EAST PALESTINE, Ohio — When President Joe Biden came to this town where a Norfolk Southern train carrying toxic chemicals derailed a year earlier, residents had one question for him: What took so long?
“It's overdue,” said East Palestine resident Linda Murphy, who owns a hobby farm with her husband, Russell. “I wish that the president would have come in the aftermath to see everything, because it seems to hit people harder when you could see the devastation.”
But the preparations and the security needed for a presidential visit can make a trip so soon after a disaster more disruptive than comforting.
“There is a time and place for that following a disaster, but it needs to be timed in a way when the local resources are used in a way that helps people recover rather than provide a headline for the president of the United States,” former Federal Emergency Management Agency spokesman Rafael Lemaitre said. “The president should visit at the right time and place after a disaster. That time and place should always put the optics after the survivors.”
Friday’s presidential visit took place more than a year after dozens of cars, some carrying toxic chemicals such as vinyl chloride, derailed near the Ohio-Pennsylvania border.

Even former President Donald Trump seized the day and flew into town just two weeks after the derailment, bringing bottled water and criticizing the Biden administration’s response as a “disaster.”
Read More
“A dollar late and day short,” Tobe Berkovitz, associate professor of advertising emeritus at Boston University, said of Mr. Biden’s visit. “If I lived out there, it would stick in my craw: What took you so long?”
Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Michael Regan, who accompanied Mr. Biden to East Palestine, said the president “decided to strategically visit and engage when he thought the time was right.”
He also said Mr. Biden had received an invitation from the village mayor, Trent Conaway, who a year ago said it was “the biggest slap in the face” when the president traveled to Ukraine rather than East Palestine after the derailment.
“I will note that a lot of work has gone on this past year, and it has been, as of late, that the mayor extended an invitation to the president to join,” Mr. Regan told reporters aboard Air Force One en route to the village. “And the president is responding to that local invite, which I think is very appropriate.”
Mr. Regan had been to East Palestine before. So had Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg. And the National Transportation Safety Board that is investigating the derailment. And the Department of Health and Human Services. And the Federal Emergency Management Agency official who is coordinating the cleanup.
The administration has pledged to hold Norfolk Southern responsible for the costs of removing any contaminated soil and water and to address any impact to the community.
But the president hadn’t visited. Until Friday.

“I am so disappointed,” said Traci Meek, who lives just about 750 feet from the derailment site and owns a small agricultural business, Buck Berry Farms. “I mean, if there's a hurricane, he went. If there was a flood, he went. What happened here feels just as disastrous.”
Seeing the fiery derailment unravel from her own living room, she said she wondered what the community would have felt had Mr. Biden come back then, giving them the same assurances they’re hearing now.
”He should have been here when there were burned out rail cars lined up here, when we didn't know what we were going to do,” she said.
While Mr. Trump in 2020 won nearly 72% of the vote in Columbiana County, which includes East Palestine, Mr. Biden said that party affiliation was irrelevant.
“It doesn’t matter if you’re a Democrat, a Republican, or an independent,” he said during his trip. “What matters is we’re all Americans — everyone, everyone. We look out for one another. We leave no one behind. And we come back stronger than before.”
Those who have been part of presidential visits to disaster sites said it’s more important for federal officials to be on the ground rather than a White House entourage. A presidential trip can wait, they said. The cleanup cannot.
“It’s great to have the president come to your community after something like that happens,” said former U.S. Rep. Tom Malinowski, who joined Mr. Biden in September 2021 on a tour of a New Jersey town ravaged by the remnants of Hurricane Ida.
“But it is also much more disruptive than those people realize because of the extraordinary security requirements the Secret Service imposes on any presidential trip,” said Mr. Malinowski, D-N.J. “Presidents have got to take that into account, especially when a community is already traumatized by a disaster. The presidents are the ones frustrated because there is demand that they be seen comforting people. But on balance, if the trip is going to disrupt people's lives rather than bring them relief and reassurance, the right call is not to come, or delay going until things settle down.”
Indeed, Mr. Lemaitre said that Mr. Biden may have done more good this time by waiting until long after the attention has faded.
“If you’re a survivor, a year is certainly not too late,” Mr. Lemaitre said. “A visit at this time demonstrates that the administration hasn’t forgotten about this community. A recovery takes years. It shows the administration is in there for the long haul. It means staying on the ground even when there isn’t media attention.”
Republicans, though, have continued to make an issue over Mr. Biden’s failure to come until now.

