WASHINGTON — A two-day deliberation began in a hotel conference room in Arlington, Va., with all the appearances of bureaucratic sausage-making. Committee members walked through a lengthy agenda full of technical analyses, taking occasional short breaks before diving back in.
By going through the formal motions, the meeting was a remarkable protest.
The group of 20 air quality experts who met on Thursday were recruited years ago to draw up health-based recommendations to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on fine particulate matter — a sooty pollutant known with a long history in the Pittsburgh region.
But last year, the EPA disbanded the review panel without any prior notice, calling it an impediment to meeting legal deadlines.
Many of the scientists, who discovered the news in an EPA press release in October 2018, were outraged that the Trump administration would close the door on a health-based review for a pollutant that threatens the health of millions of Americans and is the subject of quickly evolving scientific study.
This week — organized by the Union of Concerned Scientists and panel chair H. Christopher Frey, an engineering professor at North Carolina State University — the panel was resolved to submit its recommendations anyway.
Read More
“While the [five-year] schedule is a matter of law, it’s also matter of law that these have to be science-based reviews,” Mr. Frey said during a discussion of the review process.
He added the review’s delays have “nothing to do with the panels and have everything to do with EPA and how it manages the review.”
Peter Adams, an air quality expert who teaches engineering and public policy at Carnegie Mellon University, jumped at the opportunity to join the EPA’s panel.
In an interview before the panel meeting, Mr. Adams called fine particulate matter, or soot with particles measuring 2.5 microns, “arguably the single most important [air pollutant] because most of the health impacts and damage that come from air pollution come from pm-2.5.”
Particulate matter is one of six major air pollutants governed by the National Ambient Air Quality Standards, which set countrywide caps on the concentrations allowed to be released in the atmosphere. The EPA is required by the Clean Air Act to review those standards every five years on particulate matter, as well as carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, lead and ozone.
Mr. Adams, who moved to the Pittsburgh region in 2001, credited the standards for helping to dramatically clean up the region's air quality and save thousands of lives.
“It’s the indirect lever that really pushes a lot of air quality regulation in the United States,” he said.
The current national annual standard for fine particulate matter is 12 micrograms per cubic meter. The standard was last updated in 2012, lowered from the previously allowable 15 micrograms per cubic meter by the Obama administration’s EPA. It was previously changed in 1997.
If regions of the country are found to exceed the standard, local officials must draft a plan to come into compliance.
Mr. Adams said he sees evidence the standard may need tightened again.
“My personal opinion — and this is widely shared amongst scientific community — is that, even at concentrations below the 12 micrograms per cubic meter that is the current standard, there’s still significant public health risk,” he said in the interview. “That’s the type of thing that’s normally discussed during the review.”
Particulate matter has long been a concern in Pittsburgh, with the American Lung Association listing the region’s air quality among the lowest in the country year after year. The Allegheny County Health Department last month submitted a plan to comply with the EPA’s fine particulate matter standards.
The EPA’s scientific review “kind of drives everything that happens around air pollution,” said Myron Arnowitt, Pennsylvania state director for Clean Water Action.
The law only requires the EPA to hear guidance from a seven-member group, known as the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee. But for decades, that committee has gathered insight from ad hoc panels consisting of a couple dozen top experts in each specific pollutant. Those panels are common practice — but not required by law.
The EPA’s own notice in 2015 seeking experts to sit on the particulate matter panel shows the range and depth of experience. It states: “Experts are sought in: air quality and climate responses, atmospheric science and chemistry, dosimetry, toxicology, controlled clinical exposure, epidemiology, biostatistics, human exposure modeling, risk assessment/modeling, characterization of PM concentrations and light extinction, and visibility impairment and related welfare effects.”
“These panels have become very crucial for EPA to set a scientific standard,” said Gretchen Goldman, a research director for the Union of Concerned Scientists. “It’s really a remarkable deal for taxpayers because you’re getting 20 of the top experts in the world on a particular pollutant.”
In October 2018, the EPA abruptly announced the panels were done.
Last month, EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler testified to Congress that the review process had become “never-ending” and that “it’s our intention to get it done on time.”
“We disbanded the subcommittees to meet the five-year requirement,” Mr. Wheeler told the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology during a hearing last month.
An EPA spokeswoman said in a statement the agency is “committed to scientific integrity and transparency” and “routinely takes comments from the public and outside organizations, including those not employed or associated with EPA, and will continue to take into consideration those comments that meet our scientific standards.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.