HARRISBURG -- The state Supreme Court yesterday ruled that a blanket ban on political contributions by gaming interests was unconstitutional, striking down a key provision of Pennsylvania's 2004 law designed to keep corruption out of the fledgling slots industry.
In a case involving a Blue Bell developer, the justices found that such a ban "clearly, palpably and plainly" violated free speech provisions.
The ban restricts "a constitutionally protected form of expression that is no less legitimate or important than other forms of expression," Chief Justice Ronald Castille wrote on behalf of the 5-1 majority.
The Legislature imposed the ban as a firewall against wealthy gaming interests trying to influence politicians. Some fear that without it, there is an open invitation for high-stakes pay-to-play politics.
Considered the nation's broadest such restriction, the gaming law prohibited all political contributions from a long list of those involved in gaming, from casino-license applicants to slot-machine suppliers.
But developer Peter DePaul, co-owner of the Foxwoods Casino planned for Philadelphia, challenged the restriction on the ground that it unfairly singled out one business sector.
He said he felt vindicated.
"I don't feel that we should be taken advantage of and penalized for doing something that everyone else can do," Mr. DePaul said. "I'm a substantial taxpayer in this state, and I have a right."
Mr. DePaul contributed nearly $32,000 to Philadelphia-area candidates and committees between January and April 2006 while Foxwoods' application for a slots license was pending before regulators.
He and the company that owns Foxwoods each agreed later that year to pay $100,000 for violating the ban. Mr. DePaul later sued.
Justices found that the ban served a legitimate goal of preventing undue influence, or at least the appearance of it, but said it was overly broad. They suggested that if contributions had been limited to a dollar amount, their decision might have been different.
The ruling does not affect any other portions of the gaming law, which legalized slots at up to 14 casinos and racetracks in the state.
In his dissent, Justice Seamus McCaffery wrote that in an era when "pay-to-play is a commonly known expression, and where public officials of high office have found themselves subject to federal corruption prosecutions, the necessity for the General Assembly to make every effort to avoid even the appearance of corruption in the highly charged theater of publicly sanctioned 'gaming' is apparent."
Gov. Ed Rendell said that as long as he was governor he would continue turning away checks from anyone tied to gaming.
The ruling comes as the Legislature is considering a number of gambling-related bills, including one opposed by casinos that would allow bars across the state to install video-poker machines.
Senate Minority Leader Robert Mellow, D-Lackawanna, said he did not think the decision will open up the floodgates to corruption.
But he said elected officials who did accept donations would have to disclose them.
Rep. Curt Schroder, R-Chester, called the court's decision "a tortured piece of legal reasoning."
"They struck down the one piece of the law that truly protects the public," he said. "Why should we be surprised? This is the same court that found a way to take the pay raise even though the General Assembly repealed it." Mr. Schroder was referring to the 2005 pay raise lawmakers gave themselves and other state officials, but then repealed. The Supreme Court later ruled state judges could keep their raises.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.