The changing of the guard of state Supreme Court chief justices from Ronald D. Castille to Thomas G. Saylor marks a distinct shift in leadership styles that may foster more collegiality and collaboration on the court, members of the legal community said.

Justice Saylor’s ability to build consensus among his fellow justices, according to observers, is the primary difference between him and Justice Castille, whose administrative disposition was described as being more self-reliant.

“[Justice] Castille made decisions; he called balls and strikes,” said former Justice William Lamb, who served on the court with both men. “I think [Justice] Saylor will be much more inclusive in the whole decision-making process. Particularly in the beginning, because you have to be.”

Now more than ever, with the court down to five members after Justice Castille’s and Justice Seamus P. McCaffery’s retirements, the need to build a coalition among justices is crucial, Justice Lamb said.

Advertise with us

Bruce Ledewitz, a professor at Duquesne University School of Law, categorized Justice Saylor as a “consensus-builder.”

Personality, Mr. Ledewitz said, would not be an issue with Justice Saylor as it was with Justice Castille.

“I’m sure he’s forceful in his own way,” Mr. Ledewitz said, “but with Chief Justice Castille what you saw was what you got; he didn’t have a lot of subtlety.”

Mr. Ledewitz said that despite having poor relations with Justice McCaffery and former Justice Joan Orie Melvin, and not being able to direct the justices into a harmonious coexistence, Justice Castille was legally bold.

“I think jurisprudentially, Castille was an adventurer. He changed search-and-seizure law, environmental law, reapportionment, voter ID. This is a man who put his stamp on the substantive law of the court,” Mr. Ledewitz said.

Advertise with us

That legal adventurism is something that Mr. Ledewitz said Justice Saylor, whom he called the “intellectual equal” of Justice Castille, is not likely to emulate. “It’s more likely that changes on his court will be much more gradual and less dramatic,” Mr. Ledewitz said.

Lynn Marks, executive director of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts, said the court is transitioning into an era of relative calm from the storms of its recent past. “I think Chief Justice Saylor is a quiet, intellectual visionary who doesn’t seem particularly interested in the trumpet-sounding and pomp.”

The transition between chief justices itself, according to observers, should not prove to be disruptive to court operations.

Mark Aronchick, Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller chairman, who has served on several Supreme Court committees, said that transition will be made even smoother by having Justice Saylor at the helm.

“Chief Justice Saylor himself is a terrific person to serve in this capacity,” Mr. Aronchick said. “He’s very … focused on getting the business of the court done efficiently and with high quality. He himself by nature would be working very, very hard for a smooth transition.”