WASHINGTON — Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson told the Senate’s judiciary panel Monday that she will decide cases from “a neutral posture” as her confirmation hearings to become the next associate justice of the U.S. Supreme Court commenced, marking an historic nomination process that is expected to culminate in the approval of the first Black woman to the nation’s highest court.

“If I am confirmed, I commit to you that I will work productively to support and defend the Constitution and this grand experiment of American democracy,” Judge Jackson said. “... I evaluate the facts, and I interpret and apply the law to the facts of the case before me without fear or favor, consistent with my judicial oath.”

Judge Jackson, 51, was nominated last month by President Joe Biden to replace retiring Justice Stephen Breyer, 83, for whom Judge Jackson, a Harvard Law graduate, clerked during the 1999-2000 term.

Members of the Senate Judiciary Committee — chaired by Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., alongside ranking member Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, — delivered opening remarks praising Judge Jackson’s background of federal clerkships and as a federal public defender, as well as her time at private law firms and as a federal trial judge, but they also promised tough questioning from the Republican side.

Advertise with us

If confirmed, Judge Jackson is not expected to change the ideological balance of the court, which currently leans conservative.

Her nomination could clear the 50-50 Senate with a solid block of support from the Democrats and a tie-breaking vote from Vice President Kamala Harris — though Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, has signaled support.

“We cannot replace Justice Breyer, but with you, Judge Jackson, we have a nominee who embodies the same qualities,” Mr. Durbin said.

“You’re independent-minded and understand the critical importance of judicial independence,” he added. “Your record is one of excellence and integrity.”

Committee Republicans promised thorough questioning and a “respectful” hearing.

Advertise with us

Mr. Grassley said the committee will avoid “turning this into a spectacle” as he and other members of his party repeatedly drew contrasts to the confirmation hearings for Justice Brett Kavanaugh.

“We’re off to a good start,” he said.

Day one of Judge Jackson’s hearing featured introductions from Judge Thomas Griffith, formerly of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit who was appointed by President George W. Bush, and from University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School professor Lisa Fairfax, Ms. Jackson’s Harvard classmate.

Judge Griffith, who said he has known the nominee since her time as a U.S. District judge in 2013, said Judge Jackson has “demonstrated that impartiality on the bench.”

Judge Jackson, who currently sits on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, received the Senate’s approval in June for that position when Mr. Biden nominated her to fill the vacancy Judge Merrick Garland left behind after becoming U.S. Attorney General. The D.C. court is often referred to as the nation’s second-most influential court and has been a springboard for former and current Supreme Court justices.

Advertise with us

Three Republican members of the Judiciary Committee — Ms. Collins; Lindsey Graham, R-S.C.; and Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska — joined the Democrats in approving her nomination to the circuit court.

Even with the endorsement from members of their own party, committee Republicans said they had questions lined up for the following days regarding Ms. Jackson’s “philosophy” from the bench.

While praising her upbringing and her “strong track record of ethical values,” Sen. Tom Tillis, R-N.C. said he needed to hear more from the nominee before deciding if he would support her.

“I don’t want an activist at either end of the spectrum,” he said.

Despite his support for her last year, Mr. Graham, in his opening remarks Monday, signaled his opposition to Judge Jackson because of what he called a “wholesale effort from the left to take down a nominee from my state.” That was in reference to J. Michelle Childs, a U.S. District judge from South Carolina who made Mr. Biden’s short list for Supreme Court nominees but ultimately was not his pick.

Advertise with us

“And I don’t like it very much,” he said.

But, he promised the nominee hearings that “are going to be challenging for you, informative for the public and respectful by us.”

Ken Gormley, Duquesne University president and constitutional law scholar, said because the balance of the court will remain unchanged and because Judge Jackson is what he describes as a “centrist,” he expects a “tame” hearing, similar to that of Justice Neil Gorsuch.

“You can usually take the temperature of a [nomination] hearing from the first day, and what was clear today is that the Senate Republicans are not going to come in with guns blazing, trying to create a major war,” he said.

If there are any “flame throwers” this week, Mr. Gormley expects the fiery rhetoric from Sens. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., and Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., who asked Judge Jackson on Monday to reveal her “hidden agenda.”

Advertise with us

While Republicans raised suspicions of support from the left, Democratic committee members highlighted the praise that Judge Jackson has received since being nominated, including from victim advocates, various levels of law enforcement, former attorneys general and Department of Justice officials.

“Judge Jackson is no political activist. She is not a puppet of the so-called radical left. She has been praised by Republican-appointed judges,” said retiring Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., a former chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee.

‘Today we should rejoice’

Alongside the political back-and-forth, the panel’s 22 members and guest speakers threaded the theme of Judge Jackson’s race, gender, background as a public defender and role as a working mom throughout their opening speeches.

“Today we should rejoice,” said Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J.

Advertise with us

Of the 115 justices that have been appointed to the nation’s high court in its 233-year history, only two have been Black.

Only five have been women. Three are currently on the court: Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor, who is the first woman of color to ascend to the bench.

None of the justices have previously served as public defenders, “one of the most honorable roles in our justice system,” Mr. Booker said.

Ms. Fairfax, Judge Jackson’s Harvard roommate and friend of 35 years, said, “I know she is honored and humbled by the significance of this moment, not what it means by her, but what it means for our amazing country, confirmation of the idea that America is a place in which all of us could feel a sense of belonging and all of us can reach our fullest potential.”

During her opening statement, Judge Jackson recognized her family in the crowd, including her parents who began as public school teachers as well as her husband, two daughters and in-laws.

Advertise with us

“I know it has not been easy, as I’ve tried to navigate the challenges of juggling [law and being a mother],” she said, addressing her daughters. “And I fully admit that I did not always get the balance right. But I hope you’ve seen that with hard work, determination and love it can be done.”

The Senate Judiciary Committee will reconvene Tuesday at 9 a.m. to begin the questioning of Judge Jackson. Hearings will continue Wednesday and Thursday.

A committee vote has not yet been scheduled.

Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com