He does not have the bill yet. Once received, he has 10 days to act. They would have to come back in during a lame-duck session to override any veto.”
House Bill 1538, sponsored by Philadelphia Republican state Rep. Martina White and approved by the GOP-controlled Legislature, would bar public officials from releasing the names of officers involved in duty-related shootings or other use-of-force encounters that cause death or serious injury unless charged with a crime, at the end of an investigation or 30 days after the incident.
But it would prohibit release of an officer’s name if there is a reasonable expectation that it would “create a risk of harm” to the officer, the officer’s family or property. Anyone violating the gag could be charged with a second-degree misdemeanor.
Police unions support the bill, claiming it is necessary to protect officers from a rush to judgment following polarizing shooting incidents.
"Is that so important, that we know the officer’s name? He’s not a public official, he’s appointed through civil service. Police officers are not public figures,” said Officer Robert Swartzwelder, president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1.
Officer Swartzwelder said temporarily withholding the name of an officer involved in a shooting incident is not what sows distrust.
“What creates public distrust is when the agency isn’t forthcoming with information,” he said. “It’s the facts of the case and how much information the department releases in a timely manner as they become aware of it.”
Opponents of the bill, including media advocacy outlets, civil liberties organizations and police accountability groups, fear that the legislation would harm transparency and create a double standard.
“It’s a hypocritical bill, and it’s a bill that’s still putting law enforcement above the law compared to everyone else. Anyone that is investigated for a crime or thought to have committed a crime, we see them all over the news all the time. Not only do we see their names, we see their faces,” said Brandi Fisher, president of the Alliance for Police Accountability in Pittsburgh.
Ms. Pittinger wrote that the bill “offers to create a double standard of the type nurturing public skepticism and suspicion of government institutions.”
“Concealing the name of a public employee exercising power in the name of the State is contrary to the very notion of, and obligations attendant to, public employment.”
Ms. Pittinger said the bill raised numerous questions, such as whether any evidence had been presented to warrant the proposed restrictions; whether the changes would further the public interest “or that of an exclusive group of public employees...”; whether the bill would “usurp the discretion and public accountability of police administrators, elected officials and police oversight professionals,” and whether the bill would reduce or escalate tensions between the police and community.
Ms. Pittinger also questioned whether the bill cuts both ways by, for instance, delaying public recognition for 30 days of a police officer’s heroic acts involving use of force. Additionally, she asked whether the family of someone shot by police would have to wait at least 30 days to find out the officer’s identity.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.