WASHINGTON — After a week of “political theater,” as many observers described it, the possibility of the first Black woman reaching the nation’s highest court became closer to a reality Friday when Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., declared that he would cast his crucial vote in support of Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson.
The confirmation of Judge Jackson to be an Associate Justice on the U.S. Supreme Court requires a simple majority, per a 2017 change in Senate rules. In the evenly split 50-50 upper Chamber, if no Republicans support the nominee, Vice President Kamala Harris can cast the tie-breaking vote.
While Judge Jackson’s historic confirmation will be decided by a floor vote expected in early April, local legal scholars and observers question whether this past week’s hearing process, and other recent examples, serve the purpose of examining a nominee’s judicial record and legal knowledge, or is just being used by certain lawmakers who are “making plays for sound bites,” as Pitt Law School Dean Amy Wildermuth described it.
“The experience today of going through one of those confirmation hearings is very different than it was, you know, even 20 years ago, and I’m sure I’m just adding to the many voices that are already saying this, but I am pretty disappointed,” said Ms. Wildermuth, who clerked for former Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens.
Judge Jackson, a former federal trial judge, member of the U.S. Sentencing Commission and federal appellate judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit since June 2021, has three times received Senate approval for those appointments.
However, looming over Judge Jackson’s hearings were lingering reminders from GOP lawmakers of contentious battles over Trump-era Supreme Court picks, including the combative hearings over Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s appointment.
Read More
Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., who along with two other Republican senators supported Judge Jackson’s confirmation to the D.C. Circuit, used his time to speak Monday and Tuesday to repeat is displeasure that U.S. District Court Judge J. Michelle Childs, from his home state, wasn’t President Joe Biden’s top choice. During his line of questioning on Wednesday, he told Judge Jackson that Justice Kavanaugh “was ambushed.”
“How would you feel if we did that to you?” he asked her.
“In the Kavanaugh hearings, you had a different set of political interests,” Ms. Wildermuth said. “I’m going to say this right now, this is the responsibility of both parties. It’s not one, it’s not the other. This has devolved into point-scoring and political theater in ways that really troubled me.”
Mr. Graham, who has signaled that he will not support Judge Jackson this time around, also joined Sens. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., Ted Cruz, R-Texas, and Tom Cotton, R-Ark. in lines of questioning that suggested Judge Jackson was lenient when sentencing child pornography offenders.
Ms. Jackson defended her sentencing record.
David Hickton, former U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania, said a judge’s sentencing philosophy is “surely relevant” to discuss, “but I don’t think the battle is being waged fairly.”
“The bottom line is, if we don’t apply individual sentences to individual defendants through the exercise of a human being exhibiting judicial discretion, [then] we can get rid of all the judges and just do this by computer, but that’s not right. Nobody wants that,” he said.
“A fair look at Judge Jackson’s record is that she has applied the law without fear or favor and applied all factors in the individual case, within the sentencing guidelines, and I don’t think there’s any evidence to support not confirming her because of her sentencing philosophy, but I don’t think that really matters for the people asking the questions,” continued Mr. Hickton, who was appointed and approved by the Senate during the presidency of Barrack Obama and now runs the cyber law and policy institute at the University of Pittsburgh.
Judge Jackson’s sentencing record and that she, a Harvard Law grad and current board member, would recuse herself from the Harvard affirmative action case before the high court, are important questions, observers say.
Some senators got it right, at times asking “substantive” questions, both Duquesne President Ken Gormley and Ms. Wildermuth said, respectively highlighting those of Sens. Chris Coons, D-Del., and Mike Lee, R-Utah.
“When it starts going into sort of theater, or drama, then, you know, that’s where it really isn’t especially helpful,” said Mr. Gormley, Duquesne’s former law school dean.
At another point during the hearing Mr. Cruz questioned Judge Jackson on critical race theory — a law school theory that is widely known to be a political flash point — and showed her multiple children’s books with Black children on the front that broach the topic of racism.
Stephanie Dangel, a Pitt law school professor, described hearing the senator’s questions about Judge Jackson’s time as a public defender as “frustrating.”
If confirmed, Judge Jackson would be the first public defender to sit on the high court.
“There’s a really important role to be played [by the hearings] in educating the public, which is part of what I found was so disappointing. Whether it was out of ignorance or intentional campaigning, they painted the role of public defenders and judges in ways that I don’t think are accurate,” said Ms. Dangel, who clerked for former Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun in the early 1990s when the landmark decision in Planned Parenthood v. Casey reaffirmed the legality of abortions.
The Supreme Court is set to decide another landmark abortion case this coming term.
Ms. Wildermuth said that during the hearings this week a person called to ask “Why would anybody want to be a judge?” “A lot of people respond in this way,” she said. “We are doing all sorts of damage to the reputation of the government, the trustworthiness of the government, and obviously to the judiciary. And I’ll tell you, we’re going to have a lot of folks who aren’t going to want to sit through that kind of hearing. They’re not going to endure the kind of theater that went on.”
The Judiciary Committee is scheduled to meet Monday for its first markup of Judge Jackson’s nomination and is expected to vote on April 4. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., said on the floor this week that he expects to wrap up the full confirmation vote by the April recess.
Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., told the Post-Gazette by phone this week that he plans to vote for the nominee who has “worked hard to achieve what she has achieved academically and professionally.”
A representative from the office of Sen. Pat. Toomey, R-Pa., said the senator plans to meet with Judge Jackson but did not provide further comment beyond the senator’s February statement.
Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.