Allegheny County Health Dept. holds hearing about U.S. Steel Corp. settlement for emissions violations at its Clairton Coke Works

A proposed agreement to settle longstanding air pollution problems at U.S. Steel Corp.’s Clairton Coke Works is either a big step toward achieving cleaner air in the Mon Valley or a step backward, depending on which of the more than 40 speakers was in front of the microphone during a public hearing that packed the Clairton Municipal Building Tuesday evening.

Mike Rhoads, Clairton plant manager, testified in support of the settlement, saying the facility has fully complied with the terms of the county enforcement orders and its new investment commitments will enable it to further reduce emissions at its three Mon Valley Works facilities in Clairton, Edgar Thomson in Braddock and Irvin in West Mifflin.

“The settlement agreement is a positive step for all stakeholders,” Mr. Rhoads said, as union members in the crowd of 200 applauded, “and represents the benefit that can be achieved by the regulatory agency, communities and industry working together.”

The proposed agreement would require the Pittsburgh-based steelmaker to pay penalties totaling $2.73 million to settle four enforcement actions dating to June 2018. It would also commit the company to spending about $200 million to improve operation of the facility's coke batteries, including upgrades to emissions controls, plant infrastructure and maintenance.

Advertise with us

Maury Burgwin, president of the Mon Yough Area Chamber of Commerce, said it will address air pollution issues while allowing the company to “move forward as an asset for the region.”

But Matt Mehalik, executive director of the Breathe Project, reading from comments submitted by 13 local, state and national environmental organizations, said the agreement is vague and isn’t strong enough to ensure unhealthy emissions violations won’t happen again.

The organizations’ joint, seven-page public comment letter states that the penalties contained in the draft settlement announced June 28 by the Allegheny County Health Department could be viewed as a “pay to pollute arrangement” — a point raised by multiple speakers at the hearing.

The groups also say in their comments that the proposed agreement “doesn’t go far enough” in specifying investment in major new pollution controls to end recurring air pollution violations at the nation’s biggest coke-making facility.

“The $200 million in promised investments should be spelled out in the deal so the company can’t back out but it isn’t,” Mr. Mehalik said. “And the civil penalty assessed is too low.”

Advertise with us

The environmental organizations say in their written comments the penalty totals just 0.25% of U.S. Steel’s net earnings of $1.1 billion last year and 0.02% of its $14.1 billion in revenue.

The organizations say the low penalties are no deterrent, and it’s less expensive for the company to keep paying fines instead of paying to upgrade old, leaky coke-making equipment.

“We believe that this agreement should require U.S. Steel to shut down and repair old coking batteries that cannot operate lawfully,” the organizations say in their comment letter, “because penalty fined do not appear to be a sufficient deterrent to stopping emissions violations.”

Emissions from the Clairton facility have been a focal point for clean air activists since a fire on Dec. 24 destroyed its pollution control system and resulted in the plant operating for 100 days without the desulfurization equipment.

Dr. Deborah Gentile testified that she recently reviewed local health system data showing the number of acute asthma visits to outpatient clinics and emergency hospital facilities nearly doubled after the fire.

Advertise with us

“The air pollution problem in our region is unacceptable,” Dr. Gentile said. “These results clearly show an increased risk of acute asthma visits among residents following the fire and during subsequent air pollution exceedances.”

Coke is used to produce iron and steel. Clairton's 10 coke batteries contain 708 coke ovens and more than 6,300 potential coke gas emission points. The facility employs 1,200, and each year produces about 4.3 million tons of coke.

The organizations say they support parts of the agreement that stipulate repairs and upgrades must be made at the coking facility, but also say the draft agreement’s two- to five-year timelines for completing the improvements are too long and should be shortened to 12 to 18 months to protect the health of nearby residents.

Dr. Karen Hacker, director of the health department, noted in June that the settlement agreement was a compromise and the department did not get the company to agree to everything it wanted, including replacements of several coke oven batteries.

The proposed settlement, originally announced June 28, allows the company to use 90% of the penalty it will pay to establish a "Community Benefit Trust" to fund projects benefiting the environment and the Mon Valley communities of Clairton, Glassport, Liberty, Lincoln and Port Vue.

Advertise with us

The settlement requires U.S. Steel to pay the remainder of the money, $273,000, to the county's Clean Air Fund.

Several speakers questioned whether the company would control the trust, but several company employees said it will be administered independently and transparently.

The environmental groups endorse the trust concept and its goal of using penalty money for projects that improve the health of Mon Valley residents, but say it should be administered by a community foundation, not the company.

U.S. Steel also agreed to provide enhanced environmental training programs for its coke works employees and submit to annual emissions audits by an independent contractor. And it recently established a community advisory panel, made up of residents, a company representative and an elected official, to address environmental and health concerns of the Mon Valley communities.

Mr. Rhoads said the panel will “facilitate better communication between the company and surrounding communities.”

Advertise with us

As its part of the proposed agreement, the health department, which issues operating permits and enforces emissions controls on the county's last coking facility, agreed to update, revise and improve its inspection and testing procedures at the coke works, located along the Monongahela River 20 miles south of Pittsburgh.

The agreement also contains a provision that the health department may only impose more stringent emissions limits that are "technically feasible. . . achievable and maintainable."

The environmental groups say in their comments that this provision unnecessarily restrains the health department’s regulatory authority and should be eliminated from the agreement.

While U.S. Steel agreed to settle the county penalties, the agreement notes that the company "has denied and continues to deny the violations" and is agreeing to pay the penalty amounts "solely to settle disputed claims without incurring the time and expense of additional contested litigation."

The full draft agreement can be found at https://www.alleghenycounty.us/Health-Department/Programs/Air-Quality/Public-Comment-Notices.aspx.

Advertise with us

Health department officials will review the comments.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1983. Twitter: @donhopey.