WASHINGTON — As the Federal Communications Commission tees up $20 billion in funding to build out broadband in the next decade, the government’s underlying method of directing that money remains “frustratingly inconsistent and unreliable,” the head of an organization of rural independent telecom companies told a congressional panel on Wednesday.
The comments — made by Shirley Bloomfield, CEO of NTCA-The Rural Broadband Association — were echoed by five other telecom industry officials and advocates who urged lawmakers to reform the FCC’s data collection requirements to improve the accuracy of maps showing which areas still lack broadband.
That task has been taken up by Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, a member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee and chair of its Subcommittee on Communications and Technology. Mr. Doyle called Wednesday’s hearing before the subcommittee to hear from experts on a package of five bills that aim to address a long-standing problem of reaching the 21 million people without broadband access.
“Accurate maps of who does and who doesn’t have access to broadband are a critical first step in closing the digital divide,” Mr. Doyle said. “We can’t hope to solve this problem if we don’t know the scope of the problem are where to put our resources.”
Put together, the bills would require the FCC to collect and disseminate far more granular broadband data, allow the commission to use crowdsourced feedback on coverage areas and establish a new office to serve as central command center for mapping efforts. They would also make it illegal to knowingly file false broadband information and create a system by which private and public entities could challenge data submitted to the commission.
The FCC did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday, but it has taken steps to improve its maps.
Read More
In August, the five-member commission voted unanimously to dole out more than $20 billion of Universal Service Fund subsidies over the next 10 years as part of the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund.
The commission also approved a proposal aimed at better collecting information from broadband providers to improve its coverage maps. Broadband providers will have to report broadband access data in the shapefile format, which is a geospatial format widely used in geographic information system, or GIS, software.
Currently, the FCC asks providers to report coverage information that fits into Census-derived blocks — areas that can range from a city block to a sweeping area of rural farmland. By that system, an entire Census block could be classified as served by broadband even if only one household has access.
Discussion of the new file format consumed much of the hearing that lasted more than two hours.
“Shapefiles will allow network providers to draw boundaries around their service areas based on what they know — based on the places they are, the places their lines run, the place they offer service,” said James Assey, executive vice president of NCTA-The Internet and Television Association. (Though it has a similar name, the group is unrelated to the rural broadband association.)
“I think being able to rely on a provider to draw the boundaries of where it can serve will lead to more accurate results,” he said.
Mr. Assey added that Congress should craft data requests as precisely as possible, because extraneous requests “would only muddy the waters, increase costs and could delay funding to underserved areas.”
“The FCC already collects a wealth of data from broadband providers,” Mr. Assey said.
Ms. Bloomfield, of the rural broadband association, said she supports allowing members of the public to view and challenge the quality of the reporting. Even with better reporting, crowdsourcing could be a way to address gaps.
“If the carrier is reporting something, what we want to know is, on the ground, is that what’s happening?” Ms. Bloomfield said. “You can allow consumers on the ground to give some feedback.”
The five bills have been referred to the Committee on Energy and Commerce. All the lawmakers on the subcommittee expressed confidence on Wednesday the bills can become law.
Last year, a Penn State University researcher argued the FCC maps greatly understated the number of Pennsylvania households at 800,000 without broadband access.
The digital divide is “going to hit Pennsylvania like a tsunami,” said the researcher, Sascha Meinrath, at a conference Downtown.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.