Republican lawmakers whose election conspiracies were echoed by Capitol insurrectionists this past week might not face immediate consequences, but Democrats in Pennsylvania hope to punish them at the ballot box -— even if it takes a few years.

The television advertisements will write themselves, said local Democratic strategist Mike Mikus. There will be images of President Donald Trump's supporters ransacking the Capitol juxtaposed with clips of Republican leaders insisting that votes should be tossed out and the presidential election overturned.

If it's up to Democrats, the midterm elections -— traditionally successful for the political party that doesn't hold the White House —- will be miserable for Republicans in 2022.

"You can remind people over and over and all it does is damage their future prospects," Mr. Mikus said. "You may not get a victory per se -— a political victory in the immediate -— but you will lay the groundwork for victory in 2022."

Advertise with us

But while Democrats intend to use the invasion of the Capitol and the last few months of claims about election integrity as a rhetorical sledgehammer, some Republicans aim to convince Americans that the invaders were extremists who aren't representative of the mainstream GOP.

Sam DeMarco, chair of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, said nearly every GOP official he knows condemned Wednesday’s violence as unacceptable and indefensible, and that though Republicans may have a "black eye" in the short term, a few hundred people shouldn't give hundreds of thousands of normal Republicans a bad name.

"All the people that think this signals a death knell for the Republican Party are sadly mistaken," Mr. DeMarco said, alleging that some of the same Democrats who are calling for GOP political annihilation were silent while businesses were burned and looted last summer, and that the party survived politically after demonstrators occupied the Wisconsin Capitol in 2011.

Mr. Mikus countered that the Republican brand is on the "path of disappearing" because many mainstream Republicans embraced the arguments that extremists were espousing: that the election was stolen from Mr. Trump.

"That's why they're going to pay a major price," Mr. Mikus said of the Republicans.

Advertise with us

That price could be paid in statewide races in 2022, when Republicans will want to flip the Pennsylvania governor's seat and hold on to Pat Toomey's U.S. Senate seat upon his retirement, said Chris Borick, director of Muhlenberg College's Institute of Public Opinion.

Republicans who run statewide won't have the same geographic protections as those who run in their own home districts, Mr. Borick said. Those candidates may struggle to translate their primary platforms -— tailored for a crowd much more inclined to believe claims about election integrity — to a general election in a state that's rewarded moderates.

Though the midterms are two years out, campaigns seem to be starting earlier and earlier, Mr. Mikus said, and "every Republican that gets into every single race should be put on the spot from day one and repeatedly through the election on where they stood on this whole nonsense about false charges of a quote unquote 'stolen election.'"

Who should be held accountable, though, is a different conversation, and will likely be subject to a political war of words.

Not every Republican questioned the integrity of the election, Mr. Mikus said, but many did. Democrats should be selective about whom they go after, he added.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeMarco said the people who stormed the Capitol are the ones who are directly responsible. But he conceded that "the rhetoric from some of our leaders" hadn't been helpful. Members of the party didn't always base their rhetoric in fact, he said, and there were enough rank and file members willing to believe the claims and not dig deeply into the data.

"People have sent me all these videos and things detailing all this supposed fraud that took place in Pennsylvania, and upon everything that I've been able to do to investigate it, it's not there," Mr. DeMarco said. "It didn't happen."

Mr. DeMarco said many Republicans believed claims such as Mr. Trump being ahead on Election Night, then having the race stolen from him. The GOP chairman also cited beliefs by a group of Republican state legislators that Pennsylvania recorded 200,000 more votes than it had voters -— a claim Mr. Trump repeated at the rally before the Capitol breach.

Republicans should still pursue investigations about what happened in the election and any irregulartieis, Mr. DeMarco said, but they need to be truthful about the findings. He said he wants Democrats and independents to know that "we're a rational Republican Party and that we can indeed govern."

Mr. DeMarco scoffs at members of his own party who say he's a RINO -— Republican in Name Only —- for disagreeing with "what their perceived narrative is."

Advertise with us

"I ran a Tea Party for six years. I'm as conservative as they come," Mr. DeMarco said, taking issue with those who would say he's "spineless."

"I'll put my spine up against any of these folks," he added. "I just like to have the facts on my side."

What's happened the last few months might not hurt the GOP on the congressional level as much as Democrats hope, Mr. Borick said. Polling has shown that Pennsylvania Republicans have doubts about election integrity and have questioned the outcome, he added.

Jim Wertz, chair of the Erie County Democratic Committee, said he expects some Republicans to change their party registrations because of Wednesday's events and the rhetoric of the last few months. It might influence some Democrats to become candidates themselves, he added.

"It will be incumbent upon people like me and future candidates to make sure the voters remember this," Mr. Wertz said. "I think the images that people saw in the Capitol on Wednesday are not something they're soon likely to forget or set aside."

Advertise with us

Democrats say they’ll make sure of it.

"All ambitious people who decided to give speeches and jump on this and lie, this is going to be wrapped around their necks,” Mr. Mikus said. “It’s going to be an anchor for the remainder of their career, and it’s too late for them to apologize.”

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.