WASHINGTON — Amid a wave of building projects throughout the Pittsburgh region, construction firms have managed to find skilled workers — despite historically low unemployment and an aging workforce — thanks to a 70-year-old workforce program: the humble apprenticeship.
Now, the Trump administration wants to expand more apprenticeships to other industries like health care, education and technology. In doing so, however, it has spurred debate over the role of labor unions and how to maintain pay and benefits for apprentices while giving more companies flexibility.
The debate is seen most prominently in the construction industry itself.
Builders in the Pittsburgh region — which fund and manage apprenticeships through a partnership of companies and more than a dozen trade unions — want nothing to do with the new apprenticeship rules proposed by the U.S. Department of Labor.
The new rules “won’t have the same scrutiny that the tried-and-true apprenticeships programs already have,” said Jack Ramage, executive director of the Master Builders’ Association of Western Pennsylvania. “We just think it’s short-cutting the apprenticeship programs that are already in place.”
The Labor Department, which accepted public comments on the rules through Monday, wants to create an entirely new system of “industry-recognized” apprenticeship programs. Programs would be registered with a network of, essentially, accreditation bodies that would maintain standards and perform oversight.
Read More
The joint apprenticeship model in Pittsburgh and other cities has worked well for years, the region’s construction officials argue.
An apprenticeship is an arrangement by which workers earn a salary as they take training courses in addition to working shifts. Its success can be seen in 16 gleaming training centers in the Pittsburgh region that teach a new generation of carpenters, operating engineers, steamfitters, boilermakers, electricians and other trades.
And, so far, the Labor Department’s rules have excluded the construction industry, in a nod to that history.
But the Associated General Contractors of America, a Virginia-based national trade group that also represents Pittsburgh-area builders’ interests in Washington, is pushing for the department to let construction companies apply for the “industry-recognized” programs.
The organization argues tens of thousands of nonunion apprenticeship programs could benefit from new rules.
“Whether it’s unionized or open shop, we want to see the same access to creating high-quality apprenticeship programs ... that currently exist in markets like Pittsburgh,” said Jim Young, the group’s senior director of Congressional relations. “Right now, it’s too difficult in too many places for firms who aren’t in partnerships with unions to get certified.”
“It’s not for lack of quality or rigor,” Mr. Young added. Some regions favor apprentices from union programs or otherwise discriminate against nonunion contractors in the project bidding process. The organization went to court against a San Diego school district in 2009 that considered union apprentices first for projects.
The debate over how to grow apprenticeships comes as they have gained popularity amid the rising cost of college and as job-seekers try to connect with companies amid a sea change in skills.
Currently, new apprenticeship programs are registered through the U.S. Department of Labor or state agencies and follow standard guidelines. In 2016, Gov. Tom Wolf created Pennsylvania’s Apprenticeship and Training Office and allocated $7 million with the goal of doubling the number of apprentices in the state to 30,000 workers.
“We do not believe the quality of instruction, standards of safety, family-sustaining wages, portability, and career-focused employment that registered apprenticeship delivers are preserved,” a spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry said in a statement on Wednesday.
Smaller manufacturers in the Pittsburgh region have experimented with apprenticeships, and Nazareth College and Career Prep in Emsworth started the region’s first “pre-apprenticeship” program for high school students last year.
President Donald Trump signed an executive order in June 2017 to draft new regulations with the goal of increasing the number of apprentices to five million — up from 500,000 at that time.
Jeff Nobers, executive director of the Builders Guild of Western Pennsylvania, said in an interview and in public comments that the rules would damage apprenticeships.
The rules serve as “a very inexpensive way for contractors to acquire apprentices” and “almost tries to non-unionize” the industry, Mr. Nobers said. “It would turn the clock back decades, even centuries, on how people are trained in the construction industry.”
He said he feared federal training dollars could flood in to fund competing apprenticeships that could have lower standards. The Pittsburgh region’s jointly funded construction apprenticeships use virtually no government money, he said, instead collecting a small part of an apprentice’s paycheck for training funds.
Apprenticeships registered with the “industry-recognized” system would only require companies to pay apprentices the minimum wage, while Pittsburgh-area apprentices start at $16 an hour on the low end, Mr. Nobers said.
In comments to the Labor Department this month, Mr. Nobers wrote: “There is one overwhelming question on our minds: Why and how does it make sense to disrupt, damage and perhaps ultimately destroy the registered apprenticeship programs, which have a 70-plus year record of success in our industry?”
Mr. Ramage said he understood the Associated General Contractors of America viewed the rule as a way to boost apprenticeships everywhere.
“They’re looking at it strictly as a way to get more people into the construction industry ... They’re not looking at it from the standpoint of doing it the right way,” Mr. Ramage said. “Frankly, I think they’re being short-sighted in that position.”
Mr. Young said the contractors trade group is urging the same standards for all types of programs.
The public comment period closed on Monday, and the department can adjust the rule based on that feedback.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.