Although Gov. Tom Corbett’s Election Night party was held in the Omni William Penn hotel’s Urban Room, the event felt a bit like staying home for New Year’s Eve: Most of the fun was being had by people on TV.

While a TV projection screen tuned to Fox News showed Republican gains across the country, the Pennsylvania governor’s race was called just minutes after polls closed. Shortly before 10 p.m., Mr. Corbett made it official, congratulating Democrat Tom Wolf for winning "a well-fought fight."

In a speech with several heartfelt moments, Mr. Corbett noted his increased spending on mental-health programs, his work passing budgets on time, and a drop in the state’s unemployment rate during his tenure. He also reminded the audience of his promise four years ago to make tough choices. "I said I may be a one-term governor, and I am," he said. "But I am proud of what we did."

It was a remarkable turnabout in a state that has not failed to reelect a seated governor. But it came as little surprise.

Advertise with us

Early on, polls showed Mr. Wolf leading Mr. Corbett by more than 20 points, and while the race tightened in its final days, polls still showed Mr. Wolf with a double-digit lead. At the William Penn, the consenus was that Mr. Corbett had failed to adequately respond to Democratic attacks — especially that he’d cut state education spending.

"This whole campaign just seemed like the atmosphere was against Corbett," said Evan Tobin, a Westmoreland County Republican Committeeman from Allegheny Township. Mr. Corbett actually increased the amount of state money spent on education, but not enough to offset federal cuts. "I know of some Republicans who didn’t vote for him for that reason," Mr. Tobin said.

"For many months, they were saying Mr. Corbett cut education," said Marianne Stearns, who chairs the Franklin Park Republican Committee. "People are finding out the truth now, but he might have gotten his message out too late."

As for her concerns regarding Mr. Wolf, Ms. Stearns said, "I don’t want my taxes raised." Noting Mr. Wolf’s ads, she added, "He seems like a nice gentleman, and I like SUVs and Jeeps."

"And that’s about it," said Ann Harrold, the vice-chair of Ross Tonwship’s Republican Committee.

Advertise with us

State Rep. Mike Turzai, the state House Majority leader, agreed that messaging was "a real concern" for the governor. But he also faulted Mr. Corbett for not throwing his weight behind a House-passed bill to privatize the state’s liquor store system: "It was a signature issue, and if he had been out front on it and gotten the Senate to do liquor privatization the way we did, he’d be winning tonight."

Drew Sheldon, who worked as an intern for the governor’s Pittsburgh office in 2013, agreed that "other people were able to control the narrative" in the race. But Mr. Sheldon said that Mr. Corbett’s willingness to stick to his convictions was inspiring.

"He could have earned some very easy political points by accepting [gay marriage]," Mr. Sheldon said. Instead, Mr. Corbett chose to fight for the state’s ban on same-sex marriages in federal court. That impressed Mr. Sheldon, who said he hopes to become a lawyer himself someday, even though the state lost its case.

"If you compromise on the law," Mr. Sheldon said, "you’ll compromise on everything."

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com.