In June 2016, Donald Trump used an aluminum recycling plant in Monessen as a backdrop to unveil a trade agenda to “bring back” American manufacturing — ending his speech with a warning all too familiar to those who followed the real estate businessman in his upset bid for the White House: that his opponent represented a brand of Democratic politics reliant on “fear, futility and incompetence.”
Four years later, Mr. Trump’s trade wars have generated mixed reviews in the Pittsburgh region, even before the COVID-19 pandemic sent the economy into a tailspin. And now, it’s the Democrat in the race, former Vice President Joe Biden, who is trying to win over workers with his own trade and jobs plan, warning, too — at every opportunity he gets — that Mr. Trump’s fear, futility and incompetence will have irreversible effects on the U.S. if given another four years and exacerbate the pandemic.
The candidates’ appeal to communities that have been left behind and ravaged by the pandemic likely will be a determining factor in who wins Pennsylvania’s 20 electoral votes, a haul that experts say could be the ultimate decider of the entire contest this Tuesday. The election also comes in the midst of demonstrations and unrest in the state’s largest city, in response to the fatal police shooting of Walter Wallace, a 27-year-old Black man, earlier this week.
Promises
Mr. Trump said four years ago that he’d remember the “forgotten” men and women of towns like Monessen. One term in, and it’s promises made, promises kept, the incumbent says — pointing to the shape of the pre-pandemic economy, his ever-lasting fight against D.C. swamp creatures and his handling of a pandemic that he claims would have been much worse without his leadership.
Mr. Biden labels the president a grifter who cares more about Wall Street than the people of, say, Monessen, who are still struggling from the collapse of a steel industry that Mr. Trump didn’t bring back and who are suffering from a pandemic that Mr. Trump didn’t contain and are worse off than they were four years ago, when he and former President Barack Obama left office.
Read More
Who’s right ultimately will be left up to voters on Tuesday.
In Monessen, Mr. Trump’s trade policy hasn’t changed anything, its 28-year-old Democratic mayor said, because the city desperately needs infrastructure support for its crumbling roads, collapsing brick sewer lines and vacant buildings.
Only then can the city attract what Mayor Matt Sharrow sees as the future: businesses and startup companies that can — through the same access to roads, rail and rivers that made steel thrive — support Pittsburgh’s growing tech industry.
“We really need a shot in the arm,” Mr. Sharrow said from his desk in the city hall building this past week, adding that when “you have a city like this that lost thousands of jobs over the last few decades, there are a lot of pieces to pick up.”
Mr. Trump’s campaign has been aggressively pressing the issue in Western Pennsylvania in the final sprint toward Election Day, painting Mr. Biden as undermining jobs and being too cozy with China. Erica Owen, a political science professor at the University of Pittsburgh who studies globalization and organized labor, said Mr. Trump “identified something that mainstream politicians weren’t willing to say.”
“A lot of communities have been sort of devastated by these changes, and they want someone who’s going to do something about it,” Ms. Owen said.
The speech in Monessen was shaped by Peter Navarro, an economic adviser to the campaign who was tapped in 2017 to serve as the first-ever White House director of trade and manufacturing policy. The speech called for seven actions to boost manufacturing, including new import tariffs based on national security grounds. In March 2018, Mr. Trump imposed 25% tariffs on steel imports and 10% on aluminum imports in 2018.
Last month, Mr. Navarro’s team released a report showing ways he believes the policies worked in Pennsylvania, pointing to plant investments like U.S. Steel’s planned $1 billion upgrade of the Mon Valley Works.
“We laid the predicate in that speech by explaining how we’ve been ripped off by China,” Mr. Navarro said in a phone interview last week. “The tariffs really are the best defense of American workers against that kind of cheating.”
Gabe Hudock, founder of Alumisource, the operator of the Monessen plant Mr. Trump visited in 2016, said the tariffs had allowed him to invest millions into new equipment. His business has boomed with a rise in aluminum scrap that was previously going to Chinese plants.
Mr. Trump “went through the Rust Belt and he essentially highlighted why these places are decimated,” Mr. Hudock said. “His visit was extremely powerful and his trade policies have helped substantially.”
Economists and industry analysts have disagreed the tariffs have been good for the wider economy.
The steel and aluminum tariffs were a “sugar rush” that temporarily boosted prices in 2018 but wore off the following year, said Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing, a coalition in Washington founded by the United Steelworkers and American manufacturers.
The Pittsburgh region was posting annual manufacturing job losses in 2019, before the pandemic hit. Processing plants — like Allegheny Technologies Inc.’s Midland plant, NLMK Pennsylvania near New Castle and CP Industries in McKeesport — have struggled to cover the costs of imports. ATI shut down its facility in March, citing the tariffs.
“The steel industry was struggling, frankly, even with the 25 percent tariff in place,” said Tom Conway, international president of the United Steelworkers. While Mr. Trump deserves some credit for tariffs, Mr. Conway said, “he did it such a ham-fisted way that we alienated a lot of our allies round the world,” like Canada, Europe and Australia.
Mr. Biden’s plan appealed to Mr. Conway and the union’s leadership, which endorsed the candidate this year. Mr. Conway pointed to Mr. Biden’s specific plans to build a supply chain, invest in infrastructure and vocational jobs training, and rebuilding global alliances to “surgically” tackle unfair trade issues.
Union leadership, which saw rank-and-file members defect from its endorsement of Hillary Clinton in 2016, held a series of town hall meetings at 170 locations around the country beginning in January, Mr. Conway said. They got feedback from members through a questionnaire — the same survey the union sent to Mr. Biden and Mr. Trump. (Mr. Trump did not respond to the union’s survey.)
Mr. Biden’s response was “comprehensive” and “thoughtful,” Mr. Conway said.
Multiple crises
Reminiscent of the “fear, futility and incompetence” that Mr. Trump warned his 2016 opponent would foster, Mr. Biden has based much of his campaign telling voters that the president’s COVID-19 response has been incompetent and futile, while his rhetoric around the racial injustice movement in recent months has served only to stoke fear and divide people.
This comes as Pennsylvania is embroiled in multiple crises, averaging more than 2,000 new cases of COVID-19 per day over the last week and — in Philadelphia — seeing a rash of looting and violence in wake of the killing by police of Mr. Wallace.
On the virus, Mr. Trump has insisted the U.S. is “rounding the corner” and that his administration is containing it, while Mr. Biden has foreshadowed a “dark winter ahead.”
State health officials tend to agree with the Democrat’s analysis. Secretary of Health Rachel Levine said recently the state is seeing the beginnings of a second wave — or a “fall resurgence,” as she calls it. Officials say daily case increases are comparable to what it recorded in April.
Presiding over a union of about 45,000 health care workers who have been deeply engaged in the election, Matthew Yarnell, president of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania, said that not only is the country not “rounding the corner” on the pandemic, but that it’s illuminated flaws in the health care system that have long existed and need to be fixed.
Mr. Yarnell said Mr. Trump could have implemented a national strategy so states wouldn’t have to fight the pandemic on their own, but didn’t — and that he could be working with both chambers of Congress right now to push for the kind of relief workers need most, but isn’t.
U.S. Rep. John Joyce, R-Blair, a doctor and Republican supporting Mr. Trump’s re-election, credited the president for responding appropriately to the virus, given the information that was known at different points in the virus’s progression across America. He cited Mr. Trump restricting travel from China in February.
“Had the president not taken that action, the death rate from the coronavirus would have been multiples higher than it is right now,” Dr. Joyce said.
On whether the country is rounding the corner on COVID-19, Dr. Joyce said because of the “innovations that President Trump” has brought — including an FDA-approved treatment for patients with pulmonary effects amid his operation Warp Speed initiative to quickly produce a vaccine — a person diagnosed this week with the virus has a “much greater success rate of coming through” than they would have six months ago. Mortality rates have decreased, he said.
A vaccine, Dr. Joyce added, is “right around the corner” because of the public-private partnerships Mr. Trump has encouraged.
There are fundamental differences between Mr. Trump’s plan — or lack thereof, as Democrats allege — and Mr. Biden’s. Notably, Mr. Biden is calling for a system of widespread contact tracing and a seven-fold increase in weekly testing, Mr. Yarnell noted — with the goal of speeding up the results of lab-based diagnostic testing, for one.
Only then, after those measures are in place, federal and state governments are encouraged to work together and the full power of the Defense Production Act is utilized, can the U.S. get its economy running again, Mr. Biden has said. Mr. Trump, meanwhile, warns his opponent wants to “lock down your country.”
While Dr. Joyce insists the president continues to look at the pandemic from “many different angles” and weighs data from scientists, Mr. Yarnell alleged that Mr. Trump is feeding conspiracy theories that have ultimately led to people losing their lives, and that it’s incredibly disrespectful to communicate to the American people about the virus that way when his union’s nursing workers “have watched dozens of their residents they cared for for many years die on a shift.”
“To downplay this virus and be unclear in what we need to do to get out of it — and to be resistant to having a national strategy — is irresponsible and it is causing people to lose their lives,” Mr. Yarnell said.
State Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta, a legislator in Philadelphia who spoke at the Democratic National Convention and has campaigned for Mr. Biden, pointed out, too, that COVID-19 has had a disproportionate impact on Black and brown communities, and alluded to research that has shown more than 40% of Black-owned businesses have closed for good since the start of the pandemic. He applauded the former vice president for wanting to invest in those businesses.
In Philadelphia, the fight for racial justice that has continued in the streets for months has one again erupted in recent days in response to fatal shooting by police of Mr. Wallace — and Mr. Trump has used the looting and rioting in the aftermath to continue his campaign messaging that Democrats are undertaking a “war against the police” and standing with “the rioters and the vandals” instead of law enforcement.
Mr. Kenyatta said he does think what’s happening in Philadelphia will impact the election, but in a way that engages more people into the political process who recognize it is “unacceptable to have black and brown folks mowed down by police officers in the street, extrajudicially, and it happens again and again and again.”
“If our system of locking everybody up, arming our police officers like they’re in Fallujah or somewhere — if that made us safer, we would be the safest place in the world by far,” Mr. Kenyatta said. “It has not made us safer.”
U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, who recently joined the president in the Oval Office with two other Republicans to talk about the GOP''s commitment to making sure good officers have resources while increasing accountability, deemed Mr. Trump a "leader" on criminal justice reform. He said Mr. Trump has taken executive action to "promote best policing practices, hold bad actors accountable and increase transparency to foster strong bonds between police officers and the communities they serve and protect."
"Voters in Pennsylvania want law and order, not lawlessness and destruction, and they know President Trump is the candidate of law and order," said Mr. Reschenthaler, R-Peters, alleging that Mr. Biden's policies "will leave our communities unprotected" and that Mr. Trump "signed into law "the largest reforms to our criminal justice system in generations."
Mr. Biden’s agenda would make people safer, Mr. Kenyatta said, by instituting a national use-of-force standard and looking at how state and federal government can impact what local law enforcement is doing.
There is an understanding by almost everybody except for the president that our current system of policing is not accomplishing its core function, which is to keep people safe,” Mr. Kenyatta said, noting that while he’s not saying there aren’t good police officers, the system is broken and the criminal justice system needs to be reformed.
It's also about dealing with the root cause of issues that make communities less safe, Mr. Kenyatta said, alleging that Mr. Trump isn’t talking about poverty or education — the types of things that lead to less lives lost and making communities safer holistically.
A little help
In Monessen, Mr. Sharrow, the young mayor, cherishes the past, while holding a visionary future — but he needs help from both parties in Washington.
Mr. Sharrow, who was elected shortly after Mr. Trump took office, protested Mr. Trump’s visit across the street from the plant four years ago. But when he tried to organize a campaign stop in Monessen for Hillary Clinton, he got no help from the Democratic National Committee.
People “want to be heard, and if you show up, that shows that you care,” Mr. Sharrow said, deeming that one of the missteps Democrats made in 2016.
His office is filled with framed vintage postcards, maps and a painted portrait of him standing next to an historic grocery building he has sought to protect from demolition.
He even designed the city a new flag, still unofficial for now, whose design and symbolism evoke Essen, Germany, an industrial town that for decades had one of the largest coke plants in Europe. After Essen’s coke plant closed in 1993, it was turned into a public museum and a popular tourist attraction.
But the flag’s Latin motto suggests an almost defiant yearning to be seen for something else: “A city on a hill cannot be ignored.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore. Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.