First in an occasional series

Andy Amrhein, the seventh child in a family of 10 kids, grew up less than 2 miles from the hardware store he now owns in Bethel Park, where he has become a community fixture.

For 28 years, he has hosted the “Handy Andy Show” on KDKA radio Saturday mornings. He answers call-in questions about home repairs. He’s also Bethel Park’s No. 1 booster.

“It’s an amazing, absolutely amazing community that works together,” the 65-year-old owner of Evey True Value Hardware said. “I love it.”

Advertise with us

Bethel Park, where four high school graduates were accepted into U.S. military academies this year, a local record, also was home to the would be assassin of Donald Trump, Thomas Matthew Crooks.

Nearly a year after the shooting at a Trump rally in Butler, neither Mr. Amrhein nor others in the South Hills municipality of 32,000 can explain how one of their own wound up on the roof of a building 50 miles away, shooting into a crowd gathered to cheer on a presidential candidate.

The hardware store owner concedes he, too, had questions about Crooks.

“I talked with some of his teachers,” Mr. Amrhein said, still puzzled by the shooting. “He was a good student. Something snapped.”

An hour drive away

It’s an hour drive from Bethel Park to the Butler Farm Show grounds, where on July 13, thousands were gathering to rally for the former president who was running to become the rare incumbent ousted after one term to then return to the White House.

Advertise with us

There were charcoal-grilled hamburgers and kids with faces painted red, white and blue, giddy about seeing Donald Trump for the first time, as the temperature climbed to an oppressive 93 degrees.

“It was hot, hot, hot — desert hot,” said John Myers, a 67-year-old specialty tank contractor from Karns City.

Before the candidate took the stage, a huge American flag strung between two cranes became twisted in support cables by the wind. To some, it resembled an angel.

Barbara Williams, a 55-year-old financial planner from Baltimore, helped set up for the rally.

“Everything was just going so well. Everything was falling into place. The vendors, the food — everything was so nice,” said Ms. Williams, who sat in the bleachers with a Trump flag as a belt for her jeans.

Advertise with us

From the roof of a building about two football fields away, the 20-year-old Crooks was taking aim at the presidential candidate with a semiautomatic DPMS Panther Arms AK-15, a popular choice for price-conscious consumers.

He squeezed the trigger.

Pop-pop-pop-pop-pop. Sudden terror followed as the crowd realized the pops were gunshots. In the bleachers, spectator Corey Comperatore was killed; David Dutch and James Copenhaver were injured.

“It was just mass chaos, mothers were grabbing their children, people just screaming and running,” said Todd Gerhart, 63, a beekeeper from Charleston, S.C., who was selling honey at the rally. “Half-eaten chicken tenders on the tables, food on the grills.

“The innocence that was taken that day,” he said.

Advertise with us

A bullet grazed Trump’s right ear, drawing blood.

‘Giving and supportive’

A year later, his would-be assassin — shot to death by a police sniper at the rally — remains an unknown, a socially awkward math whiz who friends say was easy to miss in his neighborhood of sturdy brick houses with window shutters that don’t close and backyard decks for summer evenings.

Thomas Crooks didn’t fit the image of someone who would carefully plot to shoot a president, friends and neighbors said, and he certainly didn’t fit the image of an all-American community that’s a good place to grow up and find connections.

Bethel Park police patrol vehicle are seen parked at the border of the security perimeter in Bethel Park on Sunday, July 14, 2024. Law enforcement set up a 1 block permitter around the house of Thomas Crooks. (Esteban Marenco / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The population of the 12-square-mile municipality has remained mostly steady over the past decade, at a time when many other Pittsburgh-area municipalities have withered.

Health care giants Allegheny Health Network and UPMC have big outpatient centers in Bethel Park, which also has a Walmart, Home Depot, Lowe’s Home Improvement and two busy chain grocery stores.

Advertise with us

Today in Bethel Park, the Trump shooting is little more than a blip in the community’s collective memory, Mr. Amrhein said, barely a topic of conversation.

The community will likely have another few minutes of, if not fame, then at least a certain notoriety over the coming weeks, as a surge of coverage around the anniversary of the shooting comes and goes.

The concept of 15 minutes of fame is attributed to artist Andy Warhol, a Pittsburgh native buried in Bethel Park’s St. John the Baptist Byzantine Catholic Cemetery, where fans often leave offerings, including Campbell’s soup cans, on the grave.

