For nearly five years, Jorge Toledo learned to live in captivity in a Venezuelan prison.
For 16 days in a San Antonio military hospital, he worked to come to grips with what had happened to him.
And for years afterward, he has learned to live again in a world that kept moving while his was frozen in time.
The Brooke Army Medical Center, part of Joint Base San Antonio, sits just northwest of the city center. It is often the first stop for Americans returning home after months or years as prisoners and detainees overseas.
In an interview with the Post-Gazette, Mr. Toledo detailed his time at the medical center — the same facility that Butler native Marc Fogel was taken to Wednesday after a Tuesday-night stay in Washington, D.C.
It’s where Mr. Toledo spent time after his release in October 2022 and where WNBA star Brittney Griner spent several days when she was released from Russia two months later.
Read More
The experience of every hostage, every prisoner, every detainee is different, Mr. Toledo stressed, and Mr. Fogel is the only one who can say what he’s going through now that he’s back on American soil after more than three years in a Russian penal colony.
But, Mr. Toledo said, the work he and others like him did at the BAMC program was crucial to transitioning back to everyday life.
“When you go back home, that's a huge challenge,” Mr. Toledo said Wednesday. “That is when chapter two of the ordeal starts."

The reintegration program there isn’t one the military touts or spotlights and, by all accounts, it’s never opened its doors to the public or to the media. Much of what’s known about the process has come from those who, like Mr. Toledo, have gone through it.
“Being released is not the end of the ordeal,” he said, calling surviving the captivity only the first challenge. “It’s the closing of a chapter and beginning of another.”
The military refers to the process as post-isolation support activities, or PISA. Those activities include medical evaluations and counseling sessions meant to “facilitate the return of the recovered person to military of civilian life as expeditiously as possible,” according to the Joint Chiefs of Staff personnel recovery manual.
Mr. Toledo, one of a group that became known as the “Citgo Six,” was held for nearly five years in Venezuela until he was released in a prisoner swap in October 2022. The men, all Citgo executives, went to the country’s capital believing they would attend a business meeting. Once in the meeting room, armed security forces burst in and arrested the men. They were accused of signing a deal unfavorable to the country and found guilty of corruption.
The men were designated wrongfully detained by the U.S. One was freed in a prisoner swap in March 2022. The rest, including Mr. Toledo, returned to the U.S. in October that year, nearly five years after they arrived in Venezuela. Two other Americans being held in Caracas were released in the same deal.
When he first arrived back on American soil, Mr. Toledo said, he believed he would be going straight home. His family was waiting for him at the airport hangar, and they wanted to take him home right away. The program at BAMC is optional but, after hearing the concept, Mr. Toledo told his family he wanted to participate.
That included a full physical and medical exam after not receiving proper medical treatment for more than four years, Mr. Toledo said.
The extent of any physical or medical problems that Mr. Fogel might have developed during his 3½ years in Russian detention remains to be seen, though he told reporters Tuesday night at the White House that he “was given more than 400 injections” over the course of the 100 days he was kept hospitalized while detained.
His mother, Malphine, has spoken often about her son’s chronic physical ailments, including a failed spinal fusion, two knee surgeries and a hip replacement. He didn’t take narcotics for the pain, she’s said, which is why he had the roughly half-ounce of medical marijuana that resulted in his arrest.
A history teacher, Mr. Fogel was returning to Moscow Aug. 14, 2021, for his 10th and final year teaching at the Anglo-American School of Moscow. He was arrested after the marijuana was found in his luggage at the Sheremetyevo Airport outside of Moscow. He was convicted of drug trafficking in June 2022 and sentenced to 14 years in prison.
Federal officials said Tuesday afternoon that Mr. Fogel, 63, was on his way out of Russia with Steve Witkoff, President Donald Trump’s special envoy to the Middle East. He landed in Washington, D.C. about 9:30 p.m. and met with Trump at the White House an hour later.
The second stage of his time at BAMC, Mr. Toledo said, was what they called decompression. He and the others released with him told their stories over the course of days to a team that included psychologists, psychiatrists and some federal authorities.

The process is to keep the trauma and emotions from combusting. He said the imprisonment, or the “ordeal” as he often calls it, was akin to shaking a can of cola.
“If you open it abruptly, you’re going to have a big spill because of the pressure,” he said. “Decompression means gradually open [the can] and try to let the pressure flow. And that is when you tell the story to all of these [professionals].”
