Justice may be blind, but candidates in judicial elections have to keep at least one eye on the money. And today, the six Democrats and six Republicans vying for three state Supreme Court seats are required to file their first financial reports of 2015.
Some say it undermines the judiciary’s credibility for judges to be hustling for money — but in an election, fundraising prowess is one way candidates prove they are credible.
“We’ve been at it for just five weeks, and we’re at just under $395,000,” Judge John Foradora of Jefferson County Common Pleas Court said about his fundraising during the first three months of the year. “So we are in this fight.”
Such numbers “send the message ‘I’m a serious candidate,’ ” said G. Terry Madonna, a political scientist and pollster at Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster, Pa.
Judge Foradora’s early fundraising outpaces that of 14 state Supreme Court candidates who have run since 2003, though the serious money may not have entered the race: Mr. Madonna said totals could “triple or quadruple” by the May primary. In 2007, when seven candidates vied for two Supreme Court seats, winners Debra McCloskey Todd and Seamus McCaffery raised $3.8 million between them.
But because few voters pay attention to judicial races, such money “usually comes from lawyers and special-interest groups who have an interest in the outcome of cases,” said Lynn Marks, executive director of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts.
Read More
“I’m not saying judges make decisions based on money,” added Ms. Marks, whose organization favors appointing judges rather than electing them. “But people overwhelmingly think contributors will have a leg up in court.”
In a 2013 poll conducted for the Brennan Center for Justice, nearly 9 in 10 respondents said campaign contributions have a “great deal” or “some” influence on judges’ rulings.
The concern is especially pressing this year because 11 of the 12 candidates — most notably Supreme Court Justice Correale Stevens — are already judges at the state or county level.
Win or lose, those candidates will be on the bench somewhere, noted Ms. Marks: “Lawyers have told me they feel they are in a very difficult position if they don’t contribute.”
Justice Stevens, who said Monday that he had raised slightly under $50,000, called fundraising “the single most difficult part of campaigning.” A Republican who in 2013 was appointed to replace disgraced Justice Joan Orie Melvin, Justice Stevens said he was keeping his fundraising efforts low-key, in part because of the court’s ethical travails.
Superior Court Judge David Wecht, meanwhile, logged $279,835 in contributions before the 2015 reporting period began. Nearly half of that was lent by family members, including his father, pathologist Cyril Wecht. Over $30,000 came from lawyers at the Pittsburgh firm of Savinis, D’Amico & Kane.
What should voters think when they see attorneys giving large sums to judges?
The firm didn’t respond to a call Monday, but “we should think, ‘Hooray, a great judge has enough money to get elected,’ ” said Judge Wecht, half-seriously. After all, he noted, “A lawyer has a perspective on the quality of a judge that a non-lawyer might not have.” And $30,000 would have little impact in a race where millions could be spent.
Judge Wecht, whose 2014 disclosure is among the campaign’s earliest, said transparency helped address concerns about fairness. Once so far this year, he said, “I declared in open court that I had visited and obtained support from one or two of the firms involved and invited questions and motions.”
Lawyers won’t be the only ones spending money: One powerhouse will likely be Philadelphia-based Local 98 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers. The union’s business manager, John Dougherty, is the brother of Judge Kevin Dougherty of Philadelphia Common Pleas Court, who is a Democratic candidate for the state Supreme Court. On Monday, John Dougherty acknowledged that “we’re involved” in the campaign. Mr. Madonna said the union will “certainly have an impact” because of its fundraising might and ability to turn out Philadelphia voters.
Judge Foradora is tapping a network that includes the University of Notre Dame, his alma mater. Because ethics rules preclude a judge from making a personal appeal for money, “I’m not allowed to make any asks,” he said. “I make the connection” with supporters, but when checkbooks come out, “I leave the room.”
While he called fundraising “a necessary evil,” he said, “I do think that electing judges is a good thing” — in part because appointing judges can be political, too.
When he first ran for judge in his heavily Republican home of Jefferson County, he noted, “I was one of four Democratic attorneys out of 45.” A judicial appointment “wouldn’t have happened. But I went out, met people and won.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.