HARRISBURG -- An attorney for a defendant in a state government corruption case is petitioning the court to lift a gag order that a judge placed in 2008 on grand jury witnesses in the case.
Attorney Bryan Walk said yesterday the order impedes his ability to obtain information vital to defending his client, Brett Cott.
The order was filed under seal by Judge Barry Feudale, supervisor of a Harrisburg grand jury investigating an alleged scheme to use public funds to pay for political campaign workers. The order applies only to Democratic caucus employees and prohibits them from "disclosing their subpoena and the date, time, location and content of their testimony to anyone except their attorney."
Mr. Walk said he does not know who requested the gag order or why.
Judge Feudale could not be reached.
In the absence of such an order, state law allows people who appear before grand juries to speak freely about their own testimony.
It's rare for a judge to issue a gag order, said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association.
"We have a presumptively public court system, and the fact that Judge Feudale limited his holding to a specific group of people (witnesses that work for the caucus) shows the court is aware of the presumption of access. It would have been a sweeping gag order if it applied to all witnesses involved in the case."
In addition to Democratic House employees, witnesses have included House Republicans, Senate Democrats, lawmakers, campaign volunteers, contractors and others.
"From what I can tell, the order doesn't seem to raise any concerns [about access to court proceedings] so long as there's good cause," Ms. Melewsky said. "There are situations where secrecy is warranted in grand jury proceedings. ??? They don't want to disclose the nature of a criminal investigation while it's ongoing because it could compromise the investigation."
Mr. Cott is one of 12 people associated with the House Democratic caucus facing charges related to an alleged scheme to use tax dollars to fund campaigns, which is illegal.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.