“My team and I were meeting with constituents who live just two miles from East Palestine within weeks of the train derailment last February,” U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said Friday on the social media site X.
And Mr. Trump’s campaign marked the occasion with an advertisement criticizing the president for not coming until now.
Mr. Regan said local officials didn’t want Mr. Biden there at the beginning.
“I think we have — even with 20/20 hindsight — governed ourselves accordingly,” Mr. Regan said. “There is a little bit of a circus when we all come, and I think respecting the mayor's wish and locally elected officials’ wishes not to have federal visits disrupt the response that is needed to make people feel safe — we have listened to the people locally. And that's why you've seen us respond the way we have.”
East Palestine resident Jess Conard said she was happy just to see the president with the hope he will take the actions needed to ensure that residents are safe.
“It’s an honor to host a president in your community, no matter which side of the line you're on,” she said. “We still have unmet needs. Let's move forward together in the way that makes the most sense and heal together.”
Even when a president comes quickly, not every visit is remembered fondly. When Mr. Trump flew to Puerto Rico in the aftermath of Hurricane Maria in October 2017, he threw paper towels into the crowd.
And former President George W. Bush’s stop in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina in September 2005 is best remembered for him telling his FEMA administrator, Michael Brown, that he was doing a “heckuva job” in responding to a storm blamed for the deaths of some 2,000 people.
Ever since George Washington, Americans have considered the occupant of 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. NW as part of their families, said Barbara Perry, a professor in presidential studies at the University of Virginia’s Miller Center.
Technology lets presidents come into Americans’ living rooms to build an even closer bond, and air travel enables them to travel across the country at a moment’s notice, thus raising the expectation that the occupant of the White House will come in times of trouble, Ms. Perry said.
“People have a really personal relationship with presidents and that means they want to call on them in times of trouble,” she said.
That’s because Americans want their commander-in-chief to also be their comforter-in-chief.
“The president is the face of the administration,” Mr. Berkovitz said. “He is the person who people think of. It’s great to have your secretaries go out there, but it’s not the same.”
Ms. Perry called it the “personal presidency.”
“We see presidents as members of our family, like the Father of Our Country,” she said. “What's the first thing people do when a tornado hits their town? They look to the government. People expect the president, who is the symbol of that help, to come and they expect him to be personable and treat them as if he was a family member coming to comfort them.”
Because of his own personal tragedies — including the loss of his wife and infant daughter in a traffic crash and his oldest son to cancer — Mr. Biden has a special talent in comforting victims of disasters, Ms. Perry said
“Joe Biden gets this,” she said. “This is what his strength is. This is a real talent and skill that he has.”
And it will be a visit the residents long will remember, she said.
“No matter who the president is and whether people like that person or not, people remember seeing a president,” Ms. Perry said. “They will remember until they no longer have memories. Now with smartphones and social media, they’ll take lots of pictures and they’ll send that out to their friends.”
But Ms. Murphy said she especially felt let down by the administration when Mr. Trump came to town within a month, bringing supplies with him.
“He brought in water, which we desperately needed at that time,” she said. “He brought other things like laundry detergent, which was fantastic. He was not our president. He had no power to sign anything. But he came.”
After waiting so long, she said it feels like Mr. Biden’s visit is just another “photo op” rather than a real sign of presidential leadership.
“He should have come here in February, March, April of last year,” she said. “I feel like all this is a dog and pony show. We're getting a couple of hours, when I've been living here every day,.”
Jordan Anderson, janderson@post-gazette.com; Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.