The time in San Antonio included group therapy and full workups of the newly released detainees’ mental and physical health. They were eventually moved from the hospital facility to a guesthouse on the premises, and each person was assigned an individual psychologist to work with.
“The purpose of this segment of the program is to determine whether you have a trauma or not after your experience,” he said, “and, furthermore, to define what kind of trauma.”
And that was just the first 16 days after his release from captivity. More challenges awaited when he returned to his home and his family. After nearly five years away, he had to rebuild his relationships with his family.
“The day I arrived home, I arrived by noon. My wife was cooking and all laughter and happiness. We had meals, and my son, my granddaughters came home,” he said. “And then by the end of the day, I was going to my room, and there was a sort of tension.”
He spent five years sleeping without his wife and she without him. He broke the tension by asking her if it was OK if he slept next to her or if she’d rather sleep alone.
“We started joking and laughing about it,” he said. “The point is you need to rebuild relationships.”
Mr. Toledo said his granddaughters knew him only through video clips and photographs. The youngest called him “Virtual Grandfather.” Now, she told him, he was “Normal Grandfather.”
Everyday tasks could strike fear followed by frustration.
“The first time I tried to write a check, I struggled: Where should I sign? Where’s the date. Then I got stressed,” he said. “When I tried to drive for the first time, the degree of stress that I had when I turned on the engine was indescribable.”
Because for Mr. Toledo, the world had stopped moving just before Thanksgiving 2017. Outside of the Venezuelan prison, though, it kept moving. Coming home mean realizing the gap between his perception of reality and reality itself.
He likened it to being a photograph: He stayed still and motionless while everything around him kept moving. He had no job, and the financial impact on his family had been devastating. He had to reintegrate to the job market.
“It was a process, but I think that every process starts with the knowledge of your situation,” he said. “It’s to acknowledge the situation as it is: This is where I am and what is in front of me.”
Mr. Toledo, a fan of analogies, said it was like the case of an alcoholic: The most important moment is when they stand in front of a group and say, this is my name, I’m an alcoholic, and I need help.
So he was faced with a decision: Go with the flow and be driven by his circumstances or decide to survive and change what was in front of him. He called it an internal, deeply personal decision. For him, it meant deciding he was going to survive.
“After my decision to survive … why am I going to survive? So I set a motive for this,” he said. “I think that’s foundational because the ‘why’ drives you to have a meaning and a purpose for your survival.”
So when he got behind the wheel and panicked at the thought of driving, he took control. He did yoga. He meditated.
“[I did] practices that gave me tools to control all these internal reactions,” he said, “and have the courage to go back to the car and turn the engine on and drive.”
The road ahead
At the White House on Tuesday night, Mr. Fogel described himself as “the luckiest man on Earth” and said he felt like he was living in a “dream world.”
But trauma experts caution that there is likely a long road ahead for Mr. Fogel as he re-enters his life in Pittsburgh.
“Of course there’s euphoria – he’s grateful to be out of that situation and home, reunited with his family and happy to be in the United States again,” said Laurie Kramer, a professor of applied psychology at Northeastern University and a licensed clinical psychologist.
She spoke generally about those who have undergone trauma, and does not have any personal knowledge of Mr. Fogel’s case.
“In general, you would expect that once that euphoria fades a little bit away and he has time to reconcile with what he’s been through, what his life is like now, he might be feeling depressed and anxious,” she said.
She said she expected that he will receive a long and thorough assessment in San Antonio to come up with a treatment plan appropriate for his needs going forward, which mirrors the process Mr. Toledo said he went through.
“The trauma and stress-related experiences we may see may be balanced in part by the support of his family, feeling reconnected with his world, his family, working again and developing a new meaning for his life,” she said. “Stress responses can be persistent and long lasting. It may lead them to look at their lives in a different way.”
And there will be stress responses, said Priscilla Dass-Brailsford, a psychology professor at the Georgetown University School of Medicine and an expert on trauma and resilience.
“Some of the basic things that he’ll have disturbances in are his sleep, his appetite, the way he relates to people and his mood,” she said.
She noted the importance of a supportive family and home life in making the transition back into everyday life.
“How do people recover from captivity?” she said. “A lot of it depends on the context and the environment, and the kind of support they get at home.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.