About 100 former federal prosecutors and Justice Department officials, including a former U.S. attorney in Pittsburgh and a former appellate judge here, have signed a letter expressing dismay over FBI Director James Comey’s decision to tell Congress about emails pertaining to Hillary Clinton.

The group said the release of such information so close to an election is a breach of Justice Department standards and could influence the outcome. The Comey letter has many who know him and have worked with him wondering why he did it.

One of them is Harry Litman, a California lawyer who served as U.S. attorney in Pittsburgh from 1998 to 2001. He signed the letter.

“I respect Director Comey a great deal,” he said, “but I think it was a bad misjudgment to lob a grenade into the middle of a presidential election, which is what the [Comey] letter did. There are longstanding Department of Justice policies of non-interference in elections, and the episode illustrates why those policies are in place. It was especially unfortunate that he sent the letter without having even assessed the significance of the material.”

Advertise with us

Tim Lewis, a former assistant U.S. attorney in Pittsburgh and later a U.S. District Judge and member of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, also signed the letter.

“We should all be deeply concerned when the FBI director inserts himself into the electoral process on the eve of a national election,” he said. “I signed the letter because, wittingly or not, Director Comey has allowed himself to become another potential threat to our imperiled democracy.”

Mr. Lewis said Mr. Comey should make a statement clarifying whether the FBI is aware of any new information that would support a different conclusion from the one it reached in July regarding Ms. Clinton’s emails. Mr. Comey said publicly then that he would recommend no charges be brought against her.

In the letter, which was circulated by the Clinton campaign, the prosecutors said they respect Mr. Comey but were “astonished and perplexed” by his actions.

They said they couldn’t recall another instance where a Justice Department official, Republican or Democrat, issued a public statement on the eve of an election that could impact the result.

Advertise with us

The letter also cited the lack of details about the emails, which came from a computer owned by former Rep. Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y., who is under investigation on allegations that he sent sexual texts to a minor. Mr. Weiner is the estranged husband of Clinton aide Huma Abedin.

“We do not question Director Comey’s motives,” the letter said. “However, the fact remains that the director’s disclosure has invited considerable, uninformed public speculation about the significance of newly-discovered material just days before a national election.”

Some of those who signed the letter questioned whether Mr. Comey violated the Hatch Act, which prohibits executive branch employees from engaging in political activity.

Attorney Laurel Branstetter, who wasn’t among those who signed the letter, said she was shocked by Mr. Comey’s disclosure. Ms. Branstetter is a former prosecutor in the state attorney general’s office who prosecuted state officials.

“Stuff happens all the time that you would love to say, ‘You are about to re-elect somebody who is under investigation!’ “ she said. “The citizen in you would very much like to do that, but you don’t because they are cloaked in a presumption of innocence, and as a prosecutor you have enormous power” to harm reputations.

Advertise with us

She said Mr. Comey, having made a public disclosure already this summer, might have felt he had an obligation to notify Congress, but that the announcement was premature.

“ ‘We have a laptop’ does not mean we have permission to search it, or that we’ve searched it and found something,” she said. “I certainly would have waited until I had authority to look at it.”

Although the fact that the case involves a presidential candidate seems to make it carry more weight, she said that “as a prosecutor, if you’re really doing your job, you can’t pick and choose which instances a law applies to. You can’t follow the Hatch Act only when it’s a minor race.”

Meanwhile, other developments Monday rekindled questions about Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump. His former campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, is the subject of a preliminary FBI inquiry into any connections to Russia, NBC reported, citing unidentified officials.

The NBC report came one day after Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid alleged that Mr. Comey was concealing known connections between the Trump campaign and the Russian government.

Advertise with us

Mr. Manafort, who reportedly had financial ties to a pro-Russia party in Ukraine, denied the report.

The White House accused Russia this month of leaking Democratic emails, which Mr. Putin has denied.

Officials say that so far they haven’t found any link between Mr. Trump and Moscow. And even the hacking into Democratic emails, officials now believe, was aimed at disrupting the presidential election rather than electing Mr. Trump.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com  Tribune News Service, The New York Times and Los Angeles Times contributed.