“Bethel Park is very giving and supportive,” said Elaine Volpe, 49, the community’s children’s librarian for 22 years, a Dormont native who moved to Bethel Park last year. “It’s warm. Everybody wants to help everybody.”

Like Mr. Amrhein, Miss Elaine, as she is known, is a community fixture.

Advertise with us

She produces a popular five-minute bedtime story on YouTube that is broadcast on Bethel Park’s community access cable channel. Viewers have tuned in from as far away as Australia.

“It just kind of exploded,” she said. Out-of-towners will sometimes stop by the library to tell her how much they enjoy the broadcast.

She didn’t know Crooks.

“We’re all baffled by it,” she said about the shooting. “It’s baffling and it’s heartbreaking.”

Andy Amrhein, Owner of Evey Hardware store in Bethel Park prepares for the day as he opens his store at 6 a.m. on Monday, April 28, 2025. (Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘A mystery for everyone’

At the center of Bethel Park is a light rail station across from the municipal complex and police department. The T station connection to Downtown offers an easy trip for shows and football games, while sheltering residents from the ills of urban life.

Advertise with us

Bethel Park doesn’t have the higher crime rates of Pittsburgh, its big neighbor seven miles to the north, and the community is small enough to allow a whole shift of police officers to join local middle schoolers in a game of dodgeball, said Dale Arnold, 50, who has been the Bethel Park police chief for two years.

“It’s a feeling community,” Chief Arnold said. “People like to help each other.”

Last year, eight children of Bethel Park police officers received educational scholarships of $4,000, annual awards that began in 1969 and have been funded by the community’s generosity.

But Bethel Park doesn’t exist in a protective bubble, immune to the criminal element, Mr. Arnold said, adding that he didn’t know Crooks.

“It’s been a mystery for everyone involved,” he said about the shooting. “There’s just not a lot of answers. It’s — I don’t know.”

Advertise with us

The FBI said Thomas Matthew Crooks had no identifiable political ideology, and no alcohol or illegal drugs were detected in his blood after he was shot to death by a police sniper, 26 seconds after opening fire at the Trump rally. Before that day, he was remembered as quiet, but polite and respectful.

He won a $500 National Math & Science Star Award at Bethel Park High School in 2022 and graduated from the Community College of Allegheny County with a degree in engineering science, two months before turning the rifle on Trump. He would have turned 21 in the fall, when he planned to enroll in a four-year university.

He worked part time at an entry-level job — a dietary aide in a nursing home.

Crooks lived with his family in a brick ranch house on a quarter-acre lot that his parents bought in 1998, six years before he was born.

Crooks drove a Hyundai Sonata. He didn’t have a library card.

Advertise with us

“He just seemed like such a normal person,” said Kylie Katilius, who knew Crooks since elementary school.

His phone showed searches for the Democratic National Convention, the Republican National Convention, “any number of events or targets,” including celebrities, police said.

At a news briefing 16 days after the rally, special FBI agent Kevin Rojek offered this summary of his life: “Highly intelligent, attended college and maintained steady employment.”

“His primary social circle appears to be limited to his immediate family, as we believe he had few friends and acquaintances throughout his life,” Mr. Rojek said.

Crooks also used his phone to search “major depressive disorder,” which studies have strongly associated with suicide, but is rarely linked to homicide.

Advertise with us

A year later

A year after the attempted assassination of Trump, whatever turmoil roiled Crooks remains little more than speculation, partly due to how well he covered his tracks.

“While the FBI’s investigation may not have yet determined a motive, we believe the subject made significant efforts to conceal his activities,” Mr. Rojek said.

Crooks died on his belly on the roof of the building, far from home that hot day in Butler, a wide ribbon of blood spreading across his right cheek, lips parted, eyes gently closed.

A few weeks after the Trump rally, Mr. Amrhein helped kick off a new arts and music festival in Bethel Park; the timing with the shooting was coincidental. Those who participated pushed ahead with life as usual, working to make Bethel Park a good place to live.

The event drew 100 artists, eight bands, eight food trucks and 5,000 people, which surprised some organizers, Mr. Amrhein said, but he wasn’t surprised: Bethel Park is like that, he said, always stepping up for others.

This year, 10,000 visitors are anticipated.