With President Donald Trump spending his entire day in Pennsylvania, and Democrat Joe Biden bringing his former boss and the nation’s first Black president to Michigan, the race for the White House hammered two states on Saturday that had been blue since the 1980s before Mr. Trump came along and flipped them both four years ago.

Their choice of travel three days before Tuesday’s presidential election underscores the importance of Pennsylvania’s 20 electoral votes and Michigan’s 16 to who wins the White House, and gave the candidates the opportunity to pitch their closing messages to different voting blocs.

Mr. Trump, the incumbent Republican, bounced from rallies in Newtown and Reading in the afternoon before ending the evening in Butler and Montoursville, Lycoming County, a full day of travel that was spent mostly in counties that he won in 2016 en route to carrying the state by about 44,000 votes.

Meanwhile, Barack Obama, the nation’s 44th president, and Mr. Biden, his vice president who wants to be the 46th, held drive-in rallies in Flint and Detroit, predominantly Black cities where strong turnout will be essential to swing the longtime Democratic state to Biden’s column after Trump won it in 2016.

Advertise with us

“Three days until the most important election of our lifetime — and that includes mine, which was pretty important,” Mr. Obama said, urging Democrats to get to the polls.

The memories of Mr. Trump’s win in Michigan and Pennsylvania are still searing in the minds of many Democrats during this closing stretch. That leaves Mr. Biden in the position of holding a consistent lead in the national polls and an advantage in most battlegrounds, including Pennsylvania, yet still facing anxiety it could all slip away.

At his four rallies here, Mr. Trump ran through the greatest hits of his run for re-election, pinning Mr. Biden as a globalist who has spent his career “[twisting] his knife into the backs of Pennsylvania workers” and selling out the United States to foreign countries, and he — Mr. Trump — the ultimate savior.

Focusing mostly on economic issues, Mr. Trump largely promised a continuation of his first term in office if he wins again, saying he will continue to bring back jobs to the U.S., cut taxes and regulations and ensure more products are made here.

Warning his supporters that Mr. Biden would shut down the economy again, Mr. Trump said the election is a choice between that option, or the “greatest economic year in the history of our country.” Under Mr. Biden, Pennsylvania would be sent into a “deep and catastrophic depression,” the president said — and the people should opt instead for a “Trump boom.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Biden has focused almost exclusively on the president’s inability to control the pandemic, and said Saturday in Flint, “We’re gonna beat this virus and get it under control and the first step to doing that is beating Donald Trump.” That came after Mr. Obama called the Democrat his “brother,” and accused Mr. Trump of failing to take the coronavirus pandemic and the presidency seriously.

Mr. Trump talked at length about the virus that infected more than 99,000 Americans on Friday, a record high, according to Johns Hopkins University. He said the U.S. is rounding the corner, and that a vaccine is only weeks away and will be mass distributed.

In a statement issued before Mr. Trump’s rallies, Mr. Biden said thousands of lives in Pennsylvania have been lost because of Mr. Trump’s refusal to take COVID-19 seriously “or be honest with the American people about the reality of the virus.” The former vice president added that he will listen to public health experts so the U.S. can safely reopen its schools and economy.

Mr. Trump, saying that the economy is growing at the fastest rate ever recorded and that he built a “strong foundation” before the pandemic, warned — as he always does here — that a Biden administration would ban fracking and decimate Pennsylvania’s economy.

This time, his warnings were dressed in theatrics. At his Butler rally, he said he had just signed an order on Marine Force One that would “protect Pennsylvania fracking and block any effort to undermine energy production in your state.” Labeling himself a defender of American energy independence, the president also showed a video of Mr. Biden’s past statements on fracking.

Advertise with us

“Biden’s plan is an economic death sentence for Pennsylvania,” Mr. Trump said. “He will outlaw fracking and eradicate your great economy.”

Mr. Biden has sought to clarify his position in recent months, insisting that he does not want to shut down oil fields or eliminate fracking, but invest in clean energy and ensure “we don’t continue to subsidize the oil companies,” he told reporters this past week.

In his statement before the rallies, Mr. Biden said Mr. Trump has broken his promises to Pennsylvania’s working families.

“Pennsylvanians see these failures every day in the factories that have closed down in their town, in the empty chair at their kitchen table, and in the stack of medical bills that they are unable to pay,” Mr. Biden said.

Mr. Trump foreshadowed a win in Pennsylvania this Tuesday that will “save the American dream,” noting that they chose to elect an outsider in 2016 and will do it again.

Advertise with us

“We’re going to have a historic day. I really believe that, just based on what’s going on throughout all these other states,” Mr. Trump said, “but we win Pennsylvania, we win it all. You know that, right?”

“If we win Pennsylvania, it’s over,” the president added.

Though he wasn’t here in person on Saturday, Mr. Biden’s campaign kept its focus on Pennsylvania, mobilizing an apparatus of get-out-the-vote events that included several in Western Pennsylvania featuring some of the area’s top Democratic officials. Former presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg was here to campaign, U.S. Reps. Mike Doyle and Conor Lamb kicked off canvasses and Democrats, celebrities and musicians held a virtual concert to excite the base.

On Sunday, Mr. Biden will hold two events in Philadelphia, while Mr. Trump rallies in Michigan, Iowa, North Carolina, Georgia and Florida.

Then, on the day before the election, the Democratic ticket, along with their spouses, will hit all four corners of Pennsylvania. There were reports that the campaign would make reported stops in Homewood and on the North Shore. Mr. Trump’s last full day of campaigning will include a rally in Scranton, as well as visits to North Carolina, Michigan and Wisconsin. Vice President Mike Pence will rally in Latrobe and Erie that day.

The Associated Press contributed reporting. Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.