WASHINGTON — The confirmation hearings for United States Supreme Court Justice nominee Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson begin Monday, and Pittsburgh-based constitutional scholars expect the usual partisan “showmanship” during an otherwise noncontroversial multiday process that could end with the approval of the first Black woman to ascend to the nation’s highest court.
President Joe Biden last month nominated Judge Jackson, who currently sits on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, to replace retiring Justice Stephen Breyer, delivering on a campaign promise to diversify the bench that has been occupied mostly by white men for nearly two centuries.
Pittsburgh legal scholars say, if confirmed, Judge Jackson would bring with her experience that ranges from her year on the prestigious D.C. Circuit Court, where other Supreme Court justices have previously sat, to her time as a public defender — a position that no other judge appointed to the high court has held before.
“If you were to just put these credentials on a piece of paper without even caring about what color she is, what gender she is, she would be eminently qualified for this appointment,” said Ken Gormley, the president of Duquesne University and a constitutional scholar.
If confirmed, Judge Jackson would not only be the court’s first Black woman, but also only the third Black person and sixth woman added to the bench.
Historic, but ‘fits a mold’
Read More
Judge Jackson, a Washington native who grew up in Florida, attended Harvard for both her undergraduate and law degrees, and spent a year in between as a reporter and researcher at TIME magazine in New York, according to her background outlined on the questionnaire submitted earlier this month to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
The nominee, who graduated Harvard in 1996, spent the next nearly two decades clerking for federal judges, appointees by both presidents Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton; working at multiple private law firms, including one where Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett would also work; and serving twice on the the U.S. Sentencing Commission, the federal panel created as part of the judicial branch in 1984 that advises on federal sentencing guidelines.
From 1999 to 2000, Judge Jackson clerked for Justice Breyer during a term that addressed contentious topics including abortion, prayer on school grounds and LGBT issues.
“She sort of fits a mold of how we typically see Supreme Court Justice nominees come forward,” said University of Pittsburgh Law School Dean Amy Wildermuth, who clerked for Justice John Paul Stevens.
“She follows this normal trajectory in the sense that she is a former Supreme Court Clerk, and she went to Harvard, right? Those are places that seem to be where you have to be from to get to the Supreme Court.”
“Now when I clerked at the Supreme Court, we still had justices that didn't go to Harvard or Yale for law school. But it's becoming increasingly narrowed,” Ms. Wildermuth said, noting that Justice Barrett, a Notre Dame graduate, is an exception, and highlighting that former justices, including Justice Stevens and Sandra Day O’Connor, attended Northwestern and Stanford, respectively.
However, where Judge Jackson breaks the mold is with her time as a public defender, Ms. Wildermuth said. Ms. Jackson worked as a federal public defender in Washington from 2005 to 2007.
“I think you're finding somebody who's truly dedicated to this public service and public orientation, again, with a deep understanding of the law, but also you know, a humanness that makes her a different kind of nominee,” said Ms. Wildermuth, who does not know Judge Jackson personally but who has sat in meetings with her for the American Bar Association’s Administrative Law Council. “... In part, this is a historic moment. The other thing is that she is truly outstanding. There's nothing that you could say about this individual that would make her unqualified, and I'm pretty picky.”
In 2013, President Barack Obama nominated Judge Jackson for the position of U.S. District Court Judge in Washington and she was confirmed by the Senate on a voice vote. She sat on the bench for seven years, during which time she ruled on cases related to environmental law, the Americans with Disabilities Act and more high-profile cases where she sided for and against the Trump administration.
“She is, in my view, a centrist if you look at her body of work to date,” Mr. Gormley said.
In 2021, Mr. Biden nominated Judge Jackson to fill the seat on the D.C. Circuit Court left vacant by his pick for U.S. Attorney General, Judge Merrick Garland.
Former and current justices who’ve sat on the D.C. Circuit include Chief Justice John Roberts as well as justices Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh and the late Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
During Judge Jackson’s brief time on the court, she joined an opinion confirming a lower court ruling that rejected former President Donald Trump’s request to block the release of documents and communication relating to the Capitol riots of Jan. 6, 2021.
The nomination process
Judge Jackson, 51, already has been evaluated by the Senate for her previous positions — most recently in June 2021, when three Republicans joined in voting for her confirmation to the D.C. Circuit. They included senators Susan Collins, R-Maine, Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., and Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska.
She is heading into the hearing process with a range of public declarations of support, including from victims advocates, various levels of law enforcement, former attorneys general and former Department of Justice officials.
Judge Jackson has spent recent weeks on Capitol Hill meeting with senators, who’ve declared through news media interviews their support or skepticism about her. Mr. Graham, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, says he will oppose her; Ms. Collins has praised her. Others say they plan to question her specifically about her role as a public defender on behalf of Guantanamo Bay detainees.
Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., is scheduled to meet with the nominee this week, according to his office.
The office of Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., said the lawmaker also plans to meet with Judge Jackson, but no date time frame was provided.
In a statement last month, the senator said he looks foward to “vetting her record to carefully consider her nomination to the nation’s highest court. Only the most qualified jurists who will diligently serve as neutral umpires of the law — not as unelected legislators with preferred policy outcomes — merit confirmation to serve as guardians of the Constitution and arbiters of our laws on the Supreme Court.”
Supreme Court nominations are shielded from the Senate’s 60-vote threshold; that’s because Democrats in 2013 and Republicans in 2017 made changes to the rules. And in the current 50-50 Senate, Vice President Kamala Harris can cast the tie-breaking vote.
While Supreme Court confirmation hearings in recent history have become “much more partisan,” Mr. Gormley said, he doesn’t see this one “turning into a bloody battle.”
“There's a lot of politics in this, but in the end, this is not going to change the liberal-conservative, Democrat-Republican balance of the court,” said Mr. Gormley, who does not know Judge Jackson personally but who has led students on seminars and programs joining together Duquesne University Law School students and Supreme Court justices.
“It is inevitable that President Biden is going to get a [Supreme Court] pick,” Mr. Gormley said. “Judge Jackson is about as solid as one could hope for from either party, and you got to keep your powder dry for the bigger fights. There will be a lot of words by opponents talking about why she isn't qualified or ‘we're going too fast’ or whatever, just to put it on the record. But you aren't going to see the sort of galvanizing of the troops to wage a war over this.”
Justice Breyer, 83, is expected to step down later this year. He was confirmed in 1994 with 87 votes.
The Senate Judiciary Committee will open the first of its four days of hearings on Monday at 11 a.m.
More can be found on Judge Jackson’s work and decisions from the bench on the Congressional Research Service website.
Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com.
Correction: A previous version of this article misstated for which Supreme Court justice Pitt Law Dean Amy Wildermuth clerked. She clerked for Justice John Paul Stevens